- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed StyledSteets, which is a multi-style 3D Gaussian street simulator for instruction-driven editing. The main contributios include: rigid camera-vehicle pose optimization, DINO-based uncertainty-aware supervision, and unified style-conditioned gaussian model. The experimental results demonstrate good performance, and the overall evaluation is relatively comprehensive.
Critical strengths
- This paper not only enables multi-style driving scene editing, but also attempts to demonstrate that the edited driving scenes retain sufficient 3D structure and temporal information to actually improve downstream autonomous driving tasks.
- The paper proposed an explicit solution to improve reconstruction quality. The physically constrained pose optimization is a reasonable design, experienmental results and ablations demonstrate clear improvements in reconstruction accuracy and novel-view synthesis.
Critical weaknesses
- I have concerns about how the uncertainty maps are learned after DINOv2 initialization. Eq. (8) uses a hard binary threshold, but the paper does not explain how gradients are propagated through it or what prevents the learned masks from simply suppressing high-error regions. And It is unclear how the uncertainty estimates capture cross-view or temporal inconsistencies.
Questions for authors
- How are object insertion and removal implemented in the 3D Gaussian representation? Eq. (10) only describes transformations of existing Gaussian parameters.
- How does the unified model compare with a simpler baseline that freezes Gaussian geometry and uses style conditioning only for appearance?
- The paper states that the geometry MLPs receive gradients only from the rendering loss. But both the style loss and geometric regularization depend on the transformed Gaussian parameters. This seems a little confusing.