acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

StyledStreets: Multi-Style Street Simulator with Spatial and Temporal Consistency

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Urban street simulation requires more than realistic appearance transfer: it must preserve scene geometry, motion, and multi-camera consistency under changing appearance. We present StyledSteets, a multi-style 3D Gaussian street simulator for instruction-driven editing that combines physically grounded pose refinement, uncertainty-aware supervision, and unified stylization. Built on 3D Gaussian Splatting, the method addresses three coupled challenges: dynamic street reconstruction under rigid camera-vehicle constraints, noisy diffusion supervision across views and time, and geometry-preserving style transfer suitable for downstream simulation. In particular, it is designed to keep edited scenes useful not only for visual appearance control but also for downstream tasks such as vehicle tracking and ego-centric planning. Experiments on Waymo show stronger reconstruction quality than prior street-scene baselines, including an 18.2% lower Chamfer Distance than OmniRe, while edited scenes also improve tracking and planning robustness over diffusion-only alternatives. These results support controllable urban-scene simulation under diverse weather and appearance changes.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Autonomous Driving, 3D Computer Vision, Diffusion Model, Egocentric Planning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_ZnyfOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposed StyledSteets, which is a multi-style 3D Gaussian street simulator for instruction-driven editing. The main contributios include: rigid camera-vehicle pose optimization, DINO-based uncertainty-aware supervision, and unified style-conditioned gaussian model. The experimental results demonstrate good performance, and the overall evaluation is relatively comprehensive.

Critical strengths
  • This paper not only enables multi-style driving scene editing, but also attempts to demonstrate that the edited driving scenes retain sufficient 3D structure and temporal information to actually improve downstream autonomous driving tasks.
  • The paper proposed an explicit solution to improve reconstruction quality. The physically constrained pose optimization is a reasonable design, experienmental results and ablations demonstrate clear improvements in reconstruction accuracy and novel-view synthesis.
Critical weaknesses
  • I have concerns about how the uncertainty maps are learned after DINOv2 initialization. Eq. (8) uses a hard binary threshold, but the paper does not explain how gradients are propagated through it or what prevents the learned masks from simply suppressing high-error regions. And It is unclear how the uncertainty estimates capture cross-view or temporal inconsistencies.
Questions for authors
  • How are object insertion and removal implemented in the 3D Gaussian representation? Eq. (10) only describes transformations of existing Gaussian parameters.
  • How does the unified model compare with a simpler baseline that freezes Gaussian geometry and uses style conditioning only for appearance?
  • The paper states that the geometry MLPs receive gradients only from the rendering loss. But both the style loss and geometric regularization depend on the transformed Gaussian parameters. This seems a little confusing.
Reviewer_qqX4OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents StyledStreets, a multi-style street simulation framework based on 3D Gaussian Splatting that aims to preserve spatial and temporal consistency during instruction-driven scene editing. The method combines rigid camera-vehicle pose optimization, DINO-based uncertainty masking for diffusion supervision, and unified style-conditioned Gaussian transformations. It is evaluated on Waymo and PandaSet for reconstruction and novel-view synthesis, with additional experiments on nuScenes and Bench2Drive for downstream tracking and planning. The results report improvements in reconstruction quality, geometric accuracy, style consistency, and downstream performance compared with existing reconstruction and diffusion-based editing methods.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important challenge in dynamic street simulation: achieving controllable appearance editing while preserving scene geometry, motion, and multi-view consistency.

  2. The framework combines geometric reconstruction with instruction-driven stylization and evaluates its utility through both reconstruction benchmarks and downstream autonomous-driving tasks.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The core mathematical formulation contains inconsistencies that undermine the claimed uncertainty-aware learning and geometry-preserving stylization. Equation (8) defines the reliability mask using a hard indicator function applied to the predicted uncertainty. However, such a binary threshold has zero gradients almost everywhere with respect to the uncertainty values. Consequently, the masked style loss in Equation (9) cannot directly optimize the uncertainty predictor through standard backpropagation. The paper nevertheless claims that these uncertainty maps are implicitly learned through the proposed masked supervision, without specifying any differentiable relaxation, alternative training objective, or gradient estimator. This leaves the central uncertainty-aware editing mechanism mathematically incomplete. A related inconsistency appears in the unified stylization formulation. The authors state that the geometry transformation networks, MLP_mu and MLP_Sigma, are updated exclusively through the reconstruction loss to preserve geometry. However, Equations (5)–(7) define a joint objective in which the style loss explicitly depends on the transformed Gaussian geometry, while the geometric regularization directly penalizes changes in Gaussian positions and covariances. According to Equation (11), these terms contribute to the optimization gradients unless additional gradient-blocking operations are introduced. The stated restricted gradient flow therefore does not follow from the provided objective. Furthermore, Equation (10) updates Gaussian covariances through element-wise multiplication with exponentiated network outputs. While exponentiation ensures positive multiplicative factors, it does not generally guarantee that the resulting covariance matrix remains symmetric positive definite. The paper explicitly claims that this operation guarantees positive-definite covariances, which is not mathematically justified by the given parameterization. These issues are particularly consequential because uncertainty-aware supervision and geometry-preserving style transformations constitute the paper's central methodological contributions. The current mathematical formulation does not adequately establish that these mechanisms operate as claimed.

  2. Inconsistencies between the main experimental results and supplementary material raise concerns about the reliability of the empirical conclusions. A particularly significant inconsistency appears between Table 1 and Appendix Table 10. In Table 1, the proposed method reports human reconstruction PSNR/SSIM of 29.02/0.879 and novel-view synthesis PSNR/SSIM of 26.33/0.812. However, these values correspond exactly to the "Ours+Surf" configuration in Appendix Table 10, rather than the configuration explicitly labeled "Ours." More importantly, Appendix Table 10 reports substantially worse novel-view human reconstruction results for the standalone "Ours" configuration: 20.00 PSNR and 0.442 SSIM, compared with 24.36 PSNR and 0.727 SSIM for OmniRe. Thus, the standalone method performs considerably worse than OmniRe on this evaluation, whereas Table 1 presents the method as outperforming OmniRe. The main paper does not adequately clarify whether additional surface-based regularization is incorporated into the reported primary results. Since the supplementary material identifies this as a separate configuration, the discrepancy directly affects the interpretation of the reported improvements. The experimental configuration also contains an explicit inconsistency. Section 4 specifies lambda_1 = 0.1 and lambda_2 = 0.5, consistent with Table 9, whereas the discussion in Section 5.4 states that lambda_1 = lambda_2 = 0.1 are used throughout. These conflicting descriptions further weaken confidence in the reproducibility of the reported results. Beyond these inconsistencies, the downstream tracking and planning experiments provide limited information about the training protocols, augmentation budgets, and statistical variability. Although Tables 7 and 8 report improvements over diffusion-based alternatives, the paper does not establish whether these gains consistently arise from improved 3D geometric and temporal coherence rather than differences in generated training data or augmentation configurations.

Questions for authors
  1. How are the uncertainty maps optimized under the hard-thresholded formulation? Equations (8)–(9) define a binary reliability mask whose gradients with respect to the predicted uncertainty are zero almost everywhere. Is a differentiable approximation, straight-through estimator, or separate uncertainty-training objective used in the implementation? If so, why is it absent from the mathematical formulation? What prevents the learned reliability mechanism from simply suppressing difficult supervision rather than identifying genuinely inconsistent diffusion targets?

  2. How does the implementation guarantee valid Gaussian geometry and enforce the claimed restricted gradient flow? Equation (10) does not generally preserve covariance positive definiteness under arbitrary element-wise exponential scaling. What covariance parameterization is actually used? Additionally, are gradients from the style and geometric regularization losses explicitly blocked from MLP_mu and MLP_Sigma? If not, how is the claim that these networks are updated exclusively through the reconstruction loss consistent with Equations (5)–(7) and (11)? Since the geometric transformations are also conditioned on camera-related embeddings, what prevents geometry from varying across viewpoints?

  3. Which model configuration produces the main results in Table 1? The human reconstruction and novel-view synthesis results reported for "Ours" in Table 1 exactly match the "Ours+Surf" configuration in Appendix Table 10, whereas the standalone "Ours" configuration performs substantially worse on novel-view human reconstruction. Does the main method incorporate the additional EasyMocap-based surface regularization? If so, was the same configuration consistently used in all comparisons and ablations? The authors should also clarify whether lambda_2 is 0.1 or 0.5 in the final experimental configuration.

  4. How are the claimed 3D editing capabilities and downstream improvements validated under controlled conditions? Equation (10) specifies transformations of Gaussian positions, covariances, and appearance coefficients, but does not explicitly describe primitive insertion, deletion, or opacity modification for object-level editing. How are the demonstrated object insertion and removal operations implemented in the actual 3D representation? Furthermore, for the nuScenes tracking and Bench2Drive planning experiments, were all competing methods trained with identical data volumes, augmentation settings, and computational budgets? Are the reported improvements consistent across multiple random seeds or evaluation runs?

Reviewer_NdWjOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents StyledStreets, a multi-style dynamic street-scene simulator built upon 3D Gaussian Splatting.

Critical strengths

Motivation is reasonable and practically meaningful. The paper addresses the problem of preserving geometric and temporal consistency during street-scene style editing. The method achieves better reconstruction results than previous approaches.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Although several baselines are included, the evaluation lacks comparisons with relevant published works on controllable driving-scene simulation and consistent 3D/4D stylization, such as StreetCrafter and 4DStyleGaussian. This makes it difficult to fully assess the advantages of the proposed method in spatial and temporal consistency.

  2. The pose-free reconstruction demonstrated in Fig. 1 seems inconsistent with the fixed camera-to-vehicle extrinsics assumed in Eq. (3). Moreover, Sec. 4 relies on PnP-based object pose initialization and COLMAP sparse points. It remains unclear what inputs are actually required in the pose-free setting and whether the same pipeline is used.

Questions for authors

Please refer to the Critical Weaknesses.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.