- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SG-TPR for multi-view multi-label feature selection. The method decomposes each view-specific prediction mapping into a residual branch and a shared low-rank structural branch. A simplex gate adjusts the strength of structural regularization across views, while label correlations are used to constrain the shared label factor. The method then combines the two branches to produce a global feature ranking. Experiments on seven datasets compare SG-TPR with eight baselines and include several component ablations.
Critical strengths
-
The method combines shared label structure with view-specific information while preserving the full class of linear prediction mappings. The theoretical analysis of this property is clear.
-
The evaluation covers seven datasets and eight baselines under a unified protocol. The paper also includes several ablations to examine the contributions of its main components.
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty is limited. The paper argues that existing methods struggle to balance shared label structure and view-specific information, as well as adaptive sharing across views. However, these issues have already been addressed to some extent by methods such as DHLI [1] and SPLIT [2]. Low-rank factorization, view weighting, and sparse feature selection are also well-established techniques. Furthermore, the tensor-product formulation highlighted in the title is simply an algebraic rewriting of a standard inner product, and the method does not introduce an explicit regularizer for tensor structure.
-
The performance gains are small. Despite sequentially tuning four hyperparameters to select the best configuration, the AP improvement over the strongest baseline is only on the order of 0.001 for most datasets. The statistical tests in Appendix E also fail to establish statistically significant improvements.
-
The paper does not adequately explain how the proposed components address specific limitations of existing methods. Figure 1 mixes mathematical expressions with ordinary text, contains poorly formatted formulas, and includes several graphical elements whose purpose is unclear. The large box around Eq. (10) is also inconsistent with the formatting of other equations.
[1] Pingting Hao, Kunpeng Liu, and Wanfu Gao. Double-Layer Hybrid-Label Identification Feature Selection for Multi-View Multi-Label Learning. In Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence (AAAI), 38(11):12295–12303, 2024.
[2] Lu Sun, Canh Hao Nguyen, and Hiroshi Mamitsuka. Multiplicative Sparse Feature Decomposition for Efficient Multi-View Multi-Task Learning. In Proceedings of the Twenty-Eighth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI), pages 3506–3512, 2019.
Questions for authors
-
Most ablation experiments reuse the hyperparameters selected for the full model rather than tuning each variant independently. Even under this setting, removing some components leads to only minor performance differences. Could the authors provide results with independently tuned hyperparameters for each ablation variant to better establish the necessity of these components?
-
Appendix G.2 shows that the learned view weights vary considerably across data splits, making their interpretation unclear. Moreover, replacing the learned gate with uniform weights and independently retuning the model reduces average AP by only about 0.005. What meaningful role does the simplex gate actually play?