- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This article proposed a new method called InertiaMPDD, for depression detection. InertiaMPDD frames detection as estimating each person’s deviation of current expression from a counterfactual healthy baseline, turning individual differences from externally supplied labels into latent variables inferred from behavioral signals. The baseline is an individual-conditioned latent dynamics predictor trained exclusively on healthy dynamics. D-VLOG and LMVD were used for testing.
Critical strengths
- The statistical analyses are comprehensive.
- The idea of following each individual's healthy baseline and tracing individual change makes sense.
Critical weaknesses
- A fundamental flaw of the proposed method is assuming that a deviation from an individual's norm must be depression. This is rarely true in real life or even within the D-Vlog and LMVD datasets, since depression being assessed in the datasets does not mean that the individuals did not have other mental/behavioral concerns. These good results could be due to the fact that only depression was included in the datasets as the possible deviation. That means, as long as the dataset contains other deviations, the method could fail. It was unclear if the uniqueness of depression was effectively modeled.
- How "healthy" and "depressive" behaviors are labeled in the used datasets is very important to understand if the proposed method would work at least on these datasets. However, this was not clearly explained; thus, how the data were parsed and marked was unknown.
- The formulation does not increase the understanding of the methods since how each modality was handled and balanced, as well as which part is unique to depression was still unclear.
Questions for authors
- How was the sensitivity to depression evaluated empirically?