- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes VeriRL, a reinforcement learning post-training framework for video-based depression assessment, aiming to improve the consistency between generated reasoning and observable visual evidence. The authors use OpenFace to extract facial Action Unit (AU) dynamics and construct four discrete behavioral indicators as auxiliary verifiable rewards. They also introduce GroundFace-CoT and GroundVideo-CoT datasets for progressive image-level and video-level supervised fine-tuning. During reinforcement learning, the proposed Dynamics-Grounded Sign-GRPO (DGS-GRPO) replaces group-relative classification advantages with fixed-sign advantages based on prediction correctness, while using AU dynamics agreement to adjust their magnitudes. Experiments on AVEC 2014 and a curated Vlog dataset demonstrate modest improvements in binary classification and structured facial-dynamics agreement over the supervised baseline.
Critical strengths
The paper studies the difference between getting the final answer correct and using the correct visual evidence in medical video reasoning. Using facial changes as extra signals to check the reasoning is a reasonable idea.
The proposed method combines image-level facial understanding, video-level supervised fine-tuning, and reinforcement learning in a clear training pipeline.
The paper evaluates both classification accuracy and how well the model results match facial changes extracted by an independent method. This provides more evidence than task accuracy alone.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty of DGS-GRPO. The zero-advantage problem in homogeneous rollout groups has already been studied. For example, the ICLR 2026 paper No Prompt Left Behind (https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.21880) addresses this problem through advantage shaping. The main difference of DGS-GRPO is using AU dynamics rewards to adjust the advantage values. Besides, the paper does not compare with these existing methods.
-
The AU-based reward is not well justified. The reward uses only four facial AUs and their changes over time, but these AUs are not clearly validated as indicators of depression. Matching the facial dynamics extracted by OpenFace does not necessarily mean better depression detection. The paper also provides limited analysis of why these four AUs are selected. Since I am not an expert in depression detection, I would leave this concern to reviewers with more domain knowledge.
-
Better dynamics agreement does not mean better CoT reasoning. The RL reward only checks the four categories in the <dynamics> block, but does not directly evaluate whether the reasoning in <think> is based on the correct video evidence. Therefore, better dynamics agreement cannot fully support the claim that the CoT reasoning becomes more faithful to the video.
-
Limited improvements and missing ablation studies. Compared with SFT, VeriRL only improves Accuracy and Macro-F1 from 0.61 to 0.63 on Vlog Full, while the four-class AVEC Macro-F1 remains at 0.28. Each test set also contains only 100 videos. In addition, the paper does not include an ablation that removes the dynamics reward while keeping DGS-GRPO. Therefore, it is unclear how much each component contributes to the final performance.
-
The experiments mainly use Qwen2.5-VL-7B, which is relatively outdated compared with newer models like Qwen3-VL. Although the paper includes newer models as baselines, it does not test the proposed training method on these stronger models.
Questions for authors
see weakness