- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a novel method of representing molecular orbitals as learnable floating Gaussians and variationally optimizing this representation with a differentiable KS-DFT implementation. Alongside the new orbitals, the paper also introduces two solver steps that save computational effort and allow for stable gradient propagation, respectively. GS-DFT is then tested on a range of molecular experimental setups, including significantly large structures and across several functionals, demonstrating strong accuracy and favorable memory scaling. Notably, the new adaptive basis functions do not have to be expert-tuned and generalize well to difficult systems such as diffuse ones.
Critical strengths
Clear and detailed presentation:
The paper is well written and presented. Every method is motivated and the paper contains extensive results and discussions. All aspects required to frame and understand the problem are clearly laid out by the authors, leaving little to no confusion after reading it.
Promising method:
The presented method is very promising. Instead of orbital-free DFT, this method still retains the typical variational KS-DFT formulation while the basis set itself is system-agnostic. Since choosing the right basis set is often a non-trivial task for difficult systems, this method could present an all-inclusive approach. The combination of an adaptive basis and efficient density fitting represents a particularly interesting direction for improving the scalability of electronic-structure calculations.
Critical weaknesses
Computational cost:
As noted by the authors in Appendix D.4, the method is significantly slower in wall-clock time than conventional SCF calculations because jointly optimization of the basis and orbital coefficients introduces computational overhead. I do not believe this undermines the methodological contribution, but it limits the immediate applicability of the method as a replacement for conventional DFT solvers.
On a related note, the largest-system experiments have favorable memory scaling on calculations involving thousands of atoms. However, these results primarily establish computational feasibility rather than accuracy at this scale. I recognize that performing fully converged conventional DFT calculations on the largest systems is likely prohibitively computationally expensive, but it would have been instructive to see an "accuracy versus system size" curve of the error per atom extending as far as computationally feasible into the large-system regime (e.g., 50, 100, 200, 300, 500 atoms or whatever is feasible). Even comparisons against conventional DFT at a fixed functional and basis set level would provide useful evidence.
However, neither limitation substantially changes my overall positive assessment of the paper.
Questions for authors
-
Could GS-DFT be extended to open-shell systems, for example through unrestricted KS-DFT? Or are there reasons why this would be difficult?
-
Is there a reason you did not chemically inform all initializations, e.g., your results in Figure 3? Based on the ablation in Appendix E.3, it seems like the best approach. Did you attempt to pre-fit the splats in a superposition-of-atomic-densities way?
2 comments
While there were not any major concerns on my part to begin with, I think the authors have answered well for themselves on the questions that I and other reviewers had.
This only reinforces my positive assessment of the paper, which I believe is timely and presented well.
Response to Reviewer 6RRa
We thank the referee for their feedback. Our response can be found below.
The answer is yes. We can extend the method and the implementation to open-shell systems by jointly optimising a coefficient matrix for each spin channel. This can be easily wired throughout the code. We strongly believe this is a necessary next step to deal with more complex, relevant systems. However, due to time constraints, we must defer this direction and the analysis of their optimisation dynamics to further studies.
We wanted to show that even random initialisation yields correct results as we first focus on correctness, leaving the convergence cost as a future problem. Furthermore, we indeed thought about doing many different initializations but refrained from tackling them all to better focus on the other parts of the method. It is nonetheless a necessary future direction, as a good initialization dramatically reduces the number of steps necessary for convergence. This is a fantastic insight from the referee.
Regarding accuracy versus system size, Figure 9c in Appendix F.3 reports the error per atom at each system's cc-pVTZ size from 7 to 196 atoms: splats are 2 to 6 times more accurate than cc-pVTZ on every C/H/N/O system. Figure 6 shows the full accuracy scaling of the two largest, at 168 and 196 atoms. While a full accuracy scaling analysis of our largest systems is unfeasible, we provide such analysis for a bridging, intermediate scale.