- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a new model base on Recursive Quadrature Filtering. This model gets very good performances over different EEG tasks, almost reaching the performances of FM models for EEG with way less parameters. To go a bit further the paper proposes different study for the pre-training setup showing in which setup the model fails.
Critical strengths
- The idea to use RQF to embed the signal allows to give more meaningful representation.
- The RQF method allows to get almost same performances with way less parameters, showing that smart model is sometimes better.
- The paper is pretty easy to read.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper lacks of motivation for the new model they propose. For example the introduction is unbalanced. Most of the introduction is focus on contribution of the paper (5 paragraphs out of 6). It would be interesting to have a better introduction to the field rather than one page on the contribution. This introduction could point out what are the missing part of the field that RQF try to fill.
-
This comes to the second point. If RQF is an interesting method, in practice model like Reve or CBraMod have better results. I understand that RQF has way less parameters but a study of the computational time to fine-tune the backbones could be interesting to see that in practice using RQF reach almost the same results with less computational time.
-
My last point that is the most critical, I'm wondering how trustful are these results. The majority of the values on the tables are from initial paper. But is the split and pre-processing the same ? Looking at CBraMod paper, for TUAB they used specific pre-processing and a split of 80/20%. It seems that is not what the paper is doing. Nothing in the paper is telling us that the tables are fully comparable because the splits are the same.
Questions for authors
-
In plot top right in Figure 2, USleep is said train only on ISRUC, but in the orignal paper it is trained on separate corpus no? Do you re-train it?
-
Do you think that having this kind of representation could help to have more interpretable features for our signals ? In this case it could be interesting to try to interpret the features.
-
I'm wondering how much your work can be related to the work of [1], where they propose filtering in the frequency space EEG for better generalisation? I'm wondering if this step could be applied to the different filter you get.
[1] Gnassounou et. al., PSDNorm: Test-Time Temporal Normalization for Deep Learning in Sleep Staging