acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Minimizing Polarization in Geometric Opinion Dynamics on Social Networks

Abstract

We propose a multidimensional geometric opinion dynamics model on social networks, in which opinions evolve through alignment-based interactions. We rigorously analyze the dynamics to identify its characteristics and show that polarization can emerge endogenously. To mitigate the effect of polarization, we introduce recommendation-based interventions with exposure as a controllable parameter, yielding a nonlinear optimization problem. We show that the dynamics have a Lipschitz-continuous Jacobian and that a broad class of resulting objectives has Lipschitz-continuous gradients, establishing their tractability for optimization. We further apply a Zeroth-order projected optimization method to minimize polarization using only function evaluations, with guarantees of convergence to first-order stationary points up to smoothing bias. Experiments on synthetic and real-world network topologies demonstrate that recommendations effectively reduce polarization, and that the zeroth-order method achieves performance comparable to first-order approaches.

Primary area:
alignment, fairness, safety, privacy, and societal considerations
Keywords:
Opinion Dynamics, Polariation, Optimization and Control

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_82FtOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a multidimensional opinion dynamics model on social networks and it shows that polarization emerges endogenously. It then studies recommendation-based interventions to reduce polarization. Theoretical analysis is provided for the smoothness properties of the dynamics and resulting objectives. Experiments are conducted on synthetic and real-world data.

Critical strengths

S1. Opinion dynamics is an interesting topic in social network analysis. S2. The paper combines the classic (network based) FJ model with the geometric opinion model of external influences in an interesting way. S3. Mathematical analysis of the proposed model.

Critical weaknesses

W1. While mathematically interesting, the approach is highly stylized and there is no evidence that reflects reality. Similarly there is no evidence that the proposed interventions can be implemented, or that one can efficiently estimate the parameters (initial opinions, W, and A) needed to materialize the interventions.
W2. The method relies on gradient descend and there are no global guarantees of optimality. W3. The energy function does not distinguish the signs. This means that one gets the same energy if all opinions are perfectly aligned, if the alignment happens along communities, or if the nodes are randomly aligned along vectors v and -v. W4. There are some glitches. For example, the authors assume that the W matrix is row stochastic and symmetric, which would make it double stochastic, which in turn is a strong assumption.

Questions for authors

I invite the authors to respond to all the listed weaknesses above.

1 comment

We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful feedback and for recognizing the interest of combining network-based and geometric opinion dynamics. We appreciate the concerns regarding practical applicability and modeling assumptions, and address each below.

W1 — Practical applicability and parameter estimation. We agree that validation with real-world opinion and recommendation data would strengthen the empirical evidence. However, our primary focus is on analyzing opinion dynamics when the relevant opinion dimensions and network structure are given, rather than prescribing a particular method for estimating these representations.

From an implementation perspective, multidimensional opinions can be constructed by eliciting preferences through dimension-specific questions, recording responses in [−1,+1][-1,+1], and normalizing the resulting vectors. Recommendation vectors can be represented using the same dimensions. The interaction matrix WW could be estimated using network inference techniques, while the exposure matrix AA is our control variable, representing how recommendation exposure is allocated across individuals, analogous to resource allocation in information campaigns or recommendation systems.

Theoretical results such as Theorem 2.1 (energy convergence and fixed-point accumulation) and Theorem 3.1 (smoothness of intervention objectives) do not require particular distributions of opinion or recommendation vectors, provided their stated assumptions hold.

Our experiments with synthetic opinions on SBM and real Facebook topologies are intended to illustrate these theoretical properties and the intervention framework, rather than establish real-world deployment effectiveness. We acknowledge that estimating opinions and influence networks from observational data is application-dependent and will clarify this scope and its limitations in the revision.

W2 — Global optimality. We agree that global optimality would be desirable. However, the intervention objective is generally nonconvex due to the nonlinear interactions between opinions and the network. Consequently, standard first-order and zeroth-order optimization methods do not guarantee global optimality.

Our objective is to establish the regularity of the intervention problem (Theorem 3.1) and provide a principled basis for optimization toward first-order stationary points. While stationarity is not sufficient for global optimality, it is a meaningful necessary condition for constrained local optimality. The experiments complement this analysis by reporting achieved objective reductions against alternative intervention strategies. We will clarify the scope of these guarantees.

W3 — Sign-invariant energy. We agree that squared alignment assigns the same maximum energy to consensus and perfectly bipolar configurations. This distinction is explicitly acknowledged in Section 2.2, where the energy is interpreted as a measure of sign-invariant axial concentration rather than a complete measure of social division.

To distinguish these configurations empirically, Appendix L.2 additionally evaluates principal-direction concentration and sign-sensitive network disagreement, showing that the observed bipolar configurations are not simply consensus states.

Importantly, our intervention framework is not restricted to squared alignment. Theorem 3.1 accommodates a broad class of sufficiently smooth downstream objectives, including alternative measures of disagreement and diversity. We will clarify the distinction between reducing axial concentration and reducing polarization under broader definitions.

W4 — Symmetric, row-stochastic network assumption. We agree that requiring WW to be symmetric and row-stochastic also makes it doubly stochastic, and that this is a restrictive assumption for general social influence networks.

This assumption is used in our energy analysis to establish the Riemannian gradient structure and monotone energy evolution. It is therefore a deliberate condition for the theoretical guarantees, rather than a claim that all real-world networks satisfy it.

Both the Facebook and synthetic SBM networks used in our experiments have undirected connections. However, ordinary row normalization does not necessarily preserve symmetry. To ensure consistency with the theoretical assumptions, we are correcting the implementation using Metropolis weights:

wij=1max⁡(di,dj),(i,j)∈E, i≠j,w_{ij}=\frac{1}{\max(d_i,d_j)},\quad (i,j)\in E,\ i\ne j,

with zero weights for nonedges and wii=1−∑j≠iwijw_{ii}=1-\sum_{j\ne i}w_{ij}. This construction guarantees nonnegative, symmetric, row-stochastic interaction matrices. We will clarify the construction and verify the experiments using the corrected matrices.

We acknowledge that extending the theoretical results to asymmetric and heterogeneous influence networks is an important direction for future work.

Reviewer_o5kpOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies multidimensional geometric opinion dynamics on social networks, where unit-vector opinions evolve through alignment-dependent interactions with their neighbors. The authors analyze an alignment-energy function and establish monotone energy evolution and fixed-point accumulation under symmetric, row-stochastic interactions. They also examine polarized and non-polarized fixed-point configurations. To influence the dynamics, the paper introduces recommendation exposure as a control variable and formulates an optimization objective combining squared alignment with a distributional drift penalty. The authors establish smoothness properties of the controlled dynamics and apply a standard zeroth-order projected optimization method. Experiments use synthetic networks and Facebook network topologies with synthetically generated opinions and recommendations.

Critical strengths

S1. The paper provides a coherent framework that integrates geometric opinion interactions, network structure, and recommendation exposure. Separating recommendation influence from subsequent peer interactions makes the intervention mechanism clear and captures how its effects can propagate through the social network.

S2. The theoretical analysis provides useful insights into the dynamics. In particular, the paper explicitly distinguishes fixed-point accumulation from convergence to polarized states. The non-polarized cycle construction also illustrates how network structure can affect the possible fixed-point configurations. These results help clarify the behavior of geometric opinion dynamics in networked settings.

S3. The experiments examine both squared alignment and opinion distribution drift, while the appendix includes additional baselines and sensitivity analyses. Uniform exposure, random search with a matched evaluation budget, and recommendation strategies based on opinion geometry provide useful points of comparison for evaluating the optimization methods.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The fixed-qq convergence guarantee in Corollary 4.1 needs clarification. The variance term O(ησ2/q)O(\eta\sigma^2/q) does not generally follow from the stated assumptions: even a linear objective on a probability simplex can retain a nonzero average squared gradient mapping despite zero smoothing bias. Please provide a complete derivation or clarify the additional conditions needed.

W2. The technical novelty could be clearer. Since the zeroth-order estimator and smoothness composition arguments use established tools, the paper should better distinguish its new technical contributions and highlight the insights arising from network structure and opinion geometry.

W3. Squared alignment is maximized under both consensus and bipolar configurations. Although the authors acknowledge this limitation, the practical meaning of reducing this objective needs further discussion, particularly its relationship to disagreement, diversity, and distributional drift.

W4. The experiments use networks of at most a few hundred nodes, with synthetic opinions and recommendations. Larger-scale evaluation and direct first-order versus zeroth-order comparisons under matched computational budgets would strengthen the practical evidence.

Questions for authors

Q1. Table 1 shows that PCA diversity achieves larger objective reductions and lower drift than network-aware ZO. Under what conditions does network-aware optimization offer an advantage? Comparisons across different opinion configurations, recommendation sets, and longer intervention horizons would help clarify this.

Q2. How are the SBM and Facebook interaction matrices constructed to satisfy both symmetry and row-stochasticity? Ordinary row normalization does not generally preserve symmetry. Please specify the weighting procedure and self-loop conventions.

Q3. Appendix L.3 uses Gaussian perturbations, whereas the theory uses uniform-sphere directions. Could the authors reconcile these implementations and explain how Gaussian queries outside the neighborhood covered by Appendix I are handled?

3 comments

We thank the reviewer for the detailed assessment and constructive suggestions. We address each point below. We use shorter form ZO for Zeroth-Order and FO for First-order.

W1 — ZO convergence. We agree that the original variance bound is generally invalid, as stochastic projection can prevent the diminishing-step gradient mapping from vanishing. We correct Corollary 4.1 by separating the update stepsize η\eta from a fixed stationarity reference stepsize γ=1/(2LJ)\gamma=1/(2L_J). Define

Gγμ(A)=γ−1[A−ΠA(A−γ∇Jμ(A))].\mathcal G^\mu_\gamma(A)=\gamma^{-1}[A-\Pi_{\mathcal A}(A-\gamma\nabla J_\mu(A))].

Unlike Gημ\mathcal G^\mu_\eta, this mapping uses a reference step independent of TT; both mappings vanish at exactly the constrained FO stationary points. Let Δ=Jμ(A0)−min⁡A∈AJμ(A)\Delta=J_\mu(A^0)-\min_{A\in\mathcal A}J_\mu(A) and G=max⁡A∈A∥∇Jμ(A)∥F<∞G=\max_{A\in\mathcal A}\|\nabla J_\mu(A)\|_F<\infty. A Moreau-envelope descent argument yields

\le \frac{9\Delta}{\eta T} +9L_J\eta\left(G^2+\frac{\sigma^2}{q}\right).$$ Choosing $\eta=\Theta(T^{-1/2})$ yields **$O(T^{-1/2})$ average squared stationarity with constant $q$**; transfer to the unsmoothed objective adds $O(B_\mu^2)$. This is a corrected guarantee for a different stationarity measure, not a proof of the original inequality. We will provide the full derivation in the appendix. Algorithm 1, its evaluation complexity, and the existing assumptions remain unchanged. **W2 — Technical novelty.** We agree that the ZO estimator and smoothness composition arguments are established techniques. Rather, our contribution lies in the model-specific analysis enabling their application to nonlinear, network-coupled geometric opinion dynamics. We show that increase in alignment diminishes the dimensional variety of opinions and recommendations can be used to retain that variety to some extent, under different objectives. The objectives can be any combination of metrics as long as they are within the Lipschitz-continuous gradient family. And finally demonstrate a dynamics and gradient independent method in the for of ZO optimization. We will distinguish these contributions more clearly from the standard optimization machinery. **W3 — Squared alignment.** In section 2.2, we identify that squared alignment as sign-invariant axial concentration, not a measure separating consensus from bipolarity. additionally, appendix L.2 also reports principal-direction concentration and sign-sensitive disagreement. As theorem 3.1 allows other sufficiently smooth downstream metrics, in specific use cases, the metrics and objectives can be tuned accordingly. We will clarify that in the final revision. **W4 — Scalability/comparison.** We present analysis on varied $N,M,d,q,\mu$ in appendix L.3. Analytically, a one-step objective evaluation costs $O(d(|E|+NM+N^2))$, including direct pairwise MMD evaluation. Reverse-mode FO differentiation has comparable asymptotic cost when the computational model is accessible; ZO takes $2q$ objective evaluations per iteration. The benefit of ZO method is in use cases where gradients are not available, but it is generally slower than FO methods when gradients are available. We will add this cost comparison and clarify the limits of our empirical evidence. **Q1 — PCA diversity.** We agree that PCA performs better in Table 1. Appendix L.2 uses noisy bipolar opinions concentrated around two antipodal directions, a setting particularly favorable to PCA, which explicitly targets the dominant opinion subspace. However, PCA's heuristic is tailored to this geometric structure, whereas ZO directly optimizes the full network-mediated objective without assuming a particular opinion distribution or objective form. The ZO experiments also use a limited budget ($T=50,q=64$). We will clarify this distinction; broader configurations and horizons merit further evaluation. **Q2 — Interaction matrices.** Facebook and SBM graphs are undirected, but ordinary row normalization need not preserve symmetry. We are correcting the implementation using Metropolis weights: $w_{ij}=1/\max(d_i,d_j)$ for undirected edges, $0$ for nonedges, and $w_{ii}=1-\sum_{j\ne i}w_{ij}$. This ensures nonnegativity, symmetry and row-stochasticity. We will clarify the construction and verify experiments with corrected matrices. Section 2.4 (Eq. 10) separately considers community-dependent strengths. **Q3 — Perturbations.** We thank the reviewer for identifying this discrepancy. Both implementations use standard two-point ZO estimation, differing only in their perturbation distributions. We can directly align them by normalizing sampled Gaussian directions to unit length, yielding uniform-sphere directions as assumed in our theory. This ensures bounded perturbations within the smooth neighborhood established in Appendix I (Lemma G.2). We will make this minor implementation correction and clarify it in the revision.

I have checked the responses. I believe the paper would benefit from further refinement, so I would like to retain my score.

Thank you for your time and thoughts about our paper.

Reviewer_beoGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies polarization in social networks. Existing work either studies how (i) opinions evolve in social networks or (ii) how interventions through recommendations changes network connections. This work investigates both of these in combination. To address (i), they propose a model where people are attracted toward similar opinions and pushed away from opposing opinions (and they analyze the behavior of these interactions over time). To address (ii), they formulate an optimization problem where the goal is to find exposure to recommendations for each person so as to reduce polarization and changes to the initial opinion distribution. They show that this objective has a Lipschitz-continuous gradient w.r.t recommendation exposure weights. They use a standard zeroth-order method to optimize the objective for which they prove a converegence guarantee.

Critical strengths
  • They address an interesting and important problem that has not yet been investigated in the related literature. Recommendations is an effective tool to mitigate polarization in social networks. Combining this with a model of how opinions evolve in a social network is an important idea.
  • The authors show that the proposed optimization objective has a Lipschitz-continuous gradient w.r.t. the recommendation exposure weights. This allows them to use standard smooth optimization methods.
Critical weaknesses
  • A core theoretical result of their algorithm is Corollary 4.1, so I briefly checked the proof of this. Under the proposed step-size schedule, eq. 198 gives an upper bound that goes to zero with a fixed number of perturbations. However, the stated assumptions allow examples where the average projected stationarity error remains positive. Therefore, I believe the inequality does not hold in general.

  • Consider a population where everyone agrees. The measure used in the paper labels this as maximally polarized, just like a population split into two fully opposing groups. The polarization term would therefore reward making the opinion of people less alike even when there are no opposing groups to begin with. Therefore, a lower score does not necessarily demonstrate reduced social division. The authors should better explain why reducing this particular measure represent a desirable form of depolarization.

Questions for authors
  • See the two weaknesses above.
  • It seems both the opinions and recommendations are synthetic. Can you explain why this is sufficient to show the benefit of your method? Can it lead to some kind of bias where it favors your method.
  • As far as I can tell, the first-order optimization method outperforms your method. Then, what exactly is the benefit of your method over this?
2 comments

We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful assessment and for recognizing the importance of combining networked opinion dynamics with recommendation interventions. We appreciate the concerns and address them below. We use shorter form ZO for Zeroth-Order and FO for First-order.

W1 — ZO convergence guarantee. We agree that the original variance bound for the projected gradient mapping is generally invalid under stochastic projection, as the reviewer correctly identifies.

We correct Corollary 4.1 by distinguishing the optimization stepsize η\eta from a fixed reference stepsize γ=1/(2LJ)\gamma=1/(2L_J) used to measure stationarity. Define

Gγμ(A)=γ−1[A−ΠA(A−γ∇Jμ(A))].\mathcal G^\mu_\gamma(A)=\gamma^{-1}[A-\Pi_{\mathcal A}(A-\gamma\nabla J_\mu(A))].

Unlike the original mapping Gημ\mathcal G^\mu_\eta, the reference stepsize does not vanish with TT. Both mappings characterize exactly the same constrained first-order stationary points.

Let Δ=Jμ(A0)−min⁡A∈AJμ(A)\Delta=J_\mu(A^0)-\min_{A\in\mathcal A}J_\mu(A) and G=max⁡A∈A∥∇Jμ(A)∥<∞G=\max_{A \in \mathcal A} \| \nabla J_{\mu} (A) \| < \infty. Using the Moreau envelope MγM_\gamma of the constrained smoothed objective, we obtain the one-step descent inequality

E[Mγ(At+1)∣At]≤Mγ(At)−η(1−γLJ)2∥∇Mγ(At)∥F2+η22γ(G2+σ2q).\mathbb E[M_\gamma(A^{t+1})\mid A^t] \le M_\gamma(A^t)-\frac{\eta(1-\gamma L_J)}{2}\|\nabla M_\gamma(A^t)\|_F^2 +\frac{\eta^2}{2\gamma}\left(G^2+\frac{\sigma^2}{q}\right).

Telescoping this inequality and relating the envelope gradient to the fixed-reference projected mapping gives

1T∑t=0T−1E∥Gγμ(At)∥F2≤9ΔηT+9LJη(G2+σ2q).\frac1T\sum_{t=0}^{T-1}\mathbb E\|\mathcal G^\mu_\gamma(A^t)\|_F^2 \leq\frac{9\Delta}{\eta T} +9L_J\eta\left(G^2+\frac{\sigma^2}{q}\right).

Thus, choosing η=Θ(T−1/2)\eta=\Theta(T^{-1/2}) establishes O(T−1/2)O(T^{-1/2}) average squared stationarity with constant qq. Transferring to the original objective adds the existing smoothing-bias term O(Bμ2)O(B_\mu^2).

This replaces the invalid bound with a valid guarantee for a different stationarity measure sharing the same stationary points. It preserves Algorithm 1, its function-evaluation complexity, and the existing assumptions. We will revise Corollary 4.1 and include the complete derivation in the appendix.

W2 — Interpretation of polarization. We agree that squared alignment alone cannot distinguish complete consensus from bipolar polarization. As explicitly acknowledged in Section 2.2, our measure represents sign-invariant axial concentration rather than all aspects of social division.

To distinguish these phenomena empirically, Appendix L.2 additionally evaluates principal-direction concentration and sign-sensitive network disagreement, demonstrating that the observed bipolar configurations are not simply consensus states.

Importantly, Theorem 3.1 is not restricted to squared alignment. It accommodates a broad class of sufficiently smooth downstream metrics, including alternative measures of disagreement and diversity. The squared-alignment objective is one particular instantiation of this framework.

We appreciate the reviewer's observation and will also distinguish these concepts more carefully when interpreting the experimental results.

Q2 — Synthetic opinions and recommendations. We agree that validation with real-world opinion data would strengthen the empirical evidence. However, our theoretical guarantees do not depend on a particular distribution of opinion or recommendation vectors.

Theorem 2.1 establishes energy convergence and fixed-point accumulation under the stated network assumptions, while Theorem 3.1 establishes smoothness for sufficiently smooth downstream objectives. Neither requires the vectors to follow a specific distribution.

Our experiments use synthetic vectors on both SBM and real Facebook network topologies to illustrate these theoretical properties and demonstrate the intervention framework, rather than establish distribution-specific conclusions about real-world opinions. We will clarify this scope and acknowledge real-world validation as an important next step.

Q3 — FO versus ZO optimization. We agree that first-order optimization is preferable when accurate gradients are readily available, as reflected in our experimental results.

Our motivation for ZO is its applicability when gradients through the opinion dynamics are unavailable or impractical to calculate, such as in more complex multi-step interactions or black-box recommendation mechanisms. FO serves as a gradient-access reference, while ZO demonstrates that recommendation exposure can still be optimized using objective evaluations alone.

We do not claim that ZO outperforms FO or that the estimator itself is novel. Rather, our model-specific regularity analysis establishes the applicability of gradient-free optimization to the proposed nonlinear, network-mediated intervention problem. We will clarify this distinction in the revision.

We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions and will incorporate these corrections and clarifications.

Thank you for the response. Given the error in the proof and lack of experimental validation on real-word datasets indicate that the paper is not quite ready for publication. I will keep my score.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.