- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a multidimensional opinion dynamics model on social networks and it shows that polarization emerges endogenously. It then studies recommendation-based interventions to reduce polarization. Theoretical analysis is provided for the smoothness properties of the dynamics and resulting objectives. Experiments are conducted on synthetic and real-world data.
Critical strengths
S1. Opinion dynamics is an interesting topic in social network analysis. S2. The paper combines the classic (network based) FJ model with the geometric opinion model of external influences in an interesting way. S3. Mathematical analysis of the proposed model.
Critical weaknesses
W1. While mathematically interesting, the approach is highly stylized and there is no evidence that reflects reality. Similarly there is no evidence that the proposed interventions can be implemented, or that one can efficiently estimate the parameters (initial opinions, W, and A) needed to materialize the interventions.
W2. The method relies on gradient descend and there are no global guarantees of optimality.
W3. The energy function does not distinguish the signs. This means that one gets the same energy if all opinions are perfectly aligned, if the alignment happens along communities, or if the nodes are randomly aligned along vectors v and -v.
W4. There are some glitches. For example, the authors assume that the W matrix is row stochastic and symmetric, which would make it double stochastic, which in turn is a strong assumption.
Questions for authors
I invite the authors to respond to all the listed weaknesses above.
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful feedback and for recognizing the interest of combining network-based and geometric opinion dynamics. We appreciate the concerns regarding practical applicability and modeling assumptions, and address each below.
W1 — Practical applicability and parameter estimation. We agree that validation with real-world opinion and recommendation data would strengthen the empirical evidence. However, our primary focus is on analyzing opinion dynamics when the relevant opinion dimensions and network structure are given, rather than prescribing a particular method for estimating these representations.
From an implementation perspective, multidimensional opinions can be constructed by eliciting preferences through dimension-specific questions, recording responses in [−1,+1], and normalizing the resulting vectors. Recommendation vectors can be represented using the same dimensions. The interaction matrix W could be estimated using network inference techniques, while the exposure matrix A is our control variable, representing how recommendation exposure is allocated across individuals, analogous to resource allocation in information campaigns or recommendation systems.
Theoretical results such as Theorem 2.1 (energy convergence and fixed-point accumulation) and Theorem 3.1 (smoothness of intervention objectives) do not require particular distributions of opinion or recommendation vectors, provided their stated assumptions hold.
Our experiments with synthetic opinions on SBM and real Facebook topologies are intended to illustrate these theoretical properties and the intervention framework, rather than establish real-world deployment effectiveness. We acknowledge that estimating opinions and influence networks from observational data is application-dependent and will clarify this scope and its limitations in the revision.
W2 — Global optimality. We agree that global optimality would be desirable. However, the intervention objective is generally nonconvex due to the nonlinear interactions between opinions and the network. Consequently, standard first-order and zeroth-order optimization methods do not guarantee global optimality.
Our objective is to establish the regularity of the intervention problem (Theorem 3.1) and provide a principled basis for optimization toward first-order stationary points. While stationarity is not sufficient for global optimality, it is a meaningful necessary condition for constrained local optimality. The experiments complement this analysis by reporting achieved objective reductions against alternative intervention strategies. We will clarify the scope of these guarantees.
W3 — Sign-invariant energy. We agree that squared alignment assigns the same maximum energy to consensus and perfectly bipolar configurations. This distinction is explicitly acknowledged in Section 2.2, where the energy is interpreted as a measure of sign-invariant axial concentration rather than a complete measure of social division.
To distinguish these configurations empirically, Appendix L.2 additionally evaluates principal-direction concentration and sign-sensitive network disagreement, showing that the observed bipolar configurations are not simply consensus states.
Importantly, our intervention framework is not restricted to squared alignment. Theorem 3.1 accommodates a broad class of sufficiently smooth downstream objectives, including alternative measures of disagreement and diversity. We will clarify the distinction between reducing axial concentration and reducing polarization under broader definitions.
W4 — Symmetric, row-stochastic network assumption. We agree that requiring W to be symmetric and row-stochastic also makes it doubly stochastic, and that this is a restrictive assumption for general social influence networks.
This assumption is used in our energy analysis to establish the Riemannian gradient structure and monotone energy evolution. It is therefore a deliberate condition for the theoretical guarantees, rather than a claim that all real-world networks satisfy it.
Both the Facebook and synthetic SBM networks used in our experiments have undirected connections. However, ordinary row normalization does not necessarily preserve symmetry. To ensure consistency with the theoretical assumptions, we are correcting the implementation using Metropolis weights:
wij=max(di,dj)1,(i,j)∈E, i=j,
with zero weights for nonedges and wii=1−∑j=iwij. This construction guarantees nonnegative, symmetric, row-stochastic interaction matrices. We will clarify the construction and verify the experiments using the corrected matrices.
We acknowledge that extending the theoretical results to asymmetric and heterogeneous influence networks is an important direction for future work.