acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Graph Propagation under Node-Value Updates

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Propagating node values across a graph is a basic operation in graph learning. We study how to maintain the result when initial input labels change but the graph and propagation rule remain fixed. Our starting point is the Friedkin–Johnsen opinion model, whose equilibrium operator is closely related to personalized PageRank and graph neural-network propagation. We start with a variation-sensitive work bound for the residual-push framework and show that it is tight up to a constant factor on unweighted graphs. We then generalize the framework from prior work to weighted graphs through a new discounted future-work potential, and further extend it to vector-valued opinions with matrix-valued couplings. Beyond opinion dynamics, our results provide a basic model of computational rollback: when a small portion of an input is discovered to be incorrect, the output can be repaired locally instead of recomputed from scratch.

Primary area:
learning on graphs and other geometries & topologies
Keywords:
Opinion dynamics, Dynamic algorithms, GNN

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_8H6uOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the efficient maintenance of graph propagation results under node-value updates, where the graph structure and propagation operator remain fixed. Based on the Friedkin–Johnsen opinion dynamics model, the authors employ a residual-based local push framework to update approximate equilibrium solutions without recomputing them from scratch. The paper first establishes the tightness of an existing variation-sensitive work bound for dynamic push on unweighted graphs. It then extends the theoretical analysis to weighted graphs by introducing a discounted future-work potential and further generalizes the framework to vector-valued opinions with matrix-weighted interactions. The authors provide approximation guarantees and theoretical bounds on the total propagation work for these settings.

Critical strengths

S1. The theoretical analysis is generally well-structured, with clear mathematical formulations and detailed proofs.

S2. The paper extends the analysis of dynamic push algorithms from unweighted graphs to weighted and matrix-weighted graphs, providing a unified theoretical framework.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The novelty and significance of the theoretical contributions are not sufficiently justified. The paper primarily extends the analysis of an existing dynamic push framework rather than proposing a fundamentally new algorithm. In particular, Theorem 4.1 establishes the tightness of the work bound for a specific algorithm, rather than an algorithm-independent lower bound. Moreover, the motivation for extending the analysis to weighted and matrix-weighted graphs is not sufficiently developed. These issues make it difficult to assess whether the theoretical results constitute sufficiently significant advances over prior work.

W2. The paper lacks experimental evaluation. Although the authors emphasize the efficiency of local updates and their relevance to graph learning applications, no experiments are provided to demonstrate the practical benefits of the proposed framework. In particular, the paper does not evaluate whether the theoretical work bounds translate into meaningful efficiency improvements on real-world graphs. This substantially limits the evidence supporting the practical significance of the proposed extensions.

Questions for authors

Q1. Could the authors further clarify the technical novelty of the proposed theoretical results compared with existing dynamic push methods? In particular, what new algorithmic insights are provided by the tightness result in Theorem 4.1 and the proposed future-work potential?

Q2. Could the authors provide experimental evaluations on real-world graphs to demonstrate the practical efficiency of the proposed framework? In particular, comparisons with recomputation and existing local propagation methods would help validate the practical significance of the theoretical results.

Q3. The related work is relatively limited, with only around 17 references. Given the connections to dynamic graph propagation, personalized PageRank, and graph unlearning, the paper would benefit from a more comprehensive discussion of existing studies and a clearer distinction between the proposed contributions and prior approaches.

Suggested References:

  • Wang et al. Edge-based Local Push for Personalized PageRank. VLDB, 2022.
  • Yi and Wei. Scalable and Certifiable Graph Unlearning: Overcoming the Approximation Error Barrier. ICLR, 2025.
  • Jain et al. Is Graph Unlearning Ready for Practice? A Benchmark on Efficiency, Utility, and Forgetting. ICLR, 2026.

Q4. Theorem 6.3 relies on the additional assumption ρ(∣T∣)<1\rho(|T|)<1, which does not necessarily follow from the original model assumptions. Could the authors clarify how restrictive this condition is in practice, particularly for non-diagonal matrix couplings? Are there broader classes of matrix-weighted graphs for which the assumption can be guaranteed?

Q5. The presentation and reproducibility could be improved. The paper contains no figures to illustrate the proposed framework or the theoretical constructions, making some parts difficult to follow. In addition, no implementation or public code repository is included in the manuscript.

Reviewer_ZYbBOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This purely theoretical paper studies dynamic maintenance of FJ equilibria (equivalently, PPR-style propagation) under point updates to node values on a fixed graph, building on the residual-push framework. Theorem 4.1 proves the existing variation-sensitive work bound is tight (factor 9/4) for the unweighted case via a K_{d,d} residual-recycling construction. Theorem 5.1 extends the bound to weighted graphs using a new potential h = (I - beta P^T)^{-1} k. Theorem 6.3 extends to matrix-coupled vector opinions under Assumption 6.2 (rho(B) < 1), with error C_inf * tau where C_inf = ||K||_inf. There are no experiments. The AI disclosure acknowledges that Assumption 6.2 itself was proposed by a generative AI tool.

Critical strengths
  1. The K_{d,d} lower-bound construction is elegant, short, and self-contained: the naive star construction fails, and the bipartite alternating repair argument is correct and insightful.

  2. The weighted potential h = (I - beta P^T)^{-1} k is derived cleanly ("potential from cost"), carries a random-walk interpretation, and is a reusable tool for other dynamic propagation problems.

  3. The paper is honest about its positioning relative to prior work and cost models (e.g., Remark 6.4 carefully distinguishes block-level vs scalar arithmetic, O(pT + p^2 W)).

Critical weaknesses
  1. The contribution is structurally thin relative to the claims. The tightness result lands only on the pre-existing unweighted bound and algorithm (both from prior work); the new bounds (Theorems 5.1 and 6.3) have no matching lower bounds, so the tightness insight produces no new algorithmic or practical consequence. The introduction's motivating question - the minimal algorithmic cost of repair - is not answered: tightness of a single algorithm's analysis is not problem-level optimality, and the abstract silently drops the paper's own concluding qualifier "for the algorithm". Moreover, with zero experiments, the de-forgetting / right-to-be-forgotten motivation is never formalized into any guarantee; it remains pure rhetoric.

  2. The most general result (Theorem 6.3) rests on Assumption 6.2, which is verified only for diagonal coupling (where it degenerates to the scalar case), is strictly stronger than the equilibrium-existence condition rho(T) < 1, has no non-diagonal instance, leaves the regime rho(T) < 1 <= rho(B) undiscussed, and yields an unbounded error constant C_inf = ||K||_inf that is never quantified. Per the paper's own AI disclosure, this assumption - the load-bearing condition of the flagship theorem - was proposed by a machine and is not validated on any non-trivial instance.

Questions for authors

(1) Can you provide any empirical evidence - e.g., measured push workload vs the bound on real weighted graphs, under adversarial and random update sequences?

(2) Is the weighted bound of Theorem 5.1 tight? If not, please state this openly as an open problem rather than letting the abstract's framing imply it.

(3) Please characterize Assumption 6.2: sufficient conditions, a failing non-diagonal instance, an upper bound on C_inf, and the behavior in the regime rho(T) < 1 <= rho(B).

(4) How do the results change under heterogeneous alpha_i (the standard FJ model), and can an adaptive adversary exceed the bound?

(5) Why is the cost of computing (or recomputing after graph changes) the potential h excluded from the accounting?

(6) The related-work claim that "no prior work handles arbitrary edge weights" does not cite EdgePush (Wang et al., VLDB 2022), which specifically studies push inefficiency on weighted graphs; please engage with it.

(7) Appendix D acknowledges that coordinate-wise scalar bounds are sharper (saving a factor p), so the practical significance of the block-wise treatment relative to p parallel scalar instances is unclear.

(8) For the de-forgetting motivation: what guarantee does l_inf repair accuracy give for certified deletion? Please formalize or soften the wording.

Reviewer_dpjWOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates dynamic graph propagation under node value updates while keeping the graph topology and propagation rule fixed. Building on the existing residual push framework, it establishes a tightness result for the work bound on unweighted graphs, introduces a discounted future work potential to analyze weighted graphs, and further extends the framework to vector valued opinions with matrix couplings. The theoretical analysis provides error and computational work guarantees under specific assumptions. However, the paper offers no experimental evaluation to demonstrate the practical efficiency or applicability of these extensions.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear problem formulation. The paper addresses a well defined problem of maintaining graph propagation under node value changes. The mathematical formulation and theoretical objectives are clearly presented.

  2. Systematic theoretical analysis. The proposed potential function extends existing complexity analysis to weighted graphs and matrix couplings. The paper provides formal guarantees for approximation error and propagation work under the stated assumptions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty. The core algorithm, residual invariant, and update mechanism are inherited from existing residual push methods, particularly InstantGNN. The main contributions consist of extending established complexity analyses to more general settings. These extensions offer limited new algorithmic insights, making the overall contribution insufficiently significant for ICLR.

  2. Lack of experimental validation. The paper provides no experiments, runtime comparisons, or scalability evaluations. Although computational efficiency and practical applications motivate the work, there is no evidence demonstrating that the proposed framework provides meaningful advantages over existing methods on realistic graphs.

  3. Unclear theoretical significance. The derived work bounds depend on graph properties, update magnitudes, and the error threshold, but their practical implications remain unclear. Moreover, the tightness result only characterizes the worst case behavior of the existing push algorithm, rather than establishing a lower bound for the dynamic propagation problem itself. The results therefore provide limited insight into the fundamental computational difficulty of the problem.

  4. Restrictive assumptions. The matrix extension requires the additional condition ρ(∣T∣)<1\rho(|T|)<1, which is not guaranteed by the original model assumptions. While this condition enables the potential analysis, the paper does not establish how broadly it holds for general matrix couplings. Consequently, the generality and applicability of the theoretical extension remain uncertain.

Questions for authors
  1. What fundamentally new algorithmic or theoretical insights does this work provide beyond existing residual push methods, particularly InstantGNN? Why are the proposed extensions sufficiently significant?

  2. Can the authors provide runtime and scalability comparisons with existing dynamic propagation methods on representative weighted graphs? Such results would help establish whether the theoretical extensions offer practical benefits.

  3. Under what graph structures and update regimes do the derived bounds imply meaningful improvements over recomputation? Can the authors clarify what the tightness result reveals about the inherent difficulty of dynamic propagation, rather than the specific push algorithm?

  4. How restrictive is the condition ρ(∣T∣)<1\rho(|T|)<1 for general matrix couplings? Can the authors characterize when it holds, provide examples where it fails, and clarify the implications for the applicability of the proposed framework?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.