- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes EI-NODE, a NODE-based sequential autoencoder for multi-population neural recordings. The latent state is split into blocks, one per recorded population. Each block’s time derivative is an additive sum of a diagonal linear self-term and one learned interaction function per source population. Every cross-population influence has a fixed sign, in the spirit of Dale's law. A block-masked, nonnegative linear readout ties each latent block to its labeled neurons. Because the derivative is a sum of per-source terms, it can be decomposed into population "influences" over time. The validation considers four examples (synthetic winner-take-all circuit, cell-type inference, mouse data, and CURBD surrogate) where the proposed method is compared against linear and RNN variants.
Critical strengths
Additive, sign-constrained decomposition gives a readable account of population interactions. Writing each population’s derivative as a sum of per-source terms lets the model attribute dynamics to specific source populations at each moment.
Sensible use of monotonic networks.
Validation against ground-truth currents in the synthetic setting. Comparing learned influences with actual synaptic currents goes beyond reconstruction accuracy. The reported correlations are high for all nine source–target pairs.
Handling of cell-class-specific perturbations. Delivering optogenetic input to the targeted inhibitory block is a sensible use of the population-partitioned latent space.
Critical weaknesses
Limited novelty: a recombination of existing components, where each ingredient exists already in the literature. Replacing linear cross-population maps with sign-wrapped monotonic MLPs is a reasonable engineering choice, but it isn’t a substantial methodological advance.
Weak grounding in neurophysiology and in the population-modeling literature. Beyond the E/I distinction and Dale’s law, the model has no physiological content: It doesn’t say what level of description its latent blocks represent (micro-circuit, mesoscale population, or region). It doesn’t consider hierarchy, laminar structure, or interneuron diversity.
Closest prior work in computational neuroscience is not cited. Wilson–Cowan population equations, neural mass models, and dynamic causal modeling (DCM) all describe E/I populations with first-order ODEs, learned time constants, and sign-fixed, monotone (sigmoidal) couplings. Several of them are fit to data. EI-NODE is structurally a Wilson–Cowan-type system with learned, flexible coupling functions, but the paper never positions itself against this literature.
Odd framing of the motivation. The introduction presents dynamical-systems explanations as something “invited” by recent large-scale recordings. Dynamical systems have been central to computational neuroscience since its inception: Hodgkin–Huxley, Wilson–Cowan, Amari, Hopfield networks, and balanced E/I networks. This framing is historically inaccurate, and it is likely why the most relevant E/I population-dynamics literature is missing from the related work.
Questions for authors
Identifiability. How do you resolve the offset and scale ambiguities in the influence decomposition, i.e., constants trading off between E, I, and self-terms, and scaling between latents and the readout?
Fixed points and stability. Were fixed points computed in the full latent space rather than read off 2D slices at mean I activity? What are their stability properties, and do they match the ground-truth attractors of the Wang circuit?
Relation to population models. How does EI-NODE relate to Wilson–Cowan, neural mass, and DCM models? What does it offer beyond fitting such a model with flexible monotone coupling functions? Why sum per-source nonlinear terms instead of applying a nonlinearity to summed input, and how does this choice affect what interactions the model can represent?
Unconstrained baseline on real data. Could an unconstrained NODE with an input channel be fit to the climbing/optogenetics data to quantify the accuracy cost of the E/I constraints? Given that Linear EI-NODE matches EI-NODE there, what evidence shows the nonlinear interactions are needed for real recordings?
8 comments
Response to Reviewer hLQn (2/3)
Framing of the motivation: Dynamical systems have been central to computational neuroscience from its foundations: the Hodgkin–Huxley model of the action potential, WC and Amari's population and neural-field models, Hopfield's attractor networks, and balanced E/I network theory. We did not intend to suggest that dynamical explanations originate with large-scale recordings, and we have rewritten the introduction accordingly.
The revised motivation makes a narrower claim we believe is accurate. Classical E/I population models were mostly specified from theory and evaluated against aggregate signals or a few summary statistics. In those settings, the cell-type identity of a population and the form of its interactions could not be checked directly. Large-scale recordings with putative or optogenetically identified cell types now make it possible to infer E/I population dynamics and interaction functions directly from single-unit activities. EI-NODE is designed for this data-driven setting. It keeps the core structural assumptions of the classical models (cell-type-specific populations, sign-fixed and monotone interactions, leaky first-order dynamics) and learns the interaction functions from data.
We also agree this framing contributed to the omission the reviewer identified. The revised introduction now motivates EI-NODE from the E/I population-dynamics tradition, and the new related-work subsection (see point 3) positions it against Wilson–Cowan, neural mass models and DCM.
Identifiability: Identifiability is a known issue (Prinz et al., 2004; Das & Fiete, 2020) that we mitigate with optogenetic perturbations, which shrink the solution set (Basrai et al., 2026; Nejatbakhsh & Wang, 2025). A constant can be shifted between fjE, fjI, and fjj without changing the vector field; all quantities we interpret (coupling signs and shapes, fixed points, winner-take-all structure) depend on how couplings vary across latent state, not their absolute level, and we report influences centered at the mean latent state. Each population's latents can be rescaled with an inverse rescaling of its readout, as in any latent model; comparisons between inputs onto the same population are unaffected, and we standardize latents to unit variance for reporting. Empirically, seeds reaching comparable held-out likelihood give the same influence functions and fixed points; we use the best-likelihood fit for the dynamics analyses.
Limited novelty: As described above, we now more clearly describe the additions of our model relative to existing model classes. And while this may be seen as an engineering achievement of constrained-yet-interpretable coupling parameterizations, empirically we see much better model fits for EI-NODE than for all other model baselines (in-particular the new Wilson-Cowan baseline, see Supplementary Section E.5), where ablations show that parametrizing the link functions with learned monotonic networks are the reason for this performance increase (see Supplementary Table 7).
Grounding in neurophysiology: This model has flexibility to use such biological information, and we do in fact take full advantage of the physiological information available to us within our given dataset, using it to constrain the connectivity between regions in our model (see Section 4.1 L453). If there was additional information available in alternate datasets, it could be incorporated (e.g. constraints on dynamics).
Fixed points and stability: The ground-truth Wang circuit commits to a decision towards the end of trials, so we used this timing to inform where we looked for fixed points in the E1/E2 plane. We found that our models' latent activity at the I value corresponding to this timing had net-zero influences, and these results were robust to nearby I values, confirming the agreement with the canonical circuit. In the linear and RNN baseline models, nearby slices continue to have non-zero influences, showing how these methods do not recapitulate the underlying dynamics.
Response to Reviewer hLQn (3/3)
Unconstrained baseline on real data: We fit an unconstrained NODE with an input channel, free of readout and E/I dynamics constraints, to the climbing/optogenetics data and found only slight gains over EI-NODE. The unconstrained linear NODE and nonlinear NODE perform about the same, but Linear EI-NODE fits the perturbation data worse than EI-NODE, indicating that the nonlinearity helps performance under the E/I constraints (see Supplementary Table 8).
Supplementary Table 8. Single-trial fit of E/I-constrained and unconstrained models. Pseudo-, mean ± SD across 12 models (3 data splits × 4 training seeds). Each model's score is averaged over the two optogenetic sessions. Unconstrained models have no E/I sign constraints, no population structure, input to all latents, and an unmasked readout with weights of either sign.
| Model | Climbing | Perturbation |
|---|---|---|
| EI-NODE | 0.053 ± 0.005 | 0.156 ± 0.016 |
| Linear EI-NODE | 0.050 ± 0.005 | 0.141 ± 0.020 |
| Unconstrained NODE | 0.063 ± 0.012 | 0.168 ± 0.008 |
| Unconstrained linear NODE | 0.060 ± 0.008 | 0.166 ± 0.006 |
References:
- Wilson, H. R., & Cowan, J. D. (1972). Excitatory and inhibitory interactions in localized populations of model neurons. Biophysical Journal.
- Miller, K. D., & Fumarola, F. (2012). Mathematical equivalence of two common forms of firing rate models of neural networks. Neural Computation.
- Marreiros, A. C., Daunizeau, J., Kiebel, S. J., & Friston, K. J. (2008). Population dynamics: Variance and the sigmoid activation function. NeuroImage.
- Jha, A., Gupta, D., Brody, C. D., & Pillow, J. W. (2024). Disentangling the Roles of Distinct Cell Classes with Cell-Type Dynamical Systems. NeurIPS 2024 (Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 37).
- Song, H. F., Yang, G. R., & Wang, X. J. (2016). Training Excitatory-Inhibitory Recurrent Neural Networks for Cognitive Tasks: A Simple and Flexible Framework. PLoS Computational Biology.
- Prinz, A. A., Bucher, D., & Marder, E. (2004). Similar network activity from disparate circuit parameters. Nature Neuroscience.
- Das, A., & Fiete, I. R. (2020). Systematic errors in connectivity inferred from activity in strongly recurrent networks. Nature Neuroscience.
- Basrai, D., Lee, J., Kristl, A., Wang, P., Miri, A., & Glaser, J. I. (2026). Constraining inference of across-region interactions using neural activity perturbations. bioRxiv.
- Nejatbakhsh, A., & Wang, Y. (2025). Identifying Neural Dynamics Using Interventional State Space Models. ICML 2025.
Response to Reviewer hLQn (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for their detailed and thoughtful review. We are pleased the reviewer highlighted the interpretability of our additive, sign-constrained decomposition as a key strength. Additionally, we appreciate their positive evaluation of our monotonic network formulation, our validation against ground-truth synaptic currents, and our approach to incorporating cell-class-specific optogenetic perturbations within the population-partitioned latent space. Below are our responses to the reviewer's comments and questions:
Relation to Wilson–Cowan, neural mass models, and DCM: We thank the reviewer for this point; we agree the paper should position EI-NODE relative to the mean-field literature, and we have added a dedicated related-work subsection and a new baseline.
Similarities with Wilson–Cowan, neural mass models, and DCM. EI-NODE's latent dynamics (Eq. 4 L145) are structurally a current-based Wilson–Cowan system, τdtdx=−x+∑Wf(x) (Wilson et al. 1972; Supplementary Eq. 15), which is equivalent to the more familiar rate-based form (Miller & Fumarola, 2012). The softplus-wrapped monotone MLPs, fIE=softplus(f~IE) and fEI=−softplus(f~EI), play the role of the classical sign-fixed, monotone gain function. EI-NODE differs from that literature in four ways:
Related work section. We have added a prior work section that details the related mean-field models and how this work builds on classical methods (see Section 2.5 L203).
Existing baselines already relate to the classical models. Our cell-type-constrained linear baseline (Jha et al., 2024) corresponds to a linearized E/I population model, comparable to the neuronal model of two-state DCM (Marreiros et al., 2008). Our EI-RNN (Song et al., 2016) is a high-dimensional Dale's-law rate network with a tanh.
New mean-field model baselines. To test the specific question the reviewer raises, we add a current-form Wilson–Cowan baseline (WC) and several variants. It is identical to EI-NODE (same encoder, masked readout, training and model selection), except that each f~θjk is replaced by a parametric sigmoid with a sign-fixed scalar weight. This isolates the contribution of flexible coupling functions. We find that this WC model fits the perturbation data much worse than EI-NODE, and fits the climbing data slightly worse (see Supplementary Table 7).
Per-source nonlinearity vs. nonlinearity on summed input: We trained variations of EI-NODE and Wilson–Cowan (WC) models to determine the effect of per-source nonlinear terms relative to a nonlinearity applied to summed input. We found that, for EI-NODE's learned coupling functions, the summed form fits consistently worse (see Supplementary Figure 7, Supplementary Table 7). It also loses the exact split of each population's input by source. Our per-source design therefore improves performance and allows interpretable influence analysis.
Supplementary Table 7. Held-out (validation) single-trial pseudo-R2 on climbing and optogenetic perturbation trials, averaged over two sessions from two mice. Mean ± s.e.m. over 12 runs (3 data splits × 4 training seeds). All models: 10 E / 5 I latents per region, matched training.