- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper applies Lagrangian neural networks (LNNs) and Hamiltonian neural networks (HNNs) to a one-dimensional damped harmonic oscillator and examines their behavior through comparisons with an undamped oscillator. It conducts experiments under several conditions, including with and without noise, and discusses the non-uniqueness of Lagrangians and the distinction between the Hamiltonian and physical energy in a damped system.
Critical strengths
The paper has educational value as an implementation example of LNNs and HNNs using a simple damped oscillator. However, this alone does not sufficiently support the novelty or significance of the research contribution.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution beyond applying existing LNNs and HNNs to a particular damped oscillator is unclear.
The paper presents experiments on a one-dimensional damped harmonic oscillator, varying time inputs, momentum representations, loss functions, and the presence or absence of noise. However, it is unclear what research question these comparisons answer or what they newly establish. Although the paper demonstrates that the target system’s behavior can be approximated under individual configurations, it does not adequately explain the insights obtained by bringing these results together.
Prior LNN and HNN approaches already address dissipative systems, including references [12] and [13], and HNNs with time as an input are also considered by Desai et al. (2021). The paper does not sufficiently establish a new methodology or theoretical result beyond these approaches, or design insights that can be reused for other problems. The experiments are also limited to a single oscillator and include no direct comparison with existing methods, making it difficult to assess what additional value the various configurations provide over prior work. In its current form, the research significance beyond a case study presenting individual application results remains unclear.
Additional reference: Desai, S., Mattheakis, M., Sondak, D., Protopapas, P., and Roberts, S. (2021). Port-Hamiltonian Neural Networks for Learning Explicit Time-Dependent Dynamical Systems.
Questions for authors
-
What new insights, methods, or theoretical results can be reused for other problems without relying on formulations or known parameters specific to this oscillator? Please clarify the contribution beyond applying existing LNNs and HNNs to an individual problem.
-
Please explain how the initial phases and initial states were selected, and the rationale for the number of trajectories and the sampling intervals. How did you assess the effects of these choices on state-space coverage and predictive performance?