- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This article studies the phishing detection method, particularly about the training dataset. It proposes a Siamese structure for the quasi GT collection while also claims that a new evaluation method is proposed.
Critical strengths
The strength of this article perhaps lies in the Siamese model for the quasi GTs. Taken texts and URGs as two types of input, this model helps prepare the GT automatically.
Critical weaknesses
This article is hard for me from different domain. I do have some concerns.
- The main Siamese structure is rather rough without enough details. I cannot clearly see the network structure even though the texts themselves try to explain it. In addition, I don't know how to train it. In addition, what is the loss?. More details and visual explanation can be better for me.
- The article is very boring because there is no enough graphical interpretations on the proposed principles. For example, what's the difference between a total GT and a quasi GT? What is the main pipeline of this work? What is the target of this study? Those missing details make the article very different to follow.
- The conclusion is too long. If you want to discuss something, it is better to have an independent (sub-)section on it.
- There is no enough theoretical analysis on the proposed method. It is more like a engineering work rather than a scientific study.
- The experiments are rough and simple. Only three experiments are difficult to demonstrate the particular merits proposed by the article. In addtion, ablation study are generally required to show the advantages of your methodology.
Questions for authors
See my comments on the weakness for my questions. I am not from this particular domain but your writing and presentation at least make the article difficult to accept.