- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work introduces Deep Siamese Generative Adversarial Clustering (DSGAC), which casts clustering as a pairwise‑data generation process from category variables to instance variables within an expectation‑maximization (EM) framework. Its E‑step encodes instance‑to‑instance relationships using a category‑aware conditional joint probability matrix, and the M‑step fits data distributions via adversarial training.
Critical strengths
(1)This paper reads well and organize in a good shape.
Critical weaknesses
(1)The combination of GAN and GMM-based clustering is not novel. ClusterGAN [AAAI 2019] or (“Mixture of GANs for Clustering, IJCAI”) already explored latent space clustering with GMM sampling. The Siamese architecture and adversarial clustering loss in this paper represent incremental engineering adaptations rather than a fundamental conceptual contribution. The paper does not sufficiently articulate how its approach differs in kind (not just degree) from prior generative clustering methods. The novelty of this paper is far from the accept bar.
(2)The largest dataset used is CIFAR-100 (60K samples). The paper lacks evaluation on ImageNet-1K or larger-scale benchmarks, which are increasingly standard for demonstrating scalability and practical relevance in deep clustering. This is a significant limitation given that the paper claims “superiority” over state-of-the-art methods.
(3)Several recent and directly relevant methods are missing, including TAC (ICML 2024), CLUDI (ICML 2025) and more (listed bellow). These represent different but important technical directions (external guidance and diffusion-based clustering, respectively). The comparison set is skewed toward older baselines, which weakens the empirical claims.
[1]Universal Guideline-Driven Image Clustering via a Hybrid LLM Agent, CVPR 2026
[2]Semantic-Augmented Image Clustering via Adaptive Multi-Modal Collaboration, AAAI 2026
[3]Parameter-Free Clustering via Self-Supervised Consensus Maximization, AAAI 2026
[4]DeepDP-TGMM: Amortized Non- Parametric Clustering for Hyperspherical Self-Supervised Representations, CVPR 2026
(4)The paper does not address the well-known training instability associated with GANs in clustering tasks. No convergence curves, variance across runs, or stability analysis are provided. The reported stable accuracy is therefore difficult to assess. I recommend the authors provide multiple-run statistics (mean ± std) and discuss how they mitigate GAN training instability.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weakness.