- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors proposed to encode the pointmap of a 3D geometry via implicit neural representation. A neural network is trained to predict the the pointmap values while the remaining residual is entropy encoded. The implicit neural network training is done with different optimizers and with 8-bit quantization of the network itself. The authors reported modest compression of the saved information across multiple different datasets, with the rate of the compression varies between them.
Critical strengths
The paper attempted to perform pointmap compression with a neural network, while implicit neural network compression isn’t a new field by itself, the compression of a pointmap is a relatively new task, if done well, can be beneficial for 3D geometry representation.
The selected evaluation set is relatively thorough with different scenes included.
Critical weaknesses
The empirical performance gain (compression rate) is very limited and only works in certain datasets, the rest has nearly no improvement.
The authors did discuss the encoding and decoding time related to the compression and decompression. However, the reported numbers does seem to be reasonable given today’s library and hardware. See more in the questions.
Questions for authors
Do the authors have further analysis on why some datasets are more compressible than the others. More specifically, why the proposed method works better on some datasets than the others.
The proposed method also includes the entropy encoding/decoding part, does the measured time include that as part of the process.
For the baseline comparison, JPEG XL as example, what kind of library, setting, thread, hardware (with dedicated hardware media codec used or not) leads to the reported values. The author reported encoding and decoding speed for the images are a bit too slow, particularly considering how low resolution the images are.