- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an adaptive spectral filtering method for time-series adversarial training to improve clean-data performance while preserving robustness. It uses KL divergence for spectral alignment and zero-phase filtering to preserve gradient direction. Experiments on nine datasets demonstrate improved clean-test performance and competitive adversarial robustness.
Critical strengths
-
Addressing the trade-off between clean accuracy and adversarial robustness is particularly important for time-series applications. By introducing input-adaptive spectral filtering, this work offers a practical way to generate adversarial perturbations that better preserve the spectral characteristics of the original signals.
-
A notable strength of this work lies in its extensive experimental evaluation across nine datasets and five health-related applications. The consistent improvements in clean-test performance, together with comprehensive ablation studies and robustness evaluations, provide convincing evidence of the method’s effectiveness.
-
Beyond empirical performance, the authors establish a theoretical justification for zero-phase filtering and conduct physician-based assessments of perturbation realism. These complementary analyses strengthen the reliability of the proposed method and support its potential applicability to physiological time-series data.
Critical weaknesses
-
The Introduction does not adequately establish the rationale behind the proposed method. It remains unclear why adaptive filtering is preferred over conventional filtering approaches and how spectral alignment contributes to improving adversarial training. These aspects should be more clearly motivated to strengthen the logical foundation of the work.
-
Table 3 shows that the proposed method performs worse than some baselines on certain datasets, particularly Chapman, but these results are not sufficiently discussed. Moreover, the statement “Our method improves clean-test performance over baselines” in Section 4 appears overly general, as the proposed method does not consistently outperform all baselines. The authors should provide further analysis of these limitations and make their claims more precise.
-
The Conclusion mainly highlights the advantages of the proposed method without adequately discussing its limitations. A more balanced discussion of potential weaknesses and scenarios where the method may be less effective would strengthen the paper.
-
Several inconsistencies can be found in the reference list, including variations in citation styles and missing publication details. A more consistent and standardized bibliography would improve the paper’s presentation and readability.
-
The novelty of the proposed method remains somewhat unclear, particularly in comparison with existing approaches such as FA and IFAP, which also consider input-dependent frequency constraints. While the authors employ a learnable spectral filter and KL-based regularization, it is not sufficiently explained how these designs offer fundamentally new contributions beyond prior work. Further clarification of the methodological differences would help establish the originality of the approach.
-
While Theorem 2.2 demonstrates that zero-phase filtering preserves the original perturbation direction by minimizing angular deviation, it remains unclear how this property translates into improved adversarial effectiveness. The authors should further explain the relationship between gradient-direction preservation and adversarial loss maximization to provide stronger theoretical support for the proposed method.
-
A gap remains between the theoretical formulation and the practical optimization procedure. While Equations (1) and (2) define a spectrally constrained minimax objective, the implemented method relies on a soft KL regularization term without explicitly enforcing the spectral constraint. The authors should further clarify how the practical algorithm approximates the proposed constrained objective.
Questions for authors
-
The authors should further clarify the methodological novelty of the proposed approach compared with existing input-dependent frequency methods, particularly the contributions beyond learnable filtering and KL-based regularization.
-
Further analysis is needed to explain why the proposed method performs worse than PGD on certain datasets and whether these results reveal potential limitations of the spectral alignment strategy.
-
It remains unclear how the minimum-angle property contributes to adversarial loss maximization and to what extent the practical soft KL regularization approximates the proposed constrained optimization objective.
Discussion encouraged during this period!
Hi all reviewers,
We’re about halfway through the discussion period. This is a friendly reminder to check the authors' replies. If the authors have answered questions or responded to critiques in the reviews, please leave a comment for the authors!
Thank you so much!
Best, Your AC