- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents LAP3 - method for 3D geometry and panoptic reconstruction from aerial imagery. It utilizes strong backbones such as SAM3 and VGGT to create a pipeline for the large scale aerial reconstruction, based on panoptic prediction to get better reconstruction and alignment.
Critical strengths
- The method seems to work well on the specific use case, get’s SOTA results on the validation set and the qualitative results show a very good reconstruction quality.
- The method is detailed and the pipeline is well explained. The ablation study justifies each step of the pipeline, which is the core novelty of the paper.
Critical weaknesses
- Validation - Validation is done on 6 scenes which is extremely small validation set. Moreover, the validation set is out of distribution for any other model then the presented method, while it is from the exact distribution of the training set of the method. Thus, it is not clear if the improvement comes from the new pipeline or from the training and validation set distribution. Also missing strong baselines - MapAnything, Pi3, and DepthAnything. Missing an analysis of runtime and memory, which are the bottlenecks of large scene reconstruction.
- Although the pipeline is detailed and the parts of the pipeline are justified in the ablation, it has limited novelty and it is not clear if the full pipeline is necessary or it can be learned without this pipeline at all using an existing method on the training dataset.
Questions for authors
Can you explain the validation set choice? There is a test set for your training dataset (UAVFF3D), why not using it too? UAVFF3D paper shows that MapAnything, DepthAnything, VGGT and Pi3 works well on this kind of data, especially after finetuning.