- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper attemps to propose a new concept, latent behavioural state, for domain generalization. represents the real variant element under domain shift, rather than the shift of relationship between label and domain . To align representations conditioned on the same , the authors refer to a surrogate that could represent the distribution in latent behavioural state. The optimization function thus focuses on tightening the surrogate cluster range and on tightening the representations within each cluster.
Critical strengths
- The concept of within-class variation and domain-specific nuisance provides a meaningful ingisht for domain generalization.
- The experiment protocol follows the domainbed guidelines to isolate the influence of hyperparameter selections.
Critical weaknesses
The key weakness lies on unclear definition and time-series data bias. please see my questions for details.
Questions for authors
-
Unclear definition The behavioural state is insufficiently specified: what constitutes a state, what information should be preserved, and how it differs from other invariant concepts (e.g. the "invariant information" concept in "Bayesian Domain Invariant Learning via Posterior Generalization of Parameter Distributions"). The algorithm constructs same-label local references without establishing their relationship to . The conceptual distinction from MatchDG’s object-conditioned invariance and approximate matching also needs clarification.
-
Weak connection to time-series structure LBNS uses generic latent-space neighbourhoods, averaging, and penalties while the only temporal modelling comes from the encoder. In other words, the algorithm works on all kinds of data and currently there is no specific adaptions to time series data. This raises my concern that current experiments are manually selected and LBNS fails on other common datasets. The authors should explain and demonstrate what makes the contribution specific to time series, or substantiate its broader applicability through DomainBed experiments on PACS, VLCS, Office-Home, Terra Incognita, and DomainNet.
-
Insufficient baseline DIVERSIFY is the only explicitly time-series-specific DG comparison. The remaining comparisons are out-of-date, general objectives, which are orinigally designed for image data. Time-series DG methods and up-to-date approaches are required. If possible, also include well-established baselines such as SWAD MIRO.
-
Unestablished theoretical premise Proposition 2 assumes that the local reference approximates the behavioural component with small error. However, Neighbourhood tightness does not mean zero-nuisance, leaving a substantial gap between the theoretical assumptions and the implemented estimator.
-
Inconclusive ablations Table 7 does not clearly isolate locality from RBF weighting, and its paired intervals include zero. Table 8 uses identical coefficients for direct and residual alignment, rather than select hyperparameters independently. Matched controls and fully hyperparameter-selections are required to show the attribute of conditioning granularity and residualisation.
-
Minor writing issues The abstract and introduction use notations to simplify expresions, but the intended concepts are not clearly explained before. Figure 1 contains text that is extreme small, and the connection between the independence target (top) and algorithmic procedure (bottom) is unclear. The explanation of how tightness loss prevents collapse also needs clarification.
We thank the reviewer for the helpful comments.
Unclear definition [...]. Behavioural state s denotes the underlying process condition, such as operating regime, load or fault severity. We aim to preserve meaningful within-class differences even when they can reveal domain identity (lines 053–061).
We now cite Shen et al. (2023), arXiv:2310.16277, and clarify the distinction (lines 068–071): its domain-invariant information Dc has the same distribution across domains, whereas s need not.
The algorithm constructs [...]. Same-label membership ensures task compatibility, not state identity. The relationship to s rests on the local-coherence assumption and bounded reference-error model in Proposition 2; the independent descriptor diagnostic supports behavioural comparability.
MatchDG directly regularises representations across inferred object matches. LBNS instead aligns residuals around sample-specific local references, allowing locally explained differences mi−mj between comparable but non-identical states to remain (lines 127–136).
Weak connection to [...] We clarified the motivation in the introduction (lines 053–061) and Related Work (lines 133–136), and the dataset-selection rationale at lines 315–319.
Cyber-physical systems generate sensor time series in which meaningful differences in load, control or regime may identify the installation. Direct alignment can suppress these differences alongside nuisance; LBNS aligns residuals around sample-specific local references, allowing locally explained differences between comparable states to remain.
Our empirical claims concern cross-system time series generalisation, where substantial OOD challenges remain (Wu et al., 2026). Encoder agnosticism does not imply selective reporting or failure on untested modalities. Image-domain experiments would assess broader applicability beyond our current scope, a boundary now acknowledged in the limitations.
Insufficient baseline [...]. We added SWAD, CCIL (sensor time series activity recognition), and FIXED (a general DG method evaluated on time series). ERM, DANN, CCA and CDANN isolate no suppression, global suppression and class-conditioned suppression; MatchDG tests finer correspondence. The ten baselines cover both mechanism controls and DG approaches. MIRO requires a pretrained reference, introducing pretraining-data and model choices beyond our from-scratch protocol.
Unestablished theoretical [...] Reference accuracy is an assumption, not a consequence of neighbourhood tightness (lines 308–310 and 1025). Proposition 2 does not require nuisance-free references: with mi=a(si)+ei, reference error enters through ei−ej, bounded by 2η, and a common additive bias cancels. The result characterises approximation conditions and errors; it does not establish that neighbourhood averaging recovers the behavioural component.
Descriptors assess behavioural coherence and alignment ablations assess residualisation; neither directly estimates the unobserved reference error. We have added clarifications (lines 308-310 and 1025).
Inconclusive ablations [...] Full LBNS versus local-uniform tests RBF weighting; local-uniform versus class-uniform compares local and class-wide references. Full LBNS has higher predictive point estimates on both tasks, but paired intervals include zero. These ten-fold controls are exploratory and do not establish component necessity (Appendix A.8, Table 8, lines 957–981).
Table 8 uses identical [...] Equal coefficients in Table 9 need not imply equal regularisation strength. We therefore selected the direct-alignment coefficient by source-validation ROC AUC per fold, keeping the structure coefficient fixed. LBNS has higher mean ROC/PR AUC on five of six datasets and lower domain recoverability on all six (Table 11).
Minor writing issues [...] The introduction now defines behavioural state and nuisance before the equations, with a district heating example distinguishing sensor-calibration offsets from meaningful process changes.
Figure 1 contains [...]. We enlarged Figure 1, added connecting arrows, and explained that local neighbourhoods proxy behavioural similarity, linking the population target to the practical surrogate.
The explanation [...]. Thank you for highlighting this inconsistency. Our wording should have more clearly distinguished the roles of the losses. The structure term encourages compact local groupings among selected same-label neighbours, while the supervised task loss opposes collapse that would erase class discrimination. Residual alignment penalises cross-domain residual mismatch without requiring local behavioural references to coincide. The structure term therefore serves as a local-cohesion regulariser. We have clarified these roles at lines 217 and 223.