acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

SkillProj: Skill Retrieval by Projection onto Requirement Subspaces

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Skill-based recursive self-improvement (RSI) relies on retrieving accumulated procedures as task requirements evolve. Whole-request encoding compresses multiple needs into one direction, while maximum per-requirement similarity retains only the strongest individual match. We introduce SkillProj, which represents complete active requirements by their vector span and retrieves skills through projection, requirement-level reranking, and residual diversity. We extend public SkillRouter, SkillRet, and R3-Skill resources into three trajectory benchmarks with 429 five-turn dialogues and libraries of up to 79,141 skills. With GPT-5.6 Luna, SkillProj achieves the highest Recall@10 and full coverage among eight methods on all three benchmarks. Averaged equally across benchmarks, its Recall@10 exceeds the strongest baseline by 8.16, 5.30, and 5.95 percentage points under GPT-5.6 Luna, DeepSeek V4.1 Flash, and GLM-5.3-Flash, respectively. With DeepSeek V4.1 Flash and GLM-5.3-Flash, it uses 33–34% fewer generation tokens than SkillDreamer. Agents using SkillProj also achieve the highest content accuracy in 1,128 end-to-end executions. Matched ablations support representing active requirements as a subspace and retaining requirement-level matching during reranking.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
skill retrieval, LLM agents, requirement subspaces, subspace projection, multi-turn interaction

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_CiMYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies skill retrieval when a user's requirements change during a conversation, motivated by skill-based recursive self-improvement (RSI). It argues that encoding the whole request as one vector compresses several needs into a single direction, while per-requirement MaxSim keeps only the strongest individual match. SkillProj encodes each active requirement separately with a frozen SkillRouter encoder, builds an orthonormal basis of their span by SVD, and scores every skill by projection membership, the squared norm of its projection onto that subspace. The top 50 candidates are then reranked with a frozen SkillRouter reranker, taking the maximum relevance over requirements. Finally, a DPP-style greedy step selects ten skills, using a residual kernel that down-weights the shared requirement component. To evaluate this setting, the authors build three trajectory benchmarks from SkillRouter, SkillRet and R3-Skill resources: 143 base tasks, each with three five-turn paths of additions, withdrawals and replacements, giving 429 terminal requests over libraries of up to 79,141 skills.

The paper claims the following contributions: (1) A requirement-subspace retrieval pipeline with projection scoring, requirement-level reranking and residual set selection. (2) Three trajectory benchmarks with evolving requirements: SkillRouter-Trajectory, SkillRet-Trajectory and R3-Skill-Trajectory. (3) Evidence that SkillProj improves mean Recall@10 under three language models, with matched ablations naming subspace retrieval and requirement-level reranking as the main contributors.

Retrieval is evaluated at the terminal state with eight top-10 metrics against seven baselines (Dense, SkillRouter, DSR, SkillSight, SkillDreamer, Field-Aware and SkillFlow), all using the same frozen encoder. With GPT-5.6 Luna, SkillProj leads Recall@10 on all three benchmarks: 80.61 on SR, 93.25 on Ret and 79.56 on R3. Averaged equally over the benchmarks, its Recall@10 exceeds the strongest baseline by 8.16, 5.30 and 5.95 points under Luna, DeepSeek V4.1 Flash and GLM-5.3-Flash. Confidence intervals come from a bootstrap over 42 to 45 shared-skill task families. An end-to-end study runs 1,128 executions on 47 SR tasks, where SkillProj answers 92 of 141 requests correctly against 89 for the next best method. Ablations on SR replace projection with whole-request or MaxSim retrieval, replace per-requirement reranking with whole-request reranking, and remove the DPP step.

Critical strengths

The clearest strength is the matched ablation on SR. With encoder, budgets, reranker and selector fixed, replacing projection retrieval with whole-request retrieval lowers Recall@10 by 8.12 points, and replacing per-requirement reranking with whole-request reranking lowers it by 7.63 points. Both intervals exclude zero. This shows that representing active requirements separately, rather than as one merged request, is the main source of the gain. It is a simple and practical lesson for skill routing in multi-need requests. The ablation is run only on SR with Luna, but the mean recall gain itself appears under all three language models.

The second strength is the benchmark design. Requests change through additions, withdrawals, replacements and restorations, and retrieval is scored against the requirements that remain active at the end. This tests something that static skill retrieval benchmarks do not: whether a method drops skills for withdrawn work and keeps skills for retained work. The paper also reports full metric tables for every model and benchmark, with family-level intervals, so the reader can see where SkillProj does not help.

Critical weaknesses

The main weakness is the comparison protocol behind the headline numbers. In the Luna setting on SR, SkillProj uses requirement lists maintained deterministically from the benchmark's public edits, while the baselines work from LLM-generated complete requests. This gives SkillProj a cleaner view of the task structure. When the requirements are extracted by an LLM, as in the DeepSeek and GLM settings, the gain drops by about a third, and SkillProj loses to SkillDreamer on R3. The end-to-end study adds to the doubt. SkillProj and five baselines ran in separate batches, and most paired accuracy intervals include zero. The abstract's claims of the "highest" recall and content accuracy are therefore stronger than the evidence.

The second weakness is limited novelty relative to the evidence. Projection membership is taken from Ishibashi et al. (2024), the reranker and encoder are SkillRouter's, and the residual DPP step adds nothing measurable. The remaining new element, scoring candidates per requirement and taking the maximum, is close to MaxSim at the reranking stage. The benchmarks are small, LLM-assisted, and drawn from three existing resources, and the RSI motivation is never tested. Taken together, I see a reasonable engineering pipeline evaluated on a small new benchmark, which is not enough for acceptance at a top venue.

Questions for authors

N/A

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on our response

Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback. We have added a shared-input comparison to address your fairness concern and would be grateful for your thoughts on our response when convenient. Best regards,

Reviewer_CyYUOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies skill retrieval for conversational requests with multiple active requirements that may be added, removed, or replaced over time. SkillProj represents active requirements as a subspace and retrieves candidate skills according to their projection onto this subspace, followed by requirement-level reranking and residual selection.

The authors construct trajectory versions of SkillRouter, SkillRet, and R3-Skill and evaluate eight methods under three language models. SkillProj achieves strong Recall@10 and full-coverage results, with matched ablations supporting subspace retrieval and requirement-level reranking. An end-to-end execution evaluation is also provided.

Critical strengths
  1. The retrieval gains are substantial, and the controlled ablations provide direct evidence that subspace retrieval and requirement-level reranking contribute to the improvements.

  2. The paper addresses an important setting in which user requirements evolve over multiple turns rather than remaining static.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The use of subspace representations is not itself new: prior work has already represented multiple inputs through their vector span and used subspace-membership scoring. The main novelty here therefore lies in adapting this idea to evolving requirement-based skill retrieval and combining it with the proposed reranking pipeline and trajectory benchmarks.

  2. The evaluation benchmarks are constructed through controlled additions, withdrawals, replacements, and confirmations of explicit requirements, which closely matches SkillProj’s modeling assumption that active requirements can be represented separately and combined through a shared subspace. It is therefore unclear how well the gains would transfer to naturally occurring conversations where requirements may be implicit, entangled, or ambiguously revised.

  3. The end-to-end execution improvements are much less conclusive than the retrieval improvements. SkillProj obtains the best point estimate, but paired confidence intervals against several strong baselines include zero, so the practical downstream benefit is not yet established with comparable confidence.

Questions for authors
  1. Do the authors have evidence on naturally occurring multi-turn requests or independently collected agent trajectories, where requirements may be implicit or less cleanly separable?

  2. Can the authors analyze more directly when improved retrieval translates into improved execution success, for example by relating full target-skill coverage to downstream success or by evaluating smaller retrieval budgets?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on our response

Thank you again for your helpful suggestions. We have added the coverage–execution analysis you suggested and would be grateful if you could take a look at our response when convenient. Please let us know if any concerns remain. Best regards,

Thank you for the detailed response and additional analysis. The coverage–execution results are helpful.

However, I still have concerns about generalization to naturally occurring conversations and the limited evidence for downstream execution gains. I will maintain my current rating.

Reviewer_DkA5OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SkillProj, a skill retrieval method designed for dynamically evolving task requirements. It represents active requirements as a vector subspace and retrieves relevant skills through projection scoring, requirement-level reranking, and residual diversity selection. The authors construct multi-turn dialogue benchmarks based on three public datasets. Experimental results demonstrate competitive retrieval performance across different language model settings.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses skill retrieval under evolving task requirements, which is a practically relevant problem with clear motivation.

  2. The proposed method is straightforward, using requirement subspaces to preserve semantic information across multiple requirements, combined with reranking and diversity selection to improve retrieval performance.

  3. The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive, including ablation studies, statistical analysis, and end-to-end task evaluation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The three core components of SkillProj are largely based on existing techniques. The main contribution is their integration into multi-requirement skill retrieval rather than a novel learning mechanism or retrieval optimization method. Therefore, the methodological novelty is limited.

  2. The paper aims to retrieve complementary skills for multiple active requirements. However, the final reranking score only considers whether a skill is relevant to at least one requirement, without explicitly accounting for coverage across different requirements.

  3. Table 5 reports that SkillProj reduces generation tokens by approximately 33%–34% compared to SkillDreamer. However, this comparison does not account for the complete computational cost of the retrieval pipeline.

Questions for authors
  1. The current reranking stage uses maximum relevance, while DPP optimizes embedding diversity. How do the authors ensure that the final retrieved skill set covers all active requirements, rather than selecting multiple skills that serve the same requirement?

  2. The current ablation experiments are conducted only on SR, a text-only benchmark. Could the authors extend these experiments to multimodal benchmarks, such as R3, to further validate the effectiveness of subspace scoring?

  3. The current efficiency comparison only considers generation tokens. Could the authors report the end-to-end retrieval latency and GPU computational cost, and analyze how the cost and performance of per-requirement reranking scale with the number of active requirements?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on our response

Thank you again for your constructive suggestions. We have added the extended ablations, coverage analysis, and efficiency measurements. We would be grateful if you could review our response when convenient and share any remaining concerns. Best regards,

Thank you for the additional experiments and clarifications. While the new results strengthen the empirical evaluation, my main concerns remain: the methodological novelty is limited, and the proposed reranking and DPP selection still do not explicitly optimize requirement-level coverage. So I maintain my original rating.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.