- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies complete skill-set retrieval for LLM agents. The authors observe that some required skills are only implicit in the task description, which makes them hard for dense retrievers to find.
They propose SkillComp:
- An LLM (GPT-5.4-mini) annotates pairwise relations (sequential or co-required) among the required skills of each training query.
- The description of a selected required skill is appended to the query to form expanded queries.
- The retriever is trained jointly on plain and expanded queries, with the complete required set as positives for both. Only the plain query is used at inference.
Critical strengths
- A relevant problem. Retrieving the complete required skill set is more import than a single best skill for multi-skill routing.
- A simple, inference-free design. Expanded queries and skill relations are used only in training-time, so inference remains standard dense retrieval with no extra latency and no skill graph to maintain.
Critical weaknesses
-
The ablation provides limited support for attributing the gains to skill relations.The title and motivation attribute the improvement to internalizing structural relations among required skills, but Table 3 suggests that relation-guided multi-skill expansion without single-skill expansion performs almost identically to Base (C@20 83.47 vs. 83.49) and the gains appear only once the single-skill self-expanded query (q⊕s → s) is added. That auxiliary task does not involve skill relations or multi-skill completeness. In addition, the ablation is reported only on the full SkillRet test set, not on the multi-skill subset, which the paper claims the largest benefit from. The additional generalization benefit of relation-guided training has not been demonstrated. The relationships between skills are internalized as prior knowledge through parameter updates. Whether this injected local knowledge remains effective for unseen skills warrants further investigation. Table 6 only compares the original Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B with SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B and does not include results for the Base and Random Appended Skill variants. These results therefore cannot establish whether relation-guided training provides additional benefits on unseen skill combinations beyond domain adaptation and expanded-query supervision.
-
The relation-annotation pipeline is inconsistent with the research motivation. The motivation (§1) concerns required skills that are "implied by other required skills rather than directly stated in the task description." However, the annotation (Appendix F.1) first restricts relations to the subset H ⊆ G whose relevance is directly supported by the task description. Implicit skills are therefore the ones most likely to fall outside H. They remain positives, but by construction the relation-guided expansion does not address them. Relations also determine the appended skill for only part of the training data. By Table 12, 14,300 of the 42,483 multi-skill queries (33.7%) contain at least one sequential dependency.
Questions for authors
-
Could you report the Table 3 ablation on the SkillRet multi-skill subset, and add a variant with only single-skill self-expansion (no multi-skill expansion) ?
-
How does the relation-guided expansion help required skills that are implicit in the task description, given that relations are annotated only among skills directly supported by the query?
-
Appendix A.1 provides useful evidence of transfer to unseen skills. Could you also report the results of Base and Random Appended Skill on SRA-Bench, especially R@K and C@K for multi-skill tasks? This comparison would help clarify whether relation-guided training adds a generalization benefit beyond domain adaptation and expanded-query supervision.
7 comments
Response to Reviewer iwYk (2/2)
Q2. How does the relation-guided expansion help the required skills that are implicit in the task description, given that relations are annotated only among skills directly supported by the query?
We retain implicitly required skills during relation annotation while excluding task-irrelevant skills to provide more informative expansions. Meanwhile, we preserve the original gold skill labels for retrieval training to ensure a fair comparison. We clarify these two points below.
(1) Implicitly required skills are retained during annotation. When constructing , the LLM evaluates whether a skill is needed to complete the task, rather than whether it is explicitly mentioned in the query. For example, query q-train-029706 asks the agent to analyze a codebase, create a module, and provide a spoken response. Although text-to-speech is not explicitly mentioned, it is required to deliver the spoken output and is therefore retained in for dependency annotation.
Conversely, query q-train-060513 requests Seoul weather and League of Legends match history, for which the gold skill go-error-checking is unnecessary. Excluding this skill from avoids noisy relation annotations and prevents it from being selected for relation-guided expansion. Our manual audit shows 98% annotation accuracy across 200 samples.
By providing additional information about related required skills, relation-guided expansion helps the encoder learn the relevance of implicitly required skills. As shown in Table R3-1, SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B outperforms Random in multi-skill C@20, supporting the benefit of relation-guided expansion.
(2) We preserve the original training data for a fair comparison. We retain the same training queries and complete gold skill sets, including skills excluded from . The 33.7% figure refers only to queries with annotated sequential dependencies. For the remaining multi-skill queries, we apply score-based selection within the gold set. Thus, all 42,483 multi-skill queries receive expansion and are trained to retrieve the complete gold skill set, including skills without annotated relations.
We will revise Appendix F.1 to clarify these distinctions.
Q3. Appendix A.1 provides useful evidence of transfer to unseen skills. Could you also report the results of Base and Random Appended Skill on SRA-Bench, especially R@K and C@K for multi-skill tasks? This comparison would help clarify whether relation-guided training adds a generalization benefit beyond domain adaptation and expanded-query supervision.
We extended our ablation study to SkillBench and SRA-Bench, reporting multi-skill results on both benchmarks across three training seeds. SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B improves multi-skill C@20 over Random by +4.58% on SkillBench and +0.68% on SRA-Bench. On SRA-Bench overall, SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B also improves C@20 by +11.28% over Base and +6.10% over Random. SkillBench includes more challenging queries requiring up to seven skills, where SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B shows larger gains in multi-skill retrieval.
These results show that relation-guided selection provides additional benefits beyond random expansion. We will clarify the evaluation details in the revision.
Table R3-2: Ablation results on SkillBench and SRA-Bench. Random and SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B report mean ± std across three training seeds; Base is a single run.
| Benchmark | Subset | Model | R@20 | C@20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SkillBench | Multi | Base | 72.97 | 49.02 |
| Random | 72.42 ± 1.11 | 47.71 ± 1.13 | ||
| SkillComp | 73.66 ± 1.10 | 52.29 ± 2.26 | ||
| SRA-Bench | All | Base | 64.21 | 57.44 |
| Random | 69.45 ± 10.25 | 62.62 ± 10.24 | ||
| SkillComp | 75.57 ± 0.34 | 68.72 ± 0.34 | ||
| Multi | Base | 61.73 | 32.96 | |
| Random | 63.62 ± 0.49 | 34.31 ± 0.42 | ||
| SkillComp | 64.19 ± 0.21 | 34.99 ± 0.21 |
Thank you again for your feedback. We would greatly appreciate it if you could let us know whether our responses address your concerns.
Summary of revisions for Reviewer iwYk
Thank you again for your detailed feedback. We understand that the discussion period can be busy, so we briefly summarize our responses and revisions below.
1. Single-skill self-expansion ablation (W1, Q1). We extended our ablation study by adding the w/o Multi-Skill Expansion variant. Expanding only single-skill tasks yields little improvement in multi-skill C@20 over Base, whereas expanding both task types with randomly selected skills improves multi-skill C@20 by 2.07% on SkillRet. Relation-guided expansion provides further gains of 0.62% on SkillRet and 4.58% on SkillBench over Random. These results suggest that cross-view training helps the encoder learn from expanded queries across task types, while relation-guided expansion provides more informative training views. We revised Section 5.3 and added the multi-skill results to Appendix A.3.
2. Implicit skills and the scope of (W2, Q2). A skill is included in based on whether it is necessary for task completion, not whether it is explicitly mentioned in the query. Thus, implicitly required skills remain eligible for relation-guided expansion, while skills not needed for the task are excluded to avoid irrelevant relation annotations. Importantly, only determines the scope of relation annotation and expansion; all gold skills, including those outside , remain positive training targets to ensure a fair comparison. We clarified this in Appendix E.1 (Lines 1416–1421) and added examples in Appendix E.3.
3. SRA-Bench comparison (Q3). We extended our multi-skill evaluation by adding Base and Random to the SRA-Bench comparison. SkillComp achieves the highest C@20 among the three methods, outperforming Base by 2.03% and Random by 0.68%, suggesting that relation-guided expansion remains beneficial in this setting. We also added the multi-skill comparisons across all three benchmarks to Appendix A.3 (Table 9).
We would appreciate your feedback on whether our additional experiments and clarifications address your concerns, and we would be happy to discuss any remaining questions.
Response to Reviewer iwYk (1/2)
Thank you for your detailed feedback. We appreciate your recognition of the importance of complete skill retrieval and SkillComp's simple and efficient design. We have addressed your concerns below and would appreciate hearing whether our responses address them.
Following your suggestion, we added w/o Multi-Skill Expansion (single-skill self-expansion only) and evaluated ablations on the multi-skill subset of the SkillRet test set (Table R3-1). Both w/o Multi-Skill Expansion and w/o Single-Skill Expansion perform close to Base, while SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B improves C@20 by +2.69% over Base and +2.01% over w/o Multi-Skill Expansion.
These results show that the gains are not driven by single-skill self-expansion pairs alone. Within our cross-view training framework (Section 4.2), single-skill self-expansion extends training to all queries under a unified objective, while multi-skill expansion helps the encoder learn the relevance between skills. Thus, single-skill self-expansion supports unified cross-view training rather than driving the improvements on its own.
Furthermore, under the same cross-view training framework, SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B consistently outperforms Random across three training seeds, improving multi-skill C@20 by +0.62% on average, providing further evidence for the benefit of relation-guided expansion.
Table R3-1: Ablation results on the multi-skill subset of the SkillRet test set (C@20, %). Random and SkillComp-Embedding-0.6B report mean ± std across three training seeds.