acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

TraceStencil: Signed Temporal Neighborhoods for Token-Level Policy Optimization in RLVR

Abstract

Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards supplies sequence-level feedback while updating token-level probabilities, leaving the choice of which neighboring positions should influence each update largely implicit. We introduce TraceStencil, a token-level policy-optimization objective that represents this choice as a signed temporal neighborhood. Over the selected past and/or future offsets, TraceStencil aggregates likelihood ratios in separately clipped directional branches and applies their detached product to the current-token score, making direction, radius, boundary exposure, and gradient flow explicit. We derive exact structural relations among these quantities and identify the conditions under which the objective reduces to a forward-only trace estimator. Controlled multi-run experiments on mathematical reasoning compare trace-free, one-sided, and balanced geometries under matched training and evaluation. In the pooled six-run comparison, the balanced geometry is higher on the primary coverage@256 endpoint and secondary pass@1 than its future-only counterpart, with reported pooled intervals excluding zero. Across additional model scales and mathematical benchmarks, balanced geometry yields the higher point estimate in every evaluated setting, and the larger Qwen3 configuration has a positive interval. TraceStencil therefore provides both a practical optimization rule and an auditable framework for studying how sequence-level evidence is allocated across autoregressive token updates.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards, large language models, token-level policy optimization, policy gradient methods, mathematical reasoning, temporal credit assignment, signed temporal neighborhoods, trace geometry

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_GLMxOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TraceStencil studies which neighboring tokens should enter the update weight when a verifier scores an entire response but the update is applied to each token. A signed offset table selects past tokens, future tokens, both, or neither. Probability ratios of those neighbors, relative to the old model, are split into past and future branches, clipped separately, and multiplied. The product and the current token’s own ratio are detached and used only to scale the current token’s update. The response advantage remains the group average. The main experiment compares these four settings on Qwen3-1.7B. The primary endpoint is coverage@256 on MATH-500. Looking in both directions is about 1.7 points higher than looking only ahead, and the interval over six paired runs excludes zero.

Critical strengths

The paper places several existing likelihood-ratio traces into one offset table, including NFPO’s future window, a past-only control, and an update with no trace, and compares them in the same training setup. Six paired runs and a prespecified coverage@256 endpoint make this comparison checkable.

Critical weaknesses

The experiments are limited to single-turn mathematical reasoning. The paper does not test multi-turn reinforcement learning or code tasks, so the reported gain does not show that the same offset table works outside this setting.

Questions for authors

If the probability changes of two adjacent tokens do not correspond, is this multiplier still justified? What is the theoretical basis, and when should it not be used?

Are there results on models larger than 30B? The reported models are Qwen3-1.7B, Qwen3-4B, and Qwen2.5-Math-7B. If not, should the conclusion be limited to the scales that were tested?

Are there results for multi-turn reinforcement learning or for code tasks? If not, should the conclusion be limited to single-turn mathematical reasoning?

NFPO already uses a future likelihood ratio, and CTPO already uses prefix importance sampling as a separate baseline. What is the independent contribution beyond a signed offset table that can switch among past-only, future-only, and both?

9 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer GLMx (Part 1/7)

Thank you for the questions about the multiplier and its conditions of use.

Theoretical basis, uncorrelated changes, and use conditions (R3-Q1).

If the probability changes of two adjacent tokens do not correspond, is this multiplier still justified? What is the theoretical basis, and when should it not be used?

Response. Adjacent log-ratio changes may disagree or be uncorrelated: Eq. (8) uses detached, clipped score weights and makes no positive-correlation assumption. Its role is to scale the target-token score using the selected local policy changes.

Suppressing masks and normalization, the loss and target-score gradient are

ℓt=−Asg⁡(qtBtFt)log⁡πθ(at∣st)vt.\ell_t=-A\operatorname{sg}(q_tB_tF_t)\log\pi_\theta(a_t\mid s_t)v_t.

The gradient is −AqtBtFtvt∇θlog⁡πθ(at∣st)-Aq_tB_tF_tv_t\nabla_\theta\log\pi_\theta(a_t\mid s_t). The current ratio, traces and gate are detached, so the additional weighting acts through the target score. For an active target, the positive multiplier preserves the advantage-dependent sign. At πθ=μ=ν\pi_\theta=\mu=\nu, all ratios are one and the update agrees with the trace-free score.

The submission's theory establishes cardinality, radius, mask-realized exposure, mirrored pair-count symmetry and auxiliary cost (§4; Appendix B). Truncation, clipping and gating define a local score-weighting surrogate. The trace-free, one-sided and balanced controls assess its empirical utility; the theory does not give an unbiasedness or monotonic-improvement guarantee.

New conditional interpretation derived from Eqs. (4)–(6). Hold the target score, advantage, gate and current ratio fixed. Let ut+d=log⁡πθ(at+d∣st+d)−log⁡ν(at+d∣st+d)u_{t+d}=\log\pi_\theta(a_{t+d}\mid s_{t+d})-\log\nu(a_{t+d}\mid s_{t+d}). Assume selected neighbors are valid, ratio caps and directional clips are inactive, and locally ut+d=α+βdu_{t+d}=\alpha+\beta d. Then

log⁡(BtFt)=∑d∈Dut+d=Kα+β∑d∈Dd.\log(B_tF_t)=\sum_{d\in D}u_{t+d}=K\alpha+\beta\sum_{d\in D}d.

B6 has signed first moment zero; F6 has 1+2+⋯+6=211+2+\cdots+6=21, giving

log⁡(BF)B6=6α,log⁡(BF)F6=6α+21β.\log(BF)_{\rm B6}=6\alpha,\qquad \log(BF)_{\rm F6}=6\alpha+21\beta.

Balance therefore cancels the linear temporal-trend term under these assumptions. As a numerical example, at α=.01,β=.005\alpha=.01,\beta=.005, B6's past/future log sums are 0 and .06 and F6's sum is .165, all inside the branch bounds. The factors differ even at a fully valid interior target; reversing the slope can reverse their ordering. This identity supplies a structural motivation, with masks, clipping and curvature determining how closely it applies during training.

Separate clipping can break reciprocal cancellation. At α=0,β=log⁡2/6\alpha=0,\beta=\log2/6, B6's branch products are 1/2 and 2 before clipping, while their clipped product is .8×1.4=1.12.8\times1.4=1.12. This example describes the branch factorization.

Use requires consistent policy anchors, appropriate response masks and finite log probabilities. Substantial drift or uninformative neighbors call for validation against the trace-free control. Multi-turn, tool and role transitions require explicit mask/anchor design. Applications requiring exact trajectory correction or guaranteed reciprocal cancellation need a construction that enforces those properties.

The multiplier uses completed training responses and adds no future-token access at autoregressive inference. Proposition 6 bounds auxiliary trace arithmetic by O(BTK)O(BTK) and storage by O(BT)O(BT); the ordinary inference procedure is retained.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer GLMx (Part 2/7)

About the contribution relative to NFPO and CTPO (R3-Q5)

NFPO already uses a future likelihood ratio, and CTPO already uses prefix importance sampling as a separate baseline. What is the independent contribution beyond a signed offset table that can switch among past-only, future-only, and both?

Response.

The independent contribution is the local score-weighting construction, its exact geometry/mask analysis and a controlled neighborhood study within RLVR. Building on NFPO and CTPO, TraceStencil makes the selected non-current offsets and branch factorization explicit.

NFPO uses a future suffix trace. CTPO uses cumulative prefix importance sampling, including the current position, with a position-dependent clipped surrogate for prefix/state-distribution mismatch. TraceStencil selects finite, non-current signed offsets, clips past and future branches separately, and detaches their product with the current ratio to weight the target score. This gives a different local objective from CTPO’s prefix-correction construction. CTPO-LA is already a method-native competitiveness baseline in Tables 3 and 7. The primary constructions are specified in [1] and [2].

The signed construction makes distinctions that a window-size label hides: F6 and B6 both request six neighbors, yet have radii six and three, different boundary-realized exposure, and BtFtB_tF_t supports [0.8,1.4] and [0.64,1.96]. The exact analysis quantifies these differences and proves that mirrored F6/P6 have equal total valid-pair counts for every binary response mask. The central experiments compare trace removal, mirrored orientation, and balanced versus future-only neighborhoods (Tables 1 and 2).

The empirical result is that the evaluated balanced construction improves both typical accuracy and repeated-sampling coverage in the shared stack: B6−F6 is +1.67 coverage@256 points (95% CI [+0.54,+2.78]) and +1.34 pass@1 points ([+0.55,+2.13]) over six paired runs (Table 2); both three-run block means agree in direction (Table 13). These results evaluate the balanced construction as a whole, including its radius and branch factorization.

The forward compatibility in Appendix A.2 relates the forward construction to the familiar first-order update. F3 supplies the NFPO-window geometry reference within the common objective, while the additional native NFPO arm uses the raw differentiable current ratio. C6 directly compares B6 with that native objective in the shared stack.

The additional controls give a +1.60-point B6–native NFPO coverage difference (C6), a +1.80-point difference at matched K and common final bounds (C1), and a +1.80-point difference under sequence-average aggregation (C4). These results address the baseline, factor-range and response-weighting questions separately.

About the model and task scope (R3-Q2, R3-Q3, R3-Q4)

Are there results on models larger than 30B?

Are there results for multi-turn reinforcement learning or for code tasks? If not, should the conclusion be limited to single-turn mathematical reasoning?

Response.

The evaluated scope is single-turn mathematical reasoning with Qwen3-1.7B-Base, Qwen3-4B and Qwen2.5-Math-7B. We have not evaluated >30B models, multi-turn RL or code tasks, so we limit the empirical conclusion to the tested model scales and mathematical setting.

References

[1] NFPO §3.3.

[2] CTPO §3.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer GLMx (Part 3/7)

About the baseline roles.

The submission includes GRPO/DAPO-style, CTPO-LA, and GSPO reference recipes alongside the stencil variants (Tables 3 and 7). These methods share initialization, data, reward, prompt/rollout/update budget, checkpoint selection, and evaluation, while preserving the objective-specific normalization, clipping, anchors, and optimizer exceptions disclosed in Table 7 and Appendix D.2. T0 tests trace removal; the native methods benchmark competitiveness.

CTPO-LA benchmarks a prefix-correction recipe, F3 compares forward-window geometry within TraceStencil, and C6 compares against the native NFPO objective. The new E2 and six-arm results are reported below.

About the tested settings.

The mathematical benchmarks comprise MATH-500, pooled AIME 2024–2026, AMC23, and Minerva Math. The evaluated model scales are 1.7B, 4B, and 7B. The scope is summarized in Reply 2; a multi-turn extension would require turn/role-aware masks and anchors across environment or tool transitions.

Separate E2 control cohort.

E2 comparison protocol.

Model: Qwen3-1.7B-Base, revision ea980cb0a6c2ae4b936e82123acc929f1cec04c1. Four arms: native NFPO (three future neighbors), F3, B6, and B6 with the final branch-product additionally clipped to [0.8,1.4]. All use rollout-old anchors, per-neighbor cap 3, directional bounds [0.8,1.4], and Binary-TV threshold 0.2; only declared objectives/geometries differ.

Training: the same 8,888-example exact-prompt-decontaminated data; paired seeds 1,2,3; 500 trainer steps (normally 2,000 optimizer mini-batch updates at one PPO epoch); 128 prompts/batch, eight rollouts/prompt, actor mini-batch parameter 32; configured prompt/response maxima 1024/8000, retained padded width 8000; temperature 1, top-p 1. AdamW lr 1e-6, betas (0.9,0.999), weight decay 0.01, constant schedule/no warmup, grad clip 1, bf16, optimizer offload, dynamic token budget 9024/GPU. No KL or entropy term; group-centered advantage without standard-deviation normalization. Loss normalization is one global 1/(bT)1/(bT). Save every 100 steps; step500 is the fixed endpoint, not a selected best checkpoint. The asynchronous training backend's raw context-based generation limit is separate from the retained response width.

Evaluation: all 500 MATH-500 problems, 256 generations/problem/seed, temperature 1, top-p 1, max_new_tokens 8000; math-verify 0.9.0. Report pass@1, coverage@256, coverage counting correct completions of at most 2048 tokens without replacement attempts, mean response tokens, and truncation.

Analysis: three paired seeds, paired problem identity, 10,000 hierarchical bootstrap replicates, analysis seed 0, independent generation resampling within arms. The four method-pair comparisons are F3−Native NFPO, B6−Native NFPO, B6−F3 and B6-commonclip−B6. Scorer, sample budget, seed count and checkpoint rule are fixed across arms.

Reviewer_FJJvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

Proposed: TRACESTENCIL, a token-level objective which captures locality by defining the signed temporal neighborhood value, namely:

  • This weights each token’s policy gradient score by clipped likelihood ratios of recent and near-future tokens
  • Ie. The question proposed is given a fixed number of nhbrs K, which selection is the best?
  • The authors find that a balanced usage +-3 beats future-only by abt 1.5 pts
Critical strengths

Strengths:

  • Targets a relevant area, which others have show is practical and impactful
  • A good coverage of experimental data: six paired runs, hierarchical bootstrap, block-level agreement reported
Critical weaknesses

Weaknesses:

  • The proposed method tests a fairly small domain, and the finding/contribution (to shift back by 3) feels somewhat small. This feels like a fine-tuning result.
  • At realistic lengths (~2000 tokens?), the gap is very small (9/L =0.0005 nhbrs per token). This leads me to believe that exposure alone is not really the explanation of the effect, rather it’s more like weight range and length shift.
  • The baselines are missing the actual NFPO objective
  • When looking at figure 4 and table 15, it seems B6 (the best method) responses are 8% longer (2134 vs 1968) which could explain improvements in performance, rather than the method alone

Ultimately, it seems like the contribution is fairly small and those improvements that are observed lack the proper controls (standardized length, the NFPO objective with the same protocol), confounding the conclusion that the method is causing improvement.

Questions for authors

Integrated in weaknesses

9 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer FJJv (Part 1/7)

Thank you for recognizing the paired evaluation and for examining the attribution controls.

About the contribution and exposure (R2-Q1–Q2).

The finding/contribution (to shift back by 3) feels somewhat small.

The question is how to allocate a fixed ratio-neighbor budget across temporal directions. TraceStencil defines the local score weights, derives their geometry and mask properties, and compares the resulting choices under a common protocol. The original six-run B6−F6 result is +1.67 coverage@256 points [95% CI .54,2.78] and +1.34 pass@1 points [.55,2.13] (Table 2); both three-run blocks favor B6, with coverage effects +1.47/+1.87 (Table 13). B6−T0 is +2.90 coverage points [1.71,4.08], testing trace utility rather than balance alone.

At L=2000, the same-response boundary-count gap is exactly 9/L=.0045 neighbors/target, or .075% of six, for a contiguous mask with L≥7. This is an exposure identity, not a bound on update differences. At fully valid interior targets, F6 and B6 still select different local ratios. F6 uses +1…+6 in one branch; B6 uses −3…−1/+1…+3 in two branches. Their radii are six/three and formal BF supports [.8,1.4]/[.64,1.96]. Different coefficients therefore occur throughout a response, not only at its boundaries.

The mirrored P6−F6 comparison holds K, radius, and total pair count fixed for the same response mask; its six-run coverage effect is −0.57 points [95% CI −1.81,+0.69] (Table 2). Replies 3–4 report the new aggregation and common-bounds controls for the balanced construction.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer FJJv (Part 2/7)

About native NFPO and the E2 comparison (R2-Q3).

The baselines are missing the actual NFPO objective

F3 is the same-radius NFPO-window geometry inside TraceStencil, not native NFPO (Tables 3/9; Appendix A.2). With rt=πθ(at∣st)/μ(at∣st)r_t=\pi_\theta(a_t\mid s_t)/\mu(a_t\mid s_t), suppressing common masks/normalization,

\ell_t^{\rm F3}=-A\operatorname{sg}(q_tF_t)\log\pi_\theta(a_t\mid s_t)v_t, \quad q_t=\exp(\operatorname{clip}(\log r_t,-10,10)).$$ With matching anchors/traces/masks/gates/reduction and $|\log r_t|<10$, both target-log-probability derivatives are $-Ar_tF_tv_t$. Outside the clamp, F3's detached q saturates; NFPO's active raw current ratio keeps differentiating. Native denotes the published practical objective [1], evaluated within our shared training stack. Table 11 retains source-paper NFPO results under their original protocol. E2 protocol. Qwen3-1.7B-Base revision ea980cb0a6c2ae4b936e82123acc929f1cec04c1; the same 8,888-example exact-prompt-decontaminated data. Arms: native NFPO (three future neighbors), F3, B6 and B6-commonclip. Shared rollout-old anchors, neighbor cap 3, branch bounds [.8,1.4] and Binary-TV δ=.2; commonclip adds final BF clipping. Three paired training seeds 1/2/3; 128 prompts×8 rollouts, mini-batch parameter 32, one PPO epoch; 500 trainer steps (normally 2000 optimizer mini-batch updates), save every 100, no best-checkpoint selection. The submission reports an original endpoint of 500 optimizer steps; these units and cohorts are kept separate. Prompt/response maxima 1024/8000, padded width 8000; training temperature/top-p 1/1; AdamW lr 1e−6, betas (.9,.999), weight decay .01, constant/no warmup, grad clip 1, bf16, optimizer offload, dynamic token budget 9024/GPU. Group-centered advantage without std normalization; no KL/entropy; global masked sum/(bT). Raw asynchronous generation context limits are separate from retained width. Evaluation: 500 MATH-500 problems×256 generations/run, temperature/top-p 1/1, max_new_tokens 8000, math-verify 0.9.0. Capped coverage counts correct completions≤2048 without replacement attempts; mean tokens/truncation retain the same definitions. Analysis uses 10000 hierarchical-bootstrap replicates, analysis seed 0, paired runs/problems and independent generation resampling within arms; pointwise 95%, no family-wise claim or arm-specific tuning. $$N=3\times500\times256=384000,\qquad M=3\times500=1500.$$ E2 results and fixed contrasts. Differences use unrounded means. | Method | pass@1 ↑ (fraction) | cov@256 ↑ (fraction) | cov≤2048 ↑ (fraction) | Mean tokens | Trunc. % | Training seeds | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Native NFPO | 0.726 | 0.916 | 0.871 | 1975.03 | 0.76 | 3 | | F3 | 0.726 | 0.917 | 0.871 | 1974.93 | 0.72 | 3 | | B6 | 0.740 | 0.934 | 0.887 | 2000.07 | 0.62 | 3 | | B6-commonclip | 0.739 | 0.929 | 0.885 | 1994.99 | 0.61 | 3 | | Contrast (first minus second) | Δpass@1 (fraction) | Δcov@256 (fraction) | | --- | --- | --- | | F3−Native NFPO | +0.000 | +0.001 | | B6−Native NFPO | +0.014 | +0.018 | | B6−F3 | +0.014 | +0.017 | | B6-commonclip−B6 | -0.001 | -0.005 | B6 improves over native NFPO by 1.37 pass@1 points and 1.80 coverage points, and over F3 by 1.38 and 1.67 points, respectively. B6-commonclip retains coverage advantages of 1.27 points over native NFPO and 1.13 over F3. F3−native NFPO is −0.01 pass@1 points and +0.13 coverage points. These are mean differences across three paired training seeds. E2 is a separate cohort from E3/E4, so its results are reported separately from C6. [1] [NFPO §3.3](https://arxiv.org/html/2605.20865v1).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer FJJv (Part 3/7)

About response length and E4 (R2-Q4).

Table 15 reports B6/F6 mean response lengths of 2134/1968 tokens, about 8.4% apart. Reply 6 gives the corresponding resource measurements. The E4 experiment below tests explicit response-length weighting, together with coverage counting only correct completions within 2048 tokens.

E4 tests the separate training-aggregation question using the six-arm protocol in Reply 4. For Li=∑tzitL_i=\sum_t z_{it} and unreduced token loss ℓit\ell_{it},

\mathcal L_{\rm seqavg}=\frac{1}{bT}\sum_i\frac{L_\star}{\max(L_i,1)}\sum_tz_{it}\ell_{it}, \quad T=8000,\ L_\star=2048.$$ The reference is fixed across arms before evaluation. It removes the token sum's direct proportionality to $L_i$ when per-token losses are fixed, while retaining the outer normalization and learning rate. Empty responses contribute zero. Training keeps the 8000-token cap; the 2048-token evaluation threshold is defined separately. Geometry × aggregation results. Standard F6/B6 are the same runs used in E3. | Method | pass@1 ↑ | coverage@256 ↑ | Mean tokens | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | F6-standard (K=6) | 0.726 | 0.917 | 1960.12 | | B6-standard (K=6) | 0.746 | 0.939 | 2000.00 | | F6-seqavg (K=6) | 0.722 | 0.913 | 1930.06 | | B6-seqavg (K=6) | 0.740 | 0.931 | 1940.16 | | Contrast (first minus second) | Δpass@1 (pp) | Δcoverage@256 (pp) | | --- | --- | --- | | C4: B6-seqavg − F6-seqavg | +1.78 | +1.80 | | C5: C4 − C2 | -0.20 | -0.40 | C4 is B6-seqavg−F6-seqavg; C5=C4−C2 measures how this geometry contrast changes under sequence-average weighting. Under seqavg, B6 retains advantages of 1.78 pass@1 points, 1.80 coverage points, and 1.73 capped-coverage points. The evaluation mean-length gap decreases from 39.88 to 10.10 tokens. C5 records a −0.40-point change in the coverage contrast, measuring its sensitivity to aggregation. The E4 gain persists when counting only short correct completions and when changing explicit response-length weighting. E4 tests aggregation sensitivity; it does not equalize all training-length distributions or isolate a causal mediation effect.
Reviewer_MpyxOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

Building on NFPO, a method that reweights the gradient of the current token using products of likelihood ratios for future tokens, this paper extends the analysis to examine how token selection strategies with different spans and directions affect reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR). Experiments on Qwen3-1.7B-Base, Qwen3-4B, and Qwen2.5-Math-7B show that strategies selecting balanced numbers of past and future tokens consistently outperform the other variants.

Critical strengths

The paper reports results from six repeated runs, together with confidence intervals. The results across multiple models and datasets provide reasonably strong empirical evidence for the advantages of balanced token selection geometries over one-sided alternatives.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The research question and motivation are not clearly explained. NFPO has already demonstrated the effectiveness of using future-token information to reweight policy gradients. TraceStencil extends the product of local likelihood ratios to both temporal directions, but does not explain which limitation of the unidirectional approach is addressed by incorporating past-token ratios, or provide a convincing mechanistic explanation for why bidirectional or balanced geometry should be more effective. Moreover, Table 3 shows relatively modest improvements of B6 over F6 and F3. Could the authors clarify why token updates should explicitly incorporate neighboring tokens from both directions, or provide a mechanistic analysis of the advantages of bidirectional over unidirectional traces?

  2. The presentation of this paper makes the method and experimental results difficult to understand. These issues include, but are not limited to, the lack of explanations alongside Figure 1 for variables such as (\nu), (S), and (T), redundant entries and overly dense presentation in the tables, and the absence of a clear description of the specific experimental settings shown in Figure 3(c).

Questions for authors

Please see the critical weaknesses.

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer Mpyx (Part 1/7)

Thank you for recognizing the paired-run evidence and for asking for clearer motivation and presentation.

About the motivation and mechanism (R1-Q1)

TraceStencil extends the product of local likelihood ratios to both temporal directions, but does not explain which limitation of the unidirectional approach is addressed by incorporating past-token ratios, or provide a convincing mechanistic explanation for why bidirectional or balanced geometry should be more effective.

Response.

We test whether allocating a fixed ratio-neighbor budget changes the trained policy’s accuracy–coverage profile. NFPO’s successful future trace leaves this allocation question open. At K=6K=6, balance places the nearest three neighbors on each side and minimizes radius at three, versus six for F6 (Tables 1 and 14). A past branch responds to recent conditioning-history probability shifts; a future branch responds to continuation shifts. The smaller radius and centered weighting motivate the candidate; controlled comparisons provide performance evidence.

The stencil specifies how local ratio changes enter a token’s update coefficient. In Eq. (8), suppressing mask and normalization, the target-score coefficient is −AqtBtFtvt-Aq_tB_tF_tv_t. F6 uses the next six ratios in one clipped branch. B6 uses the nearest three on each side in two separately clipped branches. Even at an interior token where both have six valid neighbors, they therefore attach different local policy changes to the same target score. The difference extends throughout a response, beyond the extra boundary pairs. At πθ=μ=ν\pi_\theta=\mu=\nu all ratios equal one and the update agrees with the trace-free score; the trace distinguishes updates as the policy moves from its rollout anchor. Neighbor ratios are detached weights, so they introduce no additional gradient path through neighboring scores.

Separate clipping gives BtFtB_tF_t support [0.8,1.4] for F6 and [0.64,1.96] for B6. Existing submission evidence helps distinguish these design choices. Mirrored P6−F6 matches K, radius, and total valid-pair counts for the same response mask; its coverage effect is −0.57 points [−1.81,+0.69] (Table 2). Table 15 also reports lower branch saturation for B6 than F6 (0.21 versus 0.34). E3 below tests the balanced construction with the final factor bounds matched to F6.

A simple interior calculation makes the distinction concrete. With every neighbor valid, setting only ρt−1=2\rho_{t-1}=2 and every other ratio to one gives trace factor 1 for F6 and 1.4 for B6; changing only ρt+6=2\rho_{t+6}=2 instead gives 1.4 for F6 and 1 for B6. Both differences survive common final clipping. Geometry therefore reallocates sensitivity to local policy changes throughout the response. Reply 3 develops the centered-log-ratio interpretation of this effect.

About the magnitude of the improvement (R1-Q2)

Moreover, Table 3 shows relatively modest improvements of B6 over F6 and F3.

Response.

The primary six-run paired contrast improves coverage@256 by 1.67 percentage points (95% CI [+0.54,+2.78]) and pass@1 by 1.34 points ([+0.55,+2.13]) (Table 2). Both three-run block means favor B6: +1.47 and +1.87 coverage points (Table 13). These comparisons support a repeated benefit of the evaluated construction under the shared protocol.

F3 and B6 both have radius three, with three and six neighbors respectively (Table 9). F3 provides a same-radius forward reference alongside matched-K F6 and serves as the NFPO-window control within our objective. The new native-objective comparison is reported separately in the shared six-arm cohort.

The E3/E4 controls below retain coverage advantages of C1=+1.80pp with common final bounds and C4=+1.80pp with sequence-average weighting. These results support the balanced construction under both controls.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer Mpyx (Part 2/7)

About the notation alongside Figure 1 (R1-Q3)

the lack of explanations alongside Figure 1 for variables such as (ν), (S), and (T)

Response.

To make Figure 1 self-contained, the proposed caption below collects its anchors, gradient routing and normalization in one place (Eq. (8), Table 5 and Appendix D.1). The displayed settings are ν=μ\nu=\mu and S=TS=T.

Proposed caption.

Figure 1. TraceStencil from policy ratios to a trace-weighted token update. The current policy is πθ\pi_\theta, μ\mu is the rollout-old policy, and ν\nu is the neighbor-trace anchor; ν=μ\nu=\mu in our experiments. The current ratio qtq_t uses anchor μ\mu and neighbor ratio ρj\rho_j uses ν\nu, with clipping in Eqs. (2)–(3). Signed offsets exclude the target token; a target–neighbor pair contributes only when both response-mask entries z equal one. Invalid neighbors contribute the multiplicative identity. Past and future products BtB_t and FtF_t are clipped separately, and sg⁡(qtBtFt)\operatorname{sg}(q_tB_tF_t) scales the target log-probability update. The advantage-conditioned gate vtv_t determines update validity. AiA_i is the prompt-group-centered response advantage (Eq. (1)); sg⁡\operatorname{sg} denotes stop-gradient. The masked loss is normalized by (bS)−1(bS)^{-1}: b is the mini-batch size, T is the padded response width, and S=TS=T. F6 requests six future offsets with radius six; B6 requests three offsets in each direction with radius three. Color is redundant with line style and labels; hatching marks an invalid pair.

In particular, S is a loss-normalization scale, rather than an additional sequence length; setting S=TS=T gives the denominator bTbT in Eq. (8).

About the presentation of the tables (R1-Q4)

redundant entries and overly dense presentation in the tables

Response.

For immediate readability, the primary endpoint and run-paired contrasts are condensed from Table 2 below. The proposed manuscript layout keeps Table 2(a/b) together, moves the full pass@k profile from Table 2(c) to the appendix, and cross-references the central arms in Table 3. Every reported value and recipe setting remains accessible, with the main endpoint and uncertainty given priority.

EndpointF6B6Paired B6−F6 [95% CI], pp
pass@10.70380.7172+1.34 [0.55,2.13]
coverage@2560.89670.9133+1.67 [0.54,2.78]

Both arms have six paired runs. Contrasts use the original unrounded estimates; they need not equal subtraction of the four-decimal displayed means.

About the settings in Figure 3(c) (R1-Q5)

the absence of a clear description of the specific experimental settings shown in Figure 3(c).

Response.

Every point is the Table 12 B6−F6 contrast in coverage@256, in percentage points. The following complete panel caption specifies its datasets, models, replication, and error bars:

Proposed panel caption.

(c) Across settings. B6 minus F6 in coverage@256, in percentage points. MATH, AIME, AMC, and Minerva denote MATH-500, pooled AIME 2024–2026 (90 problems), AMC23, and Minerva Math, respectively; all four use Qwen3-1.7B. The 4B and 7B points use Qwen3-4B and Qwen2.5-Math-7B on MATH-500. Primary MATH uses six paired runs; each other point uses three. Coverage uses 256 samples per problem. Within a setting, arms share the problem set, sampling budget, decoding distribution, token limit, and scorer. Symmetric bars use the larger reported 95% interval half-width; Table 12 retains the exact asymmetric endpoints.

The caption makes the model, benchmark, replication, and error-bar convention of each setting explicit.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer Mpyx (Part 3/7)

About why use both directions, beyond boundary exposure.

A future-only factor uses changes in continuation likelihood; a past branch also responds to changes in recent conditioning-history likelihood. At K=6, balance has radius three rather than six (Proposition 1; Table 14). The target state retains its full autoregressive prefix; the stencil selects the neighboring ratios that additionally enter its update weight.

New rebuttal analysis, derived from Eqs. (4)–(6). Hold the target score, advantage, gate, and current ratio fixed. Let ut+d=log⁡πθ(at+d∣st+d)−log⁡ν(at+d∣st+d)u_{t+d}=\log\pi_\theta(a_{t+d}\mid s_{t+d})-\log\nu(a_{t+d}\mid s_{t+d}). Assume every selected neighbor is valid, the neighbor ratio caps are inactive, and both directional branch clips are inactive. If locally ut+d=α+βdu_{t+d}=\alpha+\beta d, then

log⁡(BtFt)=∑d∈Dut+d=Kα+β∑d∈Dd.\log(B_tF_t)=\sum_{d\in D}u_{t+d}=K\alpha+\beta\sum_{d\in D}d.

B6 has signed first moment zero, while F6 has 1+2+⋯+6=211+2+\cdots+6=21. Hence

log⁡(BF)B6=6α,log⁡(BF)F6=6α+21β.\log(BF)_{\rm B6}=6\alpha,\qquad \log(BF)_{\rm F6}=6\alpha+21\beta.

Thus balance removes the linear temporal-trend component under the stated conditions. For example, at α=.01,β=.005\alpha=.01,\beta=.005, the B6 past/future log sums are 0 and .06, and the F6 log sum is .165; all lie strictly within the branch bounds. This algebraic example gives different factors at a fully valid interior target without clipping. Reversing the slope can reverse their ordering.

Balance is therefore a centered summary of local log-ratio changes, without requiring neighboring changes to have the same sign. This identity explains a structural distinction; the controlled experiments assess its practical utility. The cancellation applies in the locally affine, unclipped, fully valid case; masks, clipping, and curvature can change it.

Use conditions and interpretation. The local weighting requires finite log probabilities, consistent policy anchors, and response-aware masks. Turn, role, and tool transitions need corresponding mask and anchor design. The E3/E4 experiments test the construction in the single-turn mathematical setting used in the submission.

The future-neighbor multiplier is computed from completed rollouts for training; it adds no future-token access or lookahead at autoregressive inference.

Proposition 6 bounds the auxiliary trace arithmetic by O(BTK)O(BTK) and storage by O(BT)O(BT). The stencil operates on token ratios from the sampled response, making the neighborhood an explicit training choice with a stated auxiliary cost while retaining the ordinary autoregressive inference procedure.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
Area_Chair_CqEZOpenReview ↗

Please engage with authors

Dear Reviewers,

The author-reviewer discussion will be closed on November 18 (AoE). If you haven’t yet replied to the authors’ latest response, please do so on OpenReview as soon as possible so they have time to follow up. A brief reply indicating which of your concerns have been addressed and what questions remain would be helpful. Thank you for your time and for engaging with the authors.

Best regards,

AC

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response to the Reviewers

About the contribution and evidence

We thank the reviewers for recognizing the paired multi-run evaluation. TraceStencil asks which local policy-ratio neighborhood should weight a token update when the reward scores the complete response. It makes the anchors, signed offsets, masks, branch clipping, and gradient path explicit, derives their structural relations, and evaluates the resulting design choices in one stack.

The primary six-run B6–F6 comparison improves coverage@256 by 1.67 percentage points (95% CI [+0.54,+2.78]) and pass@1 by 1.34 points ([+0.55,+2.13]); both three-run block means favor B6 (Tables 2 and 13). The evidence supports the evaluated balanced construction in single-turn mathematical reasoning.

The new experiments address the main shared questions: a native NFPO comparison, matched neighbor budgets and final factor bounds (E3), and sequence-average loss weighting (E4). In the shared six-arm cohort, B6 improves coverage over native NFPO by 1.60 points; the common-bounds and sequence-average comparisons each retain a 1.80-point advantage over F6. The replies below give the protocols, results, and figure clarifications. The new three-seed tables report mean effects; the original six-run confidence intervals are reported separately.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.