- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
UniSlider focus non-uniform perceptual changes in continuous instruction-based image editing. It trains a LoRA on a few-step editing backbone using strength-dependent perceptual distances to the source image and the backbone’s full edit. Budgeted adaptive sampling then remaps internal editing strength to a user-facing slider. The paper introduces a 300-example benchmark and evaluates editing fidelity, preservation, endpoint consistency, quality, monotonicity, and uniformity through quantitative comparisons, ablations, qualitative results, and user studies.
Critical strengths
The paper studies the practically meaningful problem of non-uniform slider behavior in continuous image editing and extends evaluation beyond final outputs to the full editing trajectory, considering uniformity, monotonicity, edit fidelity, and content preservation. Training and remapping ablations, the independent perceptual metric TPIPS, and user studies provide complementary evidence beyond the optimized DreamSim metric.
Critical weaknesses
-
Missing discussion of closely related perceptual-uniformity work [1,2] leaves the novelty boundary unclear. The submission neither cites nor discusses these works, leaving unclear whether its distinctive contribution is the dual-endpoint trajectory training, inference-time remapping, or their combination.
-
The closest baseline comparison contains an unresolved protocol inconsistency. The appendix maps SliderEdit strength using ($\alpha=1-2$s), yet also states that its maximum-strength output equals the frozen-backbone endpoint shared with UniSlider. These statements are inconsistent. Differences in training configurations and adaptive-sampling endpoint handling also require clarification to attribute the reported gains reliably.
[1] IMPUS: Image Morphing with Perceptually-Uniform Sampling Using Diffusion Models. ICLR, 2024.
[2] AdaptiveSliders: User-aligned Semantic Slider-based Editing of Text-to-Image Model Output. CHI, 2025.
Questions for authors
- Please discuss the following works and clarify differences in problem setting, methodology, and contribution.
[1] IMPUS: Image Morphing with Perceptually-Uniform Sampling Using Diffusion Models. ICLR, 2024.
[2] AdaptiveSliders: User-aligned Semantic Slider-based Editing of Text-to-Image Model Output. CHI, 2025.
-
Under the same backbone, matched endpoints, and equal generation budgets, how much additional improvement does dual-endpoint trajectory training provide over an existing continuous editor with perceptual remapping?
-
Which SliderEdit strength mapping was actually evaluated? Are all methods assessed using consistent user-facing slider coordinates and equivalent endpoint handling?