- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on two key limitations of existing slider-based image editing methods: the lack of truly continuous control along a single slider and cross-attribute interference when using multiple sliders. To address these issues, the authors propose SliderEdit++, which builds upon the original SliderEdit framework with four regularizers: velocity-space midpoint regularization, semantic-space midpoint regularization, spectral-norm regularization, and disentanglement regularization. Together, these objectives aim to improve the continuity and independence of editing sliders.
The authors also introduce SlideBench, a new benchmark for evaluating slider-based image editing along three key dimensions: monotonic progression, frame uniformity, and multi-slider disentanglement.
Critical strengths
-
Clear motivation and well-written presentation. The paper is very well written and easy to follow. In particular, I appreciate how clearly the authors identify the limitations of existing slider-based editing methods. The motivation is convincing, and each component of the proposed method is well explained and naturally follows from the identified problems. The benchmark is also thoughtfully designed.
-
A useful and intuitive benchmark. I particularly like SlideBench, as it provides a clear and intuitive way to evaluate what slider-based image editing should ideally achieve. Rather than focusing only on editing quality at individual slider positions, it also considers how edits progress throughout the trajectory. I think this is a valuable contribution to the field.
-
Effective regularization with strong results. The proposed regularizers fit naturally into the original SliderEdit framework and lead to impressive improvements, especially in editing continuity. Both the quantitative and qualitative results are encouraging, and the multi-slider results also look promising.
Critical weaknesses
Overall, I really enjoyed this paper and found the results quite convincing. I only have two minor comments and a few questions that I'd be curious to hear the authors' thoughts on. These could also be interesting to explore in a future version.
-
A bit more analysis of the individual regularizers.
I appreciate the ablation study in Table 2, which nicely shows the benefits of each regularizer. One thing I'd love to see is a leave-one-out ablation to better understand how they work together. For example, Figure 6(b) only compares the full model with the version without any regularization. I'm curious what the results would look like if we removed just one regularizer, especially the disentanglement loss in the multi-slider examples (Figure 15).
I also have two small questions about the disentanglement regularizer:
-
Quantitative improvement. The disentanglement score in Table 3 only improves slightly from 0.9854 to 0.9869. I wonder if this is partly because the metric is already quite saturated or the reason explained under.
-
Velocity vs. semantic space. I really like the motivation behind the semantic-space regularizer, where the authors point out that smoothness in velocity space doesn't necessarily mean smoothness in the final image. This makes me wonder if the same idea also applies to disentanglement. Would it make sense to encourage disentanglement directly in DINOv2 feature space, instead of only enforcing orthogonality in velocity space? I'd be interested to hear the authors' thoughts on this.
-
-
The relationship between the training objectives and evaluation metrics.
I really like SlideBench and think it provides a useful way to evaluate continuous editing. One small thing I noticed is that the semantic-space regularizer uses DINOv2 features to encourage smoother trajectories, while DINOv2 is also part of the continuity evaluation in SlideBench.
I understand that the benchmark already includes other feature metrics and human evaluation, so this is not a major concern. Still, I'm curious how well uniform changes in DINOv2 feature space actually match what humans perceive as smooth and continuous editing. I think a short discussion on this would be helpful, and perhaps a more targeted human evaluation of intermediate slider transitions could be an interesting addition in a future version.
Questions for authors
Overall, I really enjoyed reading this paper. It is well organized, and I find the motivation and experimental results quite convincing. I would be happy to hear the authors' thoughts on the points raised in the Weaknesses section, and I currently lean toward Weak Accept.
My main hesitation in giving a higher score is that the method still builds heavily on the original SliderEdit framework, particularly its endpoint supervision and LoRA interpolation. While the proposed regularizers clearly improve the editing trajectories, I feel the broader methodological novelty and potential impact on future work are somewhat limited by this reliance. If SliderEdit had not already established this framework, I would probably lean toward Clear Accept.
One thing I'd be curious to hear more about is whether the proposed regularizers could also work with other continuous editing frameworks beyond SliderEdit. I think this would help me better understand the broader potential of this work.
5 comments
2. Relationship between training objectives and evaluation metrics
We thank the reviewer for raising this important point. Since DINOv2 is used in our semantic-space regularizer, we specifically evaluate continuity in multiple independent feature spaces, including LPIPS, CLIP, and SigLIP, rather than relying solely on DINOv2. This helps ensure that the observed improvements are not simply a consequence of optimizing the same representation used for evaluation. In addition, we complement these automatic metrics with human preference studies.
Regarding the relationship between DINOv2 feature distances and perceived smoothness, Figure 3 provides a qualitative analysis illustrating how abrupt semantic transitions correspond to large fluctuations in consecutive-frame DINOv2 distances. In our experiments, we generally observed that more uniform DINOv2 distances correspond to visually smoother editing trajectories. Nevertheless, we acknowledge that DINOv2 is an imperfect proxy for human perception and may not capture every type of semantic transition equally well.
We also believe that more sophisticated formulations of semantic progression could further improve both training and evaluation. For example, Semantic Progress Function (SPF) [1] models cumulative semantic change along a sequence and characterizes deviations from uniform semantic progression. Such approaches provide an interesting alternative for analyzing editing trajectories and could potentially be incorporated into our framework. Importantly, our semantic-space regularization is not inherently tied to DINOv2, and exploring alternative representations or semantic progression objectives is a promising direction for future work.
3. Generalizability beyond SliderEdit
We especially appreciate the reviewer's interest in the broader applicability of our approach. Importantly, our proposed regularizers are not restricted to SliderEdit. They operate on intermediate editing trajectories and can be incorporated into other slider-training objectives.
To demonstrate this, we conducted an additional experiment applying our regularizers to KontinuousKontext, which adopts a different slider-training objective from SliderEdit. We report the results below alongside the original SliderEdit ablation:
| Method | GPT-5 ↑ | Opus-4.8 ↑ | MP Avg ↑ | LPIPS ↑ | CLIP ↑ | SigLIP ↑ | DINOv2 ↑ | Uniformity Avg ↑ | Overall ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SliderEdit | 0.7100 | 0.7222 | 0.7161 | 0.7030 | 0.7310 | 0.7350 | 0.7342 | 0.7258 | 0.7209 |
| SliderEdit + Ours | 0.7801 | 0.7890 | 0.7845 | 0.8272 | 0.8431 | 0.8443 | 0.8399 | 0.8386 | 0.8116 |
| KontinuousKontext | 0.7073 | 0.6992 | 0.7033 | 0.6223 | 0.6626 | 0.6630 | 0.6585 | 0.6516 | 0.6774 |
| KontinuousKontext + Ours | 0.7412 | 0.7438 | 0.7425 | 0.7316 | 0.7589 | 0.7614 | 0.7549 | 0.7517 | 0.7471 |
As shown, our regularizers consistently improve performance across both frameworks. Specifically, the overall score increases from 0.7209 to 0.8116 for SliderEdit and from 0.6774 to 0.7471 for KontinuousKontext. Both monotonic progression and frame uniformity also improve.
These additional results demonstrate that our approach is not merely a refinement of SliderEdit, but offers a more general strategy for improving continuous editing trajectories across different training objectives. We will include this experiment in the revised manuscript.
We sincerely thank the reviewer again for the positive assessment, thoughtful questions, and constructive suggestions, which have helped us further strengthen our work. We hope our responses and additional experiments adequately address the reviewer's concerns.
[1] Metzer, Gal, et al. "Video Analysis and Generation via a Semantic Progress Function."
We thank you again for your valuable feedback and comments which have helped to strengthen our paper. As the discussion period is ending soon, we would really appreciate if you could let us know if our responses have addressed your concerns. We will be happy to answer any further questions and address any remaining concerns to the best of our abilities in the remaining time!
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the encouraging feedback and for recognizing the clear motivation and presentation of our work, the usefulness and intuitive design of SlideBench, and the effectiveness of our proposed regularizers. We appreciate the thoughtful suggestions and address each point below.
1. Further analysis of the regularizers
Leave-one-out ablation. We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. While Table 2 already demonstrates the individual contributions of each regularizer, we agree that a leave-one-out ablation would provide further insight into their complementary effects. We therefore extend our ablation by evaluating all pairwise combinations of the regularizers under the same backbone and experimental setup.
The leave-one-out ablation further supports the complementary effects of our proposed regularizers. Combining any two regularizers improves performance over their individual application, while the full objective consistently achieves the best results across all metrics. These findings suggest that each regularizer contributes distinct benefits to trajectory smoothness and continuity, and that their combination is particularly effective. We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion, which provides a more comprehensive understanding of how the proposed regularizers interact.
We will incorporate these additional ablations into the revised appendix, together with further qualitative examples illustrating the contribution of each regularizer. We also agree that slider quality is particularly intuitive to assess through an interactive interface, where users can directly observe the continuity of transitions. We plan to make such an interface publicly available upon publication, allowing users to explore and compare different training configurations interactively.
Saturated disentanglement metric. We agree with the reviewer that the disentanglement scores in Table 3 are highly saturated, making them relatively insensitive to meaningful improvements in multi-slider behavior. To better capture these differences, we conducted an extensive additional human evaluation involving 10,000 paired comparisons, where participants selected the model providing a better and more disentangled multi-slider editing experience.
The results show a clear preference for SliderEdit++, with 56% favoring our method compared to 41% for the baseline. These findings provide further perceptual evidence that our framework improves practical multi-slider controllability beyond what is captured by the saturated automatic metric.
Velocity-space vs. semantic-space disentanglement. We appreciate this insightful suggestion and agree with the reviewer's reasoning. As discussed in our paper, while encouraging orthogonality in velocity space helps reduce interference between different sliders, it may not fully guarantee semantic independence in the final generated images due to the nonlinear generation process. Therefore, extending the disentanglement objective to semantic feature spaces, such as DINOv2, is a well-motivated direction that could further improve the independence of semantic edits.
Our primary focus in this work is improving editing continuity, with disentanglement explored as an additional extension. We believe the reviewer's proposed direction could further strengthen multi-slider control and represents a promising avenue for future work.