- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents TrajWAM, a trajectory-conditioned auxiliary training framework for vision–language driving. Building on a DeepSight-style planner with DINOv3-aligned BEV future supervision, the method uses an ActionEncoder and FiLM to condition future-query states on logged or perturbed ego trajectories. Logged trajectories receive factual feature-reconstruction supervision, while perturbed trajectories receive a one-sided feature-separation loss. These objectives update the shared planner during training, and the additional conditioned readout is bypassed at inference. The method is evaluated on all 220 Bench2Drive routes, with schedule-matched continuation and component ablations.
Critical strengths
1.All Phase-II variants use the same initial checkpoint and training schedule. The full method improves over planning-only fine-tuning by 5.31 DS and eight successful routes.
2.The method distinguishes factual future supervision from perturbed trajectories, without assigning unavailable future targets to the latter.
3.The authors clearly distinguish trajectory sensitivity from counterfactual accuracy, acknowledge the single-seed limitation, and provide detailed route-level results.
Critical weaknesses
1.The experiments do not sufficiently validate the main motivation. The paper aims to learn trajectory-conditioned future representations, but the experiments mainly show improvements in planning performance. Figures 4–5 only demonstrate feature sensitivity to trajectory perturbations on training samples, without showing whether these changes reflect meaningful future scene dynamics. Table 7 also lacks comparisons with unconditioned and no-separation baselines. It remains unclear whether the planning gains come from better action-conditioned world modeling or simply from additional auxiliary supervision.
2.The evaluation of future representations is insufficient. Figures 4–5 use training samples, while Table 7 only reports reconstruction metrics for the full model. There is no comparison with the unconditioned or no-separation variants, or even a simple feature-persistence baseline. Without evaluation on held-out data, it is difficult to tell whether trajectory conditioning actually improves future prediction.
Questions for authors
1.Could the authors compare the proposed FiLM with bias-only conditioning or shuffled trajectory inputs? What happens if the current-time feature is excluded from the separation loss?
2.Could the authors report held-out future prediction results for the full model, no-separation variant, and unconditioned baseline? Please also clarify the sample count and split used in Table 7.
3.Could the authors provide paired route-level DS differences between the variants, ideally with confidence intervals? Results from additional training seeds or simulator sweeps would also be helpful.