acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Test-Time Revision: Latent Reasoning with Execution in the Loop

Abstract

Extra test-time computation improves predictions. However, updating hidden states during inference may improve intermediate scores yet still produce incorrect or invalid outputs after full task execution. Reranking can select a better output, but selection alone does not ensure that subsequent reasoning builds on the corresponding internal state. We introduce *Test-Time Revision (TTR)*, an approach to latent reasoning guided by task execution. TTR evaluates bounded changes to the current state through full task execution and jointly commits the selected output and its corresponding internal state. This preserves consistency between the selected output and the state used for subsequent reasoning, while allowing execution feedback to guide further revision. The same mechanism applies to Sudoku token states, Maze spatial representations, and Qwen prompt embeddings. Each task retains its own adapter, executor, and evaluation rules, while the original backbones remain frozen. TTR achieves strong performance on held-out Sudoku, Maze, and MATH500 data, solving of Sudoku boards correctly. Matched Maze controls show that reusing the selected state improves subsequent execution, and the anonymous code is available at [https://anonymous.4open.science/r/4D-570D/](https://anonymous.4open.science/r/4D-570D/).

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
test-time computation, latent reasoning, execution feedback, iterative refinement, state handoff, closed-loop reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.25 over 4 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_JaAGOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces Test-Time Revision (TTR), which trains a low-rank module to propose multiple bounded modifications to hidden states or prompt embeddings while keeping the backbone frozen. At test time, the model produces a complete output for each candidate, and a task-specific selector chooses one result. Further revision rounds use either the selected latent state or a re-encoded textual draft, depending on the task. The proposal module is trained with supervised task losses and remains fixed during inference. The method is evaluated on Sudoku, Maze, and MATH500.

Critical strengths
  1. A clear revision framework guided by task execution. The method evaluates latent proposals through complete task execution and uses the selected state, output, and feedback to guide subsequent revisions.

  2. Lightweight adaptation without test-time backpropagation. The method trains a low-rank proposal module while keeping the backbone frozen. At inference, all parameters remain fixed, and revision proceeds without gradient updates.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited gains from latent revision in the LLM experiment. On MATH500, TTR achieves 37.40% accuracy versus 37.27% without latent modification under the same Qwen model, draft feedback, and selector; the paired confidence interval includes zero. The improvement in Oracle@10 does not translate into a reliable gain in final-answer accuracy. Evaluation is also limited to one 0.8B model and one benchmark.

  2. Insufficient coverage of existing latent reasoning methods. Relevant latent reasoning methods, such as LTPO [1], LatentSeek [2], and GradCuit [3], are absent from both the related-work discussion and experimental comparisons. The paper therefore leaves its methodological differences and practical advantages over these approaches unclear.

  3. Performance gains are confounded by correctness-based selection. In Sudoku and Maze, the structural verifiers directly check the conditions used to judge final task success, effectively providing an exact correctness signal at test time. Describing this process as “label-free” does not convey the strength of this information. Since the main baselines use different selection rules, the reported gains do not clearly distinguish the contribution of latent revision from that of selecting candidates using the final evaluation criteria.

  4. Limited evidence for the benefit of retaining latent states. Retaining the selected latent state for subsequent reasoning is a central motivation, but direct evidence for this mechanism is largely confined to Maze. Sudoku uses only one revision, while Qwen re-encodes the selected textual draft rather than directly carrying its latent state into the next round. The broader benefit of retaining latent states beyond ordinary draft feedback remains unestablished.

  5. Missing details about the revision module. The paper does not explain how the Qwen task adapter constructs its features or incorporates information across tokens, leaving unclear how embedding modifications depend on the full problem. The Maze backbone and the exact intervention layer for Sudoku are also insufficiently specified, limiting the method’s interpretability and reproducibility.

References

[1] Wengao Ye, Yan Liang, and Lianlei Shan. Thinking on the Fly: Test-Time Reasoning Enhancement via Latent Thought Policy Optimization. ICLR, 2026. arXiv:2510.04182.

[2] Hengli Li et al. Seek in the Dark: Reasoning via Test-Time Instance-Level Policy Gradient in Latent Space. 2025. arXiv:2505.13308.

[3] Zhaoxin Yu et al. GradCuit: Credit-Assigned Gradient Flow Enables Robust and Interpretable Test-Time Latent Reasoning. 2026. arXiv:2608.02585.

Questions for authors

See the weaknesses above.

Reviewer_XxoKOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Test-Time Revision (TTR), a test-time method for latent reasoning. The method evaluates candidate changes to the internal state of a frozen model through the full task execution, and then jointly commits the selected output together with its latent state for the next revision round. Specifically, each candidate is executed with the task’s executor, the complete outputs are scored with a label-free verifier, and the selected latent state, output, and realized feedback are passed into the next revision round. They evaluate on the three benchmarks of Sudoku, Maze, and MATH500 and show competitive performance across the board.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a clear problem in test-time latent reasoning, where improving an intermediate latent score does not guarantee a correct complete output, and output reranking alone does not specify which state should be used for the next round. They address this with a simple and general design that evaluates every candidate through full task execution and keeps the selected state and output together, while always keeping the unchanged state as a fallback. In addition, the paper provides comprehensive experimental settings across a variety of reasoning benchmarks.

Critical weaknesses

For me, the novelty of the framework is limited. Specifically, the method generates several candidates, executes them, selects the best one with a verifier, and continues from it is the standard pattern of greedy or beam search with a verifier, as in Tree of Thoughts, verifier-guided step-level search. The MATH500 instantiation is especially close to Self-Refine [1], since it puts the selected draft back into the prompt with a review instruction. The motivation of TTR is that output selection does not specify which state guides the next round. However, in these existing methods, the next round already continues from the selected candidate, so the selected output and the next state are aligned by construction. As a result, I think the main contribution of this work is how the candidates are generated, through learned bounded perturbations of the latent state, and the paper should position its contribution around this rather than around the joint commit.

In term of the experimental design, the paper presents TTR as a reusable revision framework, but the actual effectiveness depends heavily on task-specific components. And all the three benchmark of Sudoku, Maze, and MATH500 use different adapters, executors, verifiers, and replanning rules, and these components requiere substantial task knowledge differences. For me, I am not fully convinced that the experiments establish the main claimed contribution of latent state revision and state consistency, because much of the performance appears to come from task-specific proposal generation and verification. In addition, the paper needs more polish in terms of writing to make sure every claim is self-contained with proper references.

Some minor comments about the paper writing, such as table presentation, which can be compressed to save more space on the main page.

[1]. Madaan, Aman, et al. "Self-refine: Iterative refinement with self-feedback." Advances in neural information processing systems 36 (2023).

Questions for authors
  1. Can you show how much performance changes as the number of revision rounds increases, and whether the gains continue after one or two revisions or mainly come from generating additional candidates?
  2. Increasing the number of branches substantially increases inference cost. It would be useful to show the wall-clock running time and the trade-off between performance and complexity computation given the same amount of runtime or executor calls.
Reviewer_LBZHOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

In reasoning models, it has been difficult to check whether an update was good or bad in later reasoning process. TTR addressed this issue by using feedback after full task execution, and succeeded in improving performance of Sudoku, Maze, and MATH500 on Qwen3.5-0.8B.

Critical strengths
  • The idea of using the feedback of the final task execution results is clear and sound, possibly opening up a new avenue of test-time scaling methodology in looped reasoners.
Critical weaknesses
  • TTR is tested on only one model (“Transformer”), making the assessment difficult whether TTR is an architecture-specific computational add-on or is a more generalizable measure in other architectures. To claim generalizability, there should be TTR results coupled with the standard strong reasoning models, such as HRM (Wang et al., 2025), TRM (Jolicoeur-Martineau, 2025), EqR (Huang+ 2026) or others.
  • Moreover, the detailed baseline architectures or the checkpoints details are not provided in Sudoku and Maze tasks. I guess these are based on some looped model, but few clue is given.
  • The comparison with TTC, TTT-Linear makes it difficult to evaluate the true merit of TTR. TTR is an additional training method requiring full execution together with other additional computations, TTR should be compared with such methods that build on frozen parameters and require additional training, not like TTC or TTT-linear where you originally have optimal control layer from the training time or test-time training structure.
  • There is no comparison to more naive (e.g., prolonging steps if the base model is a looped transformer model) nor other conventional test time scaling methods such as the ones provided in the related work section. Table 17 shows that TTR needs x2/x30 more wall time in Sudoku and maze, respectively, and I suspect other more simple test time scaling measures can improve the performance more in less computation.
  • The Sudoku and Maze benchmarks used in this work (Sudoku problems in Palm et al., 2018 and Maze in Schwarzschild et al., 2021) are different from and probably easier than Sudoku-Extreme and Maze-hard, which are used in HRM (Wang et al., 2025) and TRM (Joliceour-Martineau, 2025) and other important papers. This discrepancy, together with the lack of the model architecture details, makes it difficult to assess if TTR is truly beneficial in broad settings.
  • The way of writing should be improved. For example, in “3 Methodology” section, instead of starting from the model’s detailed structure, the authors should give a clear overview of what TTR is, what it is for, and how it is applied (e.g., “TTR is an add-on training method that is applied on a reasoning model of a frozen-parameter”). The whole description of TTR is scattered in the main draft and Appendix, making it hard to grasp the comprehensive view of what TTR is like. Many paragraphs do not start with a topic sentence, going against the conventions of academic writing.

Despite having clear conceptual clarity and strength, I score a 1 on this paper because of these shortcomings pointed out above.

Questions for authors
  • Is TTR added on to “Transformer” in Sudoku and Maze settings? If so, why is the parameter number of Maze TTR smaller than Maze Transformer (Table 17)?
  • If you include the data used to train TTR to the original Transformer training, does it improve the baseline Transformer performance? Does TTR outperform that training-budget-matched transformer baseline?
  • In Appendix A, it seems that the verifier explicitly uses the constraint information of each task. Does it have to be provided by human beings? From what I understand, one of the critical strengths of the looped reasoners lies in that they can learn rules/constraints of the puzzles and its solution methods at the same time. Does setting verifier with hand-made keys amount to rule leakage, naturally making the result being better? Can you replace this verifier settings to another one, possibly making it learnable from data and using no external constraint information?
  • I suppose the Maze performance is quite low in this model, considering other standard looped reasoners mark at least about 70-80% of accuracy. Do you have any explanation on here, other than using a different dataset?
  • The research question on line 66 goes: “how can full task execution guide both the evaluation of latent states and subsequent reasoning from the selected state”. Does the choice made by the TTR reasoner really help the following reasoning steps? Can you add some exaltations on in what way or using what kind of representation the verifier helps subsequent reasoning?
  • The three candidate boards of maze task in the box “Bounded proposal” in Figure 2 confuse me. Isn’t that the problem itself, in this case the board of maze itself, unchanged, while the possible path trajectories or next cells to reach are proposed?

What follow are some additional comments and questions for clarification purposes.

  • There seems no sentence clearly defining the abbreviation of “TTC”.
  • Is the anonymous GitHub repository shared in Abstract correct? It seems the repository is about video-guided 4D morphing.
Reviewer_dAFoOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TTR trains a lightweight proposal adapter on top of a frozen backbone. The adapter learns several bounded changes to the current latent state, using supervised branch losses and a diversity penalty. At test time, the model executes each candidate, selects an output, and continues from that result. Maze carries forward the selected hidden map and path. Qwen puts the selected draft back into the prompt and re-encodes it for the next round.

Critical strengths
  • The Maze experiment directly tests the value of continuing from a selected state. With the same candidate executions, carrying the selected map and path into round two raises the valid-path rate from 67.16% to 78.00% compared with restarting from the initial state. This is a good ablation study.
  • The matched controls are a strength. On Maze, learned proposals substantially outperform norm-matched random perturbations under the same execution budget.
Critical weaknesses
  • The evidence for iterative latent revision varies by task. Sudoku uses only one round. On MATH500, learned perturbations raise the chance of generating a correct answer among ten candidates from 44.53% to 51.87%, but final accuracy is nearly identical to simply feeding back the selected draft and reranking (37.40% vs. 37.27%)?
  • Please report GPU-hours and peak training memory for fitting the Qwen proposal adapter. This would help assess the cost of the gain.
  • The Maze results show that decoded paths help with selection and feedback. How much is gained by fully executing every proposal?
  • Fully executing every proposal may limit TTR’s usefulness when execution is expensive.
Questions for authors

N/A

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.