- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ReTrail uses reflection-token probability to decide when to backtrack and where to restart a reasoning trace. Regeneration briefly promotes then suppresses reflection. Math and coding experiments show higher mean accuracy across several models, with discarded generation counted separately.
Critical strengths
- Returning to an earlier prefix is a useful addition to reflection control. The fixed-trigger experiment isolates restart location and gives convincing evidence on AIME against entropy-based and random locations.
- The method needs no verifier or training. Evaluation spans four model families, and parameters selected on MATH-500 are shared across test settings.
Critical weaknesses
- The evidence is stronger for restart location than for hesitation-based triggering. Trigger controls use one seed, and their intervals in Appendix F include zero. Several Qwen-7B end-to-end gains are similarly unresolved. The claims should reflect this difference, or the trigger study should be repeated on more problems.
- Equal retained-output limits allow ReTrail more computation: total generation rises by 15.2% on average. The matched-generation s1 control helps, but covers only Qwen-7B and one seed. It does not establish a general advantage at equal compute, especially with hosted probe and replay costs.
Questions for authors
- Suggested control: does hesitation-triggered rollback still outperform entropy triggering across independent seeds?
- Clarification: what are the total hosted costs, including probability probes and prefix replay, relative to Original?
3 comments
Q1: Does hesitation-triggered rollback still outperform entropy triggering across independent seeds?
Yes, in the three independent seeds we ran on Qwen-7B. Table R4 lists the number of solved problems in each seed. The first entropy variant replaces only the trigger, and the second also uses entropy to choose the restart point.
Table R4. Hesitation vs. entropy, solved problems per seed (Qwen-7B).
| Method | AIME 2026, seeds 1 / 2 / 3 (of 30) | LiveCodeBench, seeds 1 / 2 / 3 (of 80) |
|---|---|---|
| ReTrail | 17 / 10 / 16 | 33 / 33 / 29 |
| w/ entropy trigger | 15 / 9 / 13 | 30 / 32 / 29 |
| w/ entropy trigger + entropy-peak rollback | 14 / 8 / 14 | 28 / 28 / 26 |
ReTrail matches or exceeds the entropy trigger in each seed on both benchmarks, and it scores higher than the fully entropy-based variant in each seed. The entropy variants intervene 2.6 to 2.7 times per problem, at least as often as ReTrail (Section 5.4), so ReTrail's lead is not explained by intervening more. The pooled accuracies are in Table R1.
Q2: What are the total hosted costs, including probability probes and prefix replay, relative to Original?
Table R5 gives the cost for the three hosted models, as per-problem averages pooled over the four benchmarks.
Table R5. Token cost on the hosted models.
| Model | Newly generated tokens vs. Original (deleted tokens included) | Replayed prefix, as a share of Original's length | Replayed prefix is billed as |
|---|---|---|---|
| DeepSeek-V3.2-Speciale | +9.4% (31.58k vs. 28.86k) | 17.5% (5.04k) | output |
| GPT-OSS-120B | +2.6% (4.94k vs. 4.81k) | 25.8% (1.24k) | input |
| Kimi-K2.5 | +16.2% (19.40k vs. 16.70k) | 21.7% (3.62k) | input |
The first column pools all problems, so it differs slightly from the per-benchmark averages in the paper.
Table R5 counts every token the provider bills. ReTrail generates 2.6% to 16.2% more tokens than Original on the hosted models, with deleted tokens counted.
Probability probes add no cost. The interface returns the top-20 token probabilities with every generated token, and ReTrail reads the hesitation mass from them without sending extra requests. The two-request recovery in Appendix C.2 is a fallback for services that do not return usable token probabilities; the reported runs did not need it. The submitted appendix lists probability probes among the hosted costs (Appendices C.1, E, and G). That wording describes our early interface tests, which sent extra requests to read the probabilities at a given position. The reported runs did not send them. We apologize for the confusion this wording caused, and we will correct these descriptions in the appendix.
Prefix replay comes from the hosted interface and is not part of the method. A hosted interface keeps no generation state between requests, so each rollback passes the kept prefix to the model again. On a locally run model, generation resumes directly from the rollback point and replay costs nothing. For GPT-OSS-120B and Kimi-K2.5 the prefix goes into the request and is billed as input, at a lower price than output. The Speciale endpoint does not accept a supplied prefix (Appendix C.1), so the model rewrites the prefix before continuing and it is billed as output. Speciale is therefore the least favorable billing case, and we report it in full. Its billed output is about 1.27 times that of Original, for gains of 4.4 to 8.1 pp on the four benchmarks. This stays well below the cost of sampling a second solution, and ReTrail needs no verifier or additional model.
We will add Table R5 to the cost section of the appendix, and Appendix C will state that the two-request recovery is needed only on services that do not return usable token probabilities.
Follow-up from the Authors
Dear Reviewer CFJr,
Many thanks for your thoughtful review. We found the experiments you suggested very valuable and carried out each of them with care. Before the discussion period closes, we would like to highlight the main results from our response, which support the method on every point you raised.
- Evidence across seeds (W1, Q1). Our three-seed trigger study confirms the single-seed result. ReTrail leads the entropy trigger by 6.67 pp on AIME 2026 and 1.67 pp on LiveCodeBench, and it beats both random triggers in every seed (Tables R1, R4). Over six seeds, ReTrail outperforms Original by 2.02 pp and leads on each of the four benchmarks (Table R2).
- Compute cost (W2, Q2). At equal compute over three seeds, ReTrail leads s1 by 6.67 pp on AIME 2026 and 3.33 pp on LiveCodeBench (Table R3). s1 itself stays below Original, which shows that extra tokens alone do not produce the gain. On the hosted models, ReTrail generates only 2.6% to 16.2% more tokens than Original and reading the probabilities adds no cost. Table R5 gives the full billed cost, including prefix replay.
We believe the paper is clearly stronger with these additions, and we hope you will feel the same. Thank you for the suggestions that made this possible and for your time during this busy period.
Best regards, The Authors
Thank you for your careful review and concrete suggestions. We respond to each weakness and question below.
W1: The evidence is stronger for restart location than for hesitation-based triggering. The trigger study uses one seed, and several Qwen-7B end-to-end gains are unresolved.
We followed your second suggestion and repeated the trigger study on Qwen-7B with three seeds, which triples the number of responses (90 on AIME 2026, 240 on LiveCodeBench). Each variant below changes only when the intervention fires and keeps rollback and bias unchanged (Table R1).
Table R1. Trigger signals compared (Qwen-7B, three seeds).
The variants intervene at similar rates (2.3 to 2.7 times per problem). ReTrail's first seed here is a separate run made together with the variants, so its LiveCodeBench total (95) is two problems above Table 1 (93).
The single-seed result holds with three seeds. ReTrail is ahead of the random trigger and the random-position variant in all three seeds we ran on both benchmarks. Although the margin over the entropy trigger on LiveCodeBench is modest, ReTrail matches or exceeds it in all three seeds on both benchmarks, and its lead on AIME 2026 averages 6.67 pp. The last row keeps how early the first intervention happens and removes only its link to hesitation, which indicates that the advantage comes from the hesitation signal.
For the end-to-end gains, we added three new seeds for Original and ReTrail on Qwen-7B on all four benchmarks, so the main comparison now has six seeds (Table R2).
Table R2. Original vs. ReTrail over six seeds (Qwen-7B).
ReTrail is ahead on all four benchmarks and in each of the three new seeds, and the gain stays at about 2 pp.
In the revision, the trigger claim in Section 5.4 will rest on these three-seed results and will give the margin for each comparison, so that the text reflects where the evidence is stronger (restart location, random trigger) and where the margin is smaller (entropy trigger on LiveCodeBench).
W2: Equal retained-output limits allow ReTrail more computation. The matched-generation s1 comparison covers only Qwen-7B and one seed, and hosted probe and replay costs are not counted.
We extended the matched-generation s1 comparison on Qwen-7B from one seed to three. For every problem, s1 is forced to keep reasoning until it reaches ReTrail's token count on that problem. We match two budgets, ReTrail's retained length and ReTrail's total generation, which also counts the deleted tokens (Table R3).
Table R3. ReTrail vs. s1 at matched generation (Qwen-7B, three seeds).
ReTrail's token count includes deleted tokens. s1 lands within 1.3% of its target length.
At equal compute, ReTrail is never below s1 in any seed on either benchmark. s1 with this budget does not exceed Original (42/90 and 89/240), so extra tokens alone do not produce the gain.
This comparison is limited to Qwen-7B, where we control decoding and can match the budget token by token. For the hosted models, ReTrail sends no separate probe calls, because the interface returns the top-20 token probabilities with every generated token and the hesitation mass is read from them. Prefix replay is caused by the hosted interface, which keeps no generation state between requests, and is not part of the method. We report its cost for each hosted model in our response to Q2 (Table R5).
We will replace the single-seed table in the appendix with the three-seed s1 results.