- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Red Alert Bench, a benchmark and simulation environment for evaluating multimodal agents on long-horizon planning and execution in a real-time strategy game. The benchmark contains 217 human-authored tasks. It supports text, image, and combined observations, limited and full visibility, mid-task handoff, and one-on-one adversarial evaluation. Experiments involve eight LLMs, a non-LLM action model, and a human baseline. The main findings include better task performance with text-only observations than image-primary observations, frequent repetition of commands that cannot take effect, and a substantial positional bias in competitive matches. In addition to final task outcomes, the benchmark records observations, commands, simulator-state changes, and goal progress to support trajectory-level analysis.
Critical strengths
-
A broad and potentially useful evaluation environment.
The benchmark covers a relatively diverse set of long-horizon tasks and supports multiple observation modalities, visibility settings, repeated attempts, mid-task handoff, and adversarial matches. The simulator-based success conditions and detailed execution records are useful additions beyond evaluations based only on final model responses.
-
The paper identifies concrete relevant agent behaviors.
The analyses reveal several phenomena, including repeated unaffordable or ineffective commands, differences between issuing a valid command and achieving its intended effect, failure to convert stated plans into tool calls, and strong positional effects in competitive evaluation. The inclusion of human and rule-constrained baselines also helps the understanding of some findings.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited scientific contribution beyond behavioral instrumentation. If the intended scope of Red Alert Bench is limited to diagnosing observable behavioral failures, then the paper’s scientific contribution appears relatively narrow. Most of the proposed diagnostics are simulator-specific, hand-defined checks of events such as repeated commands, insufficient resources, action-to-effect conversion, and missing tool calls. Although these measurements are useful for inspecting trajectories, the paper does not yet demonstrate that they yield a general diagnostic methodology or new, transferable understanding of why multimodal agents fail. In its current form, the contribution is therefore closer to a well-instrumented evaluation environment than a systematic framework for agent failure diagnosis. The paper should clarify what generalizable scientific insight Red Alert Bench provides beyond its environment and logging infrastructure.
-
Limited benchmark inspectability and modality control.
Observation modality is one of the paper’s main experimental factors, yet the paper does not provide representative examples of the actual inputs supplied under the text-only, image-plus-text, and image-primary conditions. This limits the reader’s ability to assess task difficulty, benchmark validity, and whether the three conditions are information-matched. In particular, because the interfaces differ in the information and naming they expose, the reported performance gap cannot be cleanly interpreted as a visual-perception gap.
Questions for authors
- What is the intended scope of “diagnosis” in Red Alert Bench? Is the benchmark intended to identify observable behavioral patterns only, or to attribute failures to underlying capabilities such as perception, planning, execution monitoring, and recovery? What generalizable scientific conclusions should readers draw from the proposed diagnostics?
- Could the authors include several representative benchmark examples of the actual text-only, image-plus-text, and image-primary inputs, together with the raw image observation, corresponding text observation, underlying simulator state, task instructions, success predicates, and an example trajectory? This would substantially improve the inspectability of the benchmark.
2 comments
“yet the paper does not provide representative examples of the actual inputs supplied under the text-only, image-plus-text, and image-primary conditions.”
“Could the authors include several representative benchmark examples of the actual text-only, image-plus-text, and image-primary inputs, together with the raw image observation, corresponding text observation, underlying simulator state, task instructions, success predicates, and an example trajectory?”
Thank you for the suggestion. We have included some examples of benchmarks in the Appendix of the manuscript, as the rebuttal cannot attach figures.
“What is the intended scope of “diagnosis” in Red Alert Bench?”
Embodied agents and robotic agents are an important novel direction, but they lack sufficient data. Our work provides a similar environment to examine the capability of language models in such a scenario. We hope our work can shed light on the behavior of LLMs operating in an agentic harness that requires capabilities such as complex planning, multi-objective commanding, and multimodality. Our additional experiment on transfer learning above provides a very positive signal of the usefulness of our benchmark.
Thanks again for the careful review. We believe these additional experiments address the concerns you raised. We would greatly appreciate it if you could consider raising your score.
“Although these measurements are useful for inspecting trajectories, the paper does not yet demonstrate that they yield a general diagnostic methodology or new, transferable understanding of why multimodal agents fail.”
First, we would like to clarify that this benchmark is not a synthetic benchmark - it is taken from a real-world gaming environment, along with human annotator-written fine-grained scenarios. Existing benchmarks typically focus on specific aspects of agent capabilities or particular task settings. In contrast, Red Alert Bench provides a unified framework for evaluating and diagnosing a broad range of high-level capabilities relevant to embodied intelligence and robotics. It supports both capability-specific evaluation and diagnosis, such as spatial reasoning, active perception, and planning, and integrated evaluation and diagnosis of how these capabilities work together in dynamic, long-horizon tasks. This unified approach enables us to assess not only individual capabilities, but also how their interactions affect overall agent performance and lead to failures.
To further prove the usefulness of our benchmark on real-world tasks, we conduct the following experiment.
To examine the transferability of capabilities learned from RAB, we fine-tuned Qwen3.5-9B using LoRA on RAB-generated data. The model's accuracy on precise visual localization improved from 20% to 93% on held-out RAB tasks. More importantly, the trained model achieved a 2.0 percentage-point improvement on MeasureBench (Lin et al., 2026) instrument-reading tasks (95% CI [+0.4, +3.7]). These results demonstrate that specific visual-spatial capabilities learned from RAB can transfer to external tasks.
Then, to further assess the generalizability, we compared our model rankings with benchmarks across diverse domains (using Kendall's rank correlation). The τ goes from 0.667 to 0.4; the positive correlations provide evidence that RAB captures aspects of agent performance shared across different evaluation settings.
We also found that the visual-spatial limitations identified by RAB appear in embodied reasoning tasks. By analyzing model errors on ERQA (Gemini Robotics Team et al., 2025), we identified similar difficulties in visual information extraction, spatial reference frames, and reasoning about object interactions. When images were replaced with textual scene descriptions, the model correctly answered 14 of 30 previously challenging questions. Furthermore, under comparable direct-answer settings, model rankings on RAB and ERQA were consistent. These findings further support the relevance of RAB's capability-level diagnostics to embodied intelligence and robotics.
We will include the full experimental results, implementation details, and additional analyses in the revised manuscript and supplementary materials.