- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
ANCHORZYME is a retrieval-augmented framework for zero-shot enzyme generation, where the goal is to generate candidate enzyme sequences using only a substrate molecule as input, without access to its known enzyme, EC label, reaction products, or protein structure. The authors identify an activity–structure trade-off in existing methods: improving predicted enzyme–substrate compatibility can reduce the structural confidence of generated proteins. To address this issue, ANCHORZYME separates retrieved enzyme information into two parts: a scaffold anchor that provides a structurally plausible starting sequence, and catalytic donor memories that provide residue-level information for sequence editing. The framework uses a biochemical knowledge graph for retrieval, a frozen UniKP model to construct teacher-supervised edits, and catalytic and sequence-plausibility discriminators to guide a two-stage editing process. The paper also introduce REALUNKNOWN-389, containing 389 molecules with no recorded catalytic enzyme in the database snapshot. On this benchmark, ANCHORZYME achieves a predicted UniKP log10(kcat) of 0.384 and an ESMFold normalized pLDDT of 0.770, outperforming the evaluated substrate-only baselines on both metrics.
Critical strengths
The anchor–donor decomposition is biologically motivated and provides a sensible design strategy. A key strength is the explicit separation of scaffold preservation from local residue editing. A protein must maintain a stable structural framework while allowing changes near functionally important residues to support new substrate interactions. This idea is implemented by selecting a scaffold anchor, retrieving distinct donor enzymes, and aligning their sequences to identify site, shell, and distal regions. The donor-induced edit prior provides alternative residues, while the anchor prior encourages preservation of the original scaffold. The two-stage sampling procedure further separates initial site/shell editing from subsequent distal editing. This is more structured than directly conditioning a generator on an undifferentiated set of retrieved sequences. The anchor-relative teacher objective is also reasonable because it explicitly asks whether a proposed sequence improves over its starting enzyme rather than maximizing an unconstrained score.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper does not sufficiently address the distinction between recognizing a substrate molecule and specifying a catalytic transformation. A substrate alone generally does not determine which reaction an enzyme should catalyze. The same molecule may participate in multiple enzymatic reactions, involving different reaction centers, products, cofactors, and catalytic mechanisms. However, the proposed setting explicitly excludes reaction products and EC labels, and REALUNKNOWN-389 does not provide a known target enzyme or experimentally verified catalytic activity. This creates an important ambiguity in the learning objective. It is unclear what constitutes a scientifically correct enzyme proposal for a given molecule, beyond receiving a favorable predicted compatibility score. A generated enzyme might be compatible with a molecule in some sense without catalyzing a useful or intended transformation. I think the benchmark is valuable as a chemically novel screening set, but its current construction does not establish whether the generated enzymes solve a well-defined catalytic task.
- The dependence on UniKP throughout both model development and evaluation. I think this creates a risk of surrogate optimization bias: the framework is explicitly designed to produce sequences that score well under UniKP, and its main reported activity improvement is measured using that same predictor. Even though UniKP is frozen, its use as both a training signal and an evaluation metric means that a higher score does not independently demonstrate better catalysis. Plus, for the structural evidence, ESMFold pLDDT measures confidence in a predicted structure, not experimental foldability, stability, or catalytic-site geometry.
- The authors argue that the separation of anchors and donor memories enables better enzyme generation. However, an alternative explanation is that starting from natural enzymes already provides strong structural confidence, while local mutations and a larger proposal pool increase the chance of obtaining high surrogate scores.
Questions for authors
- How is catalytic success defined when only a substrate molecule is provided?
- How can you rule out optimization toward the UniKP surrogate rather than real catalytic improvement?
- How much improvement comes from the anchor itself, and how much comes from learned editing?
3 comments
3. How do we separate anchor, donor and pool-size effects?
The natural anchor is an intentional starting point in our method; the incremental donor contribution is tested by holding that starting point fixed. Across 114 editable development targets, returned-set full-length recovery is 0.09381 with distinct donors off and 0.11428 with donors retained—a gain of 2.05 percentage points, with a paired 95% confidence interval of [1.49, 2.65]. Mean actual returns increase from 4.54 to 9.06. Both settings share the anchor, editable support and budget, identifying the donor contribution to candidate availability and set-level recovery.
To examine larger pools and additional mutations as alternative explanations, the 99-target full-length experiment gives every policy a requested cap of 20 and the same final selector. Simple editing also matches the learned output's substitution count. Actual candidate totals per seed are 1,980 for retrieval, 1,900 for the simple-editing hybrid and 1,900 for the learned-editing hybrid. The ProSmith results above come from this setting: learned and simple-editing hybrids use the same candidate count and obtain observed means of 0.07389 and 0.06783, respectively.
The experiments have distinct roles: the fixed-anchor intervention tests donor information, and the cap- and edit-count-matched controls test the editing policies. The design uses natural sequences as proposal starting points and distinct donors to expand the residue choices available for exploration.
Thanks for your rebuttal and additional experiments. The rebuttal improves the experimental evidence. But I would keep the original rating. The new independent evidence of catalytic improvement is still limited. the 95% CI both include zero, which don't provide conclusive evidence for the capability of your learned method. Plus, the activity-structure trade-off remains unresolved. The structural analysis is informative but unchanged anchors achieve higher pLDDT than learned edits.
Thank you for recognizing the anchor–donor decomposition and staged editing design. We address your questions with external pairing evaluation, modern generation baselines and structural analysis. Our application goal is to provide ranked sequence candidates when a substrate is available but a target enzyme is unknown, and to test the contributions of retrieval, donor information and learned editing.
1. What task does substrate-only input define?
ANCHORZYME addresses the proposal stage of enzyme discovery: given a molecule, return a ranked set of enzyme sequences for further investigation. Section 3.1 already defines this output. The application starts precisely where a target enzyme, EC label, product or known protein structure is unavailable.
Your observation that one substrate can participate in multiple reactions is consistent with a candidate-set formulation. Requiring a product or EC label in advance would define reaction-specified enzyme design. We focus on the earlier discovery stage, using available biochemical knowledge to supply sequence starting points and new local edit choices for molecules without an assigned enzyme.
“Unknown” in REALUNKNOWN-389 has a specific meaning: the database snapshot contains no recorded catalytic enzyme for the molecule. This is an application cohort for candidate discovery. We assess the proposals through pairing scores and structural analysis, and examine candidate recovery on development targets with reference sequences.
We will foreground this task definition: the paper expands the sequence candidates available for validation in the unknown-enzyme setting, with a ranked set as its output.
2. How do we assess performance beyond the training scorer?
We evaluate frozen candidates with ProSmith-ESP, which was used neither in training nor in generation guidance or selection. Its predicted enzyme–substrate pairing scores directly match the candidate-discovery task.
On 99 full-length targets, all three policies share a requested candidate cap of 20 and the final selector:
The learned hybrid has the highest observed mean among the three policies, 0.07389. It uses the same actual candidate count as the simple-editing hybrid: 1,900 candidates per seed, compared with 1,980 for retrieval.
Paired-difference 95% intervals: learned hybrid minus retrieval, [−0.01120, 0.03420]; learned hybrid minus simple-editing hybrid, [−0.00470, 0.01635].
Following your suggestion on structure, we further examined complete sequences and local annotated regions. Across 99 targets, mean Cα pLDDT is 85.96 for learned editing, 86.11 for count-matched simple editing and 88.98 for unchanged anchors. Across all 11 eligible targets with experimental references and annotations, the same mean substitution count gives an annotated-site distance deviation of 1.120 Å for learned editing and 1.436 Å for simple editing; nine targets favor learned editing. This descriptive analysis directly assesses local geometry. Annotations include catalytic, cofactor- and metal-related positions and overlap the existing motif information.
Each addition measures a specific property: ProSmith assesses external pairing scores, full-length pLDDT assesses prediction confidence, and reference-site distances assess local geometric changes after editing.
The modern-baseline comparisons further highlight ANCHORZYME's full-length structural-confidence advantage. Under the same ESMFold settings, our mean pLDDT and that of RFD3 are 86.80 and 74.18 on 74 shared targets; the corresponding values for ANCHORZYME and Proteina/Complexa are 86.45 and 51.58 on 78 shared targets. This direct structural assessment is central to our response to the structural-quality concern. The corresponding returned-set ProSmith means are 0.05113/0.10394 and 0.05045/0.10529, providing a complementary view of predicted pairing propensity. pLDDT evaluates each method's fixed native first complete sequence; ProSmith averages all returned candidates within target. These endpoints characterize structural prediction confidence and pairing propensity, while annotated-site distance deviations further examine local geometry.