- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a benchmark, a dataset, and an MLLM-based model all designed for capture-time photography guidance covering two aspects of photography: (1) photographer-side decision making and composition refinement; and (2) subject-side pose generation and recommendation. Through extensive experiments, the authors demonstrate the benefits and superiority of their benchmark, dataset, and model.
Critical strengths
The work is presented very well, is well-motivated, and offers valid contributions. Although MLLMs have been used in the curation of the proposed dataset and benchmark, the use of experts in the loop and self-verification mechanisms makes the collected data more reliable. The model has been trained with task-specific reward models through GRPO RL training which have been demonstrated to enhance the capabilities of the model. In addition to quantitative experiments, the authors validate the superiority of the proposed model through a subjective study.
Critical weaknesses
I have only a few points here:
• (Minor) Based on my understanding of the literature, the first contribution claim is too broad. The paper claims formulation of capture-time photography guidance as its contribution, while prior works such as Venus and [1] propose capture-time aesthetic guidance and composition decision making (Keep/Refine), respectively. The authros are encouraged to narrow down this claim and reposition their novelty.
• (Minor) I’m wondering whether it is possible for the model to get stuck in a rejection loop (e.g. the photographer wants to take a photo of an object or a scene that has little aesthetic value regardless of the composition). To make the model more practical, it would be interesting to think of these cases and design a mechanism to break the loop.
• (Minor) From a practical standpoint, the “reject” composition decision should come with clear instructions as to how to resolve the composition or capturing issue, helping the photographer recapture the scene. Based on the examples shown in the paper, the textual rationale for “reject” decision only states the problem without instructions for refinement.
• (Minor) Accroding to the paper, general-purpose MLLMs and cropping methods have complementary capabilities: MLLMs are better at making composition decisions while cropping methods excel at applying refinements. Their integration, therefore, can create a good baseline: an MLLM makes the decision and if refinement is needed a cropping method is called up. The authors are encouraged to discuss this baseline or if time allows add it to their set of baselines.
[1] Li, Jiawan, et al. "Towards smart point-and-shoot photography." 2025 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2025.
Questions for authors
I don't have any major concerns and vote for acceptance of this paper. The minor points above are my suggestions for improvement. I thank authors for putting together this interesting piece of work.
3 comments
I thank the authors for the additional clarifications and experiments and for taking into account my recommendation on repositioning their novelty. I believe their revision has improved the quality of their work and continue to recommend clear acceptance.
Finally, I suggest that authors consider filling out the empty spaces in the main manuscript by adding back content from Appendix for the revised/final version.
Dear Reviewer iM3o,
Thank you very much for your valuable feedback and follow-up. Your suggestions have helped us better position our contribution, improve the actionable guidance, and strengthen the baseline comparisons. We will also move relevant appendix content into the available space in the main text, as suggested.
We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful review and time.
Best regards, The Authors
Response to reviewer iM3o
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and constructive suggestions for improvement. We address the questions below. All changes have been incorporated into the revised manuscript and highlighted in red.
Question1:
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. We agree that prior work, including Venus [1] and SPAS [2], has already introduced capture-time aesthetic guidance. We therefore frame our first contribution as extending the formulation of capture-time photography guidance to cover both photographer-side composition decisions and refinement and subject-side pose recommendation. Fig. 13 in Appendix H of the revised manuscript illustrates this extension by comparing ShutterMuse with conventional post-capture cropping, Venus [1], and SPAS [2].
Question2:
Response: Thank you for your insightful observation. A mechanism like this could help break the rejection loop: if the same issue triggers Reject again, or if the total number of Reject decisions for the current shot exceeds a predefined threshold, the interface would offer two options: Keep adjusting or Capture anyway. Choosing the latter would end the guidance loop immediately. This gives the photographer the final say even when the model continues to suggest an adjustment.
From a training-data perspective, a complementary approach would be to construct multi-turn correction trajectories that include the previous recommendation, the updated view, and user feedback on whether the adjustment helped or was feasible. Expert-verified responses would teach the model to reassess successful adjustments, propose alternatives when an action fails, and defer to the photographer when no feasible improvement remains, rather than repeat the same instruction. This would require conditioning on interaction history and is a direction for future work.
Question3:
Response: We totally agree with your suggestion regarding Reject decisions and have revised the annotations so that each rationale gives the photographer a concrete next step. Please see our response to Reviewer hxvz’s Weakness2 and Appendix A.1 Fig\. 9 of the revised manuscript for details. After the revision, each Reject decision comes with a concrete suggestion for improving the shot. The guidance covers camera position and orientation eg˙,˙changingcameraheight,adjustingpitch,orsteppingback, framing eg˙,˙excludedistractingclutter, and camera settings eg˙,˙adjustingfocusorfocallength.
Question4:
Response: Thank you for suggesting this two-stage baseline. We have added it to Table 1 of the revised manuscript: Gemini-3.0-Flash, which achieved the highest Macro-F1 among the baselines, makes the three-way decision. When it predicts Refine, Venus [1], which achieved the highest IoU among the baselines, provides the crop. Compared with this two-stage baseline, the revised ShutterMuse improves IoU from 66.65% to 74.74%, reduces BDE from 0.071 to 0.052, and increases [email protected] from 53.12% to 68.25%. It also achieves a higher KSR ∗∗781˙3 and MLLM-Score **0\.69 vs\. 0\.62**, with a higher Macro-F1 ∗∗700˙9.
Thank you again for your thoughtful suggestions, which have helped us clarify our contribution and improve the guidance and baseline comparisons.
[1] Venus: Benchmarking and Empowering Multimodal Large Language Models for Aesthetic Guidance and Cropping, CVPR 2026.
[2] Towards Smart Point-and-Shoot Photography, CVPR 2025.