- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Aesthetic-Guided 6-DoF Image Editing, a novel framework that improves photographic composition through small camera translations and rotations while aiming to preserve scene content. To overcome the absence of such a dataset for direct supervision, the authors construct Aes6D, a dataset and benchmark containing 26,834 samples across nine composition patterns. Starting from high-quality photographs, the authors apply composition-aware camera perturbations and view synthesis to generate degraded views, using the inverse motions as corrective supervision. The dataset includes both single-DoF and multi-DoF adjustments, composition reasoning, and quality filtering. On top of the dataset, the authors further explore a two-stage training approach combining supervised fine-tuning with DoF-GRPO, which uses per-DoF geometric rewards, field-wise relative advantages, and token-level credit assignment to refine camera-motion predictions. The predicted adjustments are applied through a view-synthesis pipeline to produce edited images. Experiments show that the resulting method improves composition while largely preserving scene content, outperforming the evaluated composition and image editing baselines.
Critical strengths
- The pipeline of constructing a dataset is well designed. Instead of applying random perturbations to good photos, the framework intentionally degrades composition principles to create bad views, using the reverse motion as the ground truth. Its greatest strength lies in establishing a supervisory signal that bridges minor camera adjustments with meaningful compositional changes.
- The framework that converts the abstract goal of making a photo more aesthetically pleasing into explicit translation and rotation parameters are novel and convincing. By addressing both single and multi-axis adjustments while providing compositional reasoning, the system makes the direction of improvement easy to interpret and enables potential integration with real-world camera controls.
- Their proposed objectives are well validated by ablation studies. Applying DoF-GRPO shows clear improvements over standard SFT and conventional GRPO.
Critical weaknesses
- The evidence for generalization in composition improvement remains limited. On the 50 OOD images in Table 3, the human-evaluated win rate against the input view is 56% for the proposed method and 54% for PhotoFramer. A larger and more diverse OOD evaluation, together with confidence intervals, would help establish whether this small advantage is reliable. The paper should also clarify the annotators’ expertise and evaluation instructions and report inter-annotator agreement.
- Since the authors construct ground-truth camera movements, I wonder about the accuracy of the trained MLLM's predicted camera parameters. Providing a quantitative evaluation of these parameter predictions would make the paper significantly more convincing.
- The final image generation process is not explained with sufficient detail to ensure reproducibility. While the main text briefly notes that the predicted camera movement is applied to a view-synthesis pipeline, the details provided in Appendix C.4 is related to the data generation stage. The paper should explicitly specify how the reference image and model inputs are configured at inference time, and clarify how this inference workflow differs from the data generation process.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors report per-DoF prediction errors against the ground-truth camera motions to directly assess the accuracy of the learned camera control?
- Could the authors specify the reference images and model inputs used during inference and clarify any differences from the dataset-construction pipeline described in Appendix C.4?
2 comments
Thank you very much for taking the time to get back to us, we truly appreciate it. We are glad to hear that our response have addressed your concerns and strengthened your support for our work. Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback and constructive suggestions, which have helped us improve the paper.
Thank you for answering my questions and sorry for late reply. The expanded human evaluation provides stronger evidence that the method improves composition while preserving scene content on images amenable to viewpoint correction. The per-DoF results on 1,000 examples also address my question about camera-control accuracy, and the clarification of the inference inputs resolves my concern about the editing pipeline. Although I am keeping my score at Weak Accept, I now support acceptance more strongly.