- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SafeDivertor, a framework that estimates divertor heat flux for ITER. Taking T1 model as the backbone, SafeDivertor focuses on online operation, compared to offline infrared-based estimations. Four techniques are used to augment the backbone model: physical prior-aware initialization, input perturbation, spectral-aware reconstruction optimization, and progressive training.
Critical strengths
- This work demonstrates both improved accuracy (MSE, MAE) and spectral alignment (LSD, LSD-HF) compared to baselines.
- The paper is well-written, and the illustrations are intuitive.
Critical weaknesses
- Motivation needs better clarification. In the 2nd paragraph of Introduction, the authors mention that previous approaches including PINN and CNN are limited in terms of online reconstruction. However, Figure 1(c) shows neural network workflow is online-oriented. There appears to be a conflict.
- The definition of online-oriented is not clear.
- More details of baselines are needed to show fair comparisons.
Questions for authors
- Why are earlier NN-based reconstruction work not online-oriented?
- Why are methods dependent on thermal measurements and heat-conduction modeling not applicable to online-oriented reconstruction?
- Could you justify the comparison with baseline is fair? Are the baselines well-trained, under similar condition with SafeDivertor?
- What level of latency does "online-oriented" correspond to?
- Can existing work, e.g., the CNN work in Related Work section, be easily adapted to support online-oriented reconstruction?
2 comments
Dear Reviewer sntY,
The authors have submitted their rebuttal and we are closing in on the end of the discussion period. Please take some time to carefully read over the rebuttal and respond whether your concerns have been addressed.
Best, AC
Thank you for your valuable feedback, which helps us improve the quality of our work. We highlight the changes in blue in the revised manuscript and address your questions below.
W1, W2, Q1, and Q2. Online-oriented reconstruction and limits of prior workflows
Response to W1, W2, Q1, and Q2
Thank you for pointing out the ambiguity. Our original wording made the limitations of the two cited workflows sound like limitations of the neural network architectures themselves. In the revised Introduction, we describe the requirements of each method explicitly (Section 1, Lines 46–51).
The two workflows face different constraints on reconstruction during discharge. Aymerich et al. [1] train their PINN with fixed initial and boundary conditions in the loss. When those conditions change, the formulation they demonstrate requires retraining with the new conditions, which limits direct reuse of the trained model across discharges. Looby et al. [2] train and evaluate their CNN on ANSYS-simulated thermocouple signals. Applying their workflow on NSTX-U requires dedicated thermocouples embedded beneath the divertor tile surface. The CNN takes a temperature sequence that includes the thermal response after heating ends, so inference must wait until that part of the sequence has been recorded.
The conventional infrared workflow in Figure 1(b) is typically run after the discharge. The EAST workflow [3] first measures the divertor target temperature with an infrared camera and then reconstructs the heat flux by solving a transient inverse heat-conduction problem. The cost of this numerical inversion limits how quickly the workflow can update heat-flux estimates during a discharge (Appendix A.1).
In SafeDivertor, online-oriented reconstruction means updating the heat-flux profile during the discharge as each diagnostic window becomes available. Once the window's signals are aligned, SafeDivertor reconstructs a time-resolved radial heat-flux profile directly from routinely acquired macroscopic plasma-state signals in a single forward pass (Section 1, Figure 1(c), Lines 82–84). So each rolling update can use the existing plasma diagnostics alone (Section 4.1).
W3 and Q3. Baseline training and fair comparison
Response to W3 and Q3
We provide the detailed training protocol in Appendix B.4 and list the key model hyperparameters in Table 7. SafeDivertor and all baselines use the same data split, preprocessing, input window, and batch size. We train every model for 500,000 steps and evaluate its final checkpoint on the same test discharges. Figure 4 shows that the baseline training losses generally decrease and stabilize within this shared budget (Appendix B.4).
Q4. What level of latency does "online-oriented" correspond to?
Response to Q4
Once a 500-step input window is ready, SafeDivertor takes 11.313 ms for one forward pass at batch size 1 (Section 5, Table 6). The current experimental conditions at EAST prevent us from measuring end-to-end latency on the device.
However, this limitation does not diminish the core contribution of SafeDivertor. Our experiments show that macroscopic plasma-state signals suffice to reconstruct time-resolved radial heat-flux profiles directly. All of these input signals are routinely acquired during plasma discharges. SafeDivertor can update the profile during the discharge with a single forward pass as soon as a diagnostic window is aligned (Section 1, Figure 1(c)). The conventional infrared workflow shown in Figure 1(b) reconstructs the heat-flux profile by post-shot heat-conduction inversion, so the profile is available only after the discharge ends.
Q5. Can existing work, e.g., the CNN work in Related Work section, be easily adapted to support online-oriented reconstruction?
Response to Q5
Our online-oriented reconstruction paradigm is independent of the network architecture. A CNN can implement the same mapping from aligned windows of macroscopic plasma-state signals to time-resolved radial heat-flux profiles.
However, adapting the CNN-based method of Looby et al. [2] to our online-oriented reconstruction task requires changes to its inputs and outputs. Their workflow relies on signals from thermocouples embedded beneath the divertor tile surface, which they simulate in ANSYS for training. Their CNN estimates heat-flux profile parameters from a temperature sequence that includes the thermal response after heating ends. Therefore, the model must wait for that part of the sequence before it can produce an estimate for the heating interval.
References
[1] Physics informed neural networks towards the real-time calculation of heat fluxes at W7-X
[2] Convolutional Neural Networks for Heat Flux Model Validation on NSTX-U
[3] The development of a three-dimensional finite element method code for the heat flux analysis of tungsten monoblock divertor on EAST