- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the intrinsic robustness limitations of latent-based watermarking for diffusion models. By connecting DDIM processes with denoisers, the authors analyze invertibility, perturbation invariance, and Lipschitz bounds. They further establish a framework relating image perturbations, watermark detection thresholds, false positive rates, and latent distribution shifts. Experiments on representative watermarking methods are conducted to support the theoretical findings and highlight potential limitations of the current latent-based watermarking paradigm.
Critical strengths
- Valuable research problem and novel analytical perspective.
The paper addresses an important problem by investigating the robustness limitations of latent-based watermarking from the perspective of diffusion generation and inversion processes. This analytical perspective is interesting and potentially valuable for future watermarking research. - The experiments examine how different perturbations, watermark patterns, and detection thresholds affect watermark recovery. These observations provide useful insights and inspiration for improving watermark robustness.
Critical weaknesses
- Strong theoretical assumptions and insufficiently justified proofs.
The core theoretical analysis relies on several strong assumptions, and some derivations are not sufficiently convincing. For example, Theorem 3.2 argues that distinct latent representations remain different after Fourier–Mellin transformations. However, distinct inputs may produce identical representations under invariant transformations. Even under the authors' assumptions, this conclusion requires stronger justification. - Insufficient quantitative validation of theoretical findings.
There is a gap between the theoretical analysis and experimental validation. The experiments primarily rely on qualitative comparisons of distributions and figures, without sufficient quantitative analysis to establish the proposed relationships or validate the predictive value of the theoretical bounds. - Overly broad conclusions regarding latent-based watermarking.
The authors strongly question the viability of latent-based watermarking and advocate post-hoc watermarking as an alternative. However, the analysis does not establish that all latent-based methods are inherently incapable of achieving high robustness. Furthermore, systematic comparisons with post-hoc watermarking methods under unified experimental settings are missing.
Questions for authors
The paper suggests fundamental limitations of latent-based watermarking and recommends post-hoc watermarking as an alternative. Could the authors clarify what theoretical evidence supports this broader conclusion? Could the authors provide comparisons with post-hoc methods under the same attack settings and FPR constraints to support this recommendation?