- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies multimodal end-to-end driving planners that output a fixed number of candidate trajectories but may still suffer from mode collapse or redundant overlap within the candidate set. The proposed AMC-Drive keeps the output cardinality K and inference interface unchanged, and adds training-time regularization: an effective-multimodality calibration loss, a topology-aware realization, and a one-sided cross-mode guard. The experiments on Navsimv1, v2 and Hugsim are given to show its effectiveness.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an interesting and relevant problem, and the proposed direction is plausible. AMC-Drive reaches 93.9 PDMS on NAVSIM v1, and attains 89.2 EPDMS on NAVSIM v2. It can be combined with proposal-, diffusion-, and flow-based planners.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty is moderate. The main novelty is the use of action-conditioned predictive relations as a candidate-level structural regularizer for driving planners.
- Direct evidence for improved effective multimodality is missing. the title asks “How Many Futures Are Enough?”, but the paper does not answer how many futures are enough or how K eff relates to planning performance across budgets.
- The ablation suggests the main gain may come from the frozen JEPA backbone.
- Cross-generator and cross-domain evidence in Table 14 is too thin for the claims.
- The inference FPS should be given and compared.
Questions for authors
- What exactly the real-MTD teacher is? Whether it is available during training in a realistic deployment pipeline?
- The paper does not compare against simple set-diversity regularizers such as DPP, DLow, repulsion, entropy, or coverage losses.
- HUGSIM results contain apparent data-consistency problems.
Response to Reviewer pHRC: Summary and Appreciation
We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing the significance of our research problem and for the constructive and insightful feedback.
In response to your concerns, we have strengthened our work in three main aspects: (1) Practical utility, through candidate-budget comparisons, effective multimodality analysis, and coverage evaluations; (2) Methodological contribution, by disentangling AMC's improvements from the predictive backbone and clarifying the complementary roles of Capacity, Topology, and Guard; and (3) Generalizability, through additional closed-loop evaluations and experiments across different planning architectures and decision-making tasks.
Importantly, our contribution goes beyond improving benchmark scores. We address a distinct and underexplored question in multimodal planning: whether multiple generated trajectories truly represent meaningfully different predictive futures. AMC provides a practical approach to calibrating this structure while preserving the original inference interface. The additional experiments further support the effectiveness and broader relevance of this perspective.
We sincerely appreciate your valuable suggestions, which have helped us strengthen the experimental evidence, clarify our contributions, and better communicate the significance of this work. Thank you again for your time and thoughtful consideration.