- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Motivated by the literature that brain connectome organization and large-scale network structure are related to patterns of neurodegenerative vulnerability, this paper proposes a framework that represents interval-normalized cortical changes from baseline to follow-up pairs in the spherical harmonic (SH) domain. A diffusion score model is trained on these SH coefficients, conditioned on the diagnostic class, to estimate the class-conditional score. With the score model frozen, the Jacobian of the score (i.e., the Hessian of the log-density) is interpreted as a dependency operator among SH modes and used as guidance for the classifier under each diagnostic hypothesis. The model shows strong classification performance compared with other methods across modalities and under cross-cohort and phase-transfer settings.
Critical strengths
-
The idea of representing longitudinal cortical changes in the spherical harmonic domain and modeling the dependencies among these changes is interesting, as this differs from existing approaches.
-
They evaluated the method not only on a single modality but also on three modalities (cortical thickness, FDG-PET, and AV45-PET). The method also achieves strong performance in cross-cohort and phase-transfer settings. This suggests that the method generalizes beyond a single modality or dataset.
Critical weaknesses
-
The first sentence of the abstract raises sparse and irregularly sampled longitudinal data as a challenge, so I read the paper somewhat expecting a way to overcome the limited availability of longitudinal data. However, the method still requires a baseline and follow-up pair for classification, so it cannot be applied to patients with only a single scan, which the authors also note as a limitation. There seems to be a slight mismatch between this motivation and the actual contribution. Framing the paper around the importance of learning the coupling structure among longitudinal cortical changes would provide more insight.
-
Although some ablation results support the role of W, it is still unclear whether the performance gain comes from W itself or simply from using the follow-up information. The zero-change ablation removes the only pathway (W) through which follow-up information reaches the classifier, so the performance drop is somewhat expected. Since W is the core module, comparisons such as using S_f alone or S_f with W (see Requested additional experiments) would help clarify this.
Questions for authors
[Questions]
- In the ablation study, in the “Zero-change guidance” experiment, when you replace S_f with S_b, is the first stage (score network training) trained using both S_f and S_b, and only changed in the second stage?
- Curious about why you select S_b instead of S_f? Because using S_f with W also seems reasonable, as W still carries the change information from the baseline, so combining it with S_f (the more recent state) could provide more information.
- Which time point is the diagnostic label based on (baseline, follow-up, or final diagnosis)?
[Requested additional experiments]
- In “Zero-change guidance”, the classifier input is only S_b, and the guidance carries no change information. There is no follow-up information, although the label may be based on the follow-up. It seems that additional experiments would be helpful: (1) only using S_f instead of S_b at the second stage without guidance, (2) using S_f instead of S_b with W guidance.
- When conducting the classification using only W, how much does it work? I wonder to what extent W actually plays a role.
- In Figure 2, the figure seems to show the result from a randomly selected subject from each group, but how about showing it at the group level (e.g., group-averaged maps)?
[Minor comments]
- In Figure 1, instead of only notating J, W, etc., putting the short name of each module might help understanding.
- Figure 2 is not referenced in the text of Section 4.
[Suggestion]
- It might be interesting to use only S_b to predict or generate the changing information (e.g., SH coefficient c or W).
- Regarding Figure 2, if the data has CN (baseline) -> CN (follow-up), CN -> AD, and AD -> AD, it might be interesting to analyze each of those types or use a t-test for each pair or ANOVA.
5 comments
Author Response to Reviewer kmzb (Part 2/4)
Q1.
As the reviewer correctly pointed out, in the Zero-change guidance experiment, the score network in the first training stage is still trained using the original longitudinal cortical observation pairs . After training, the score network parameters are frozen, and is replaced with only during guidance construction in the second stage.
Specifically, under the Zero-change condition, we set , such that the observed longitudinal cortical change becomes zero. Consequently, the clean deformation coefficients become . However, the spherical OU perturbation used for guidance computation is applied in the same manner as in the original setting, resulting in the score network input . Therefore, this experiment does not remove or modify the trained score network itself, but instead removes only the subject-specific longitudinal change information used to construct the guidance.
The purpose of this experiment is not to directly evaluate the necessity of longitudinal supervision in Stage 1, but rather to examine how downstream classification performance changes depending on whether each subject's actual longitudinal cortical changes are incorporated into the guidance, while keeping the trained score model unchanged.
Recognizing that this distinction was not sufficiently clear in the original manuscript, we clarify this distinction here. We further address the related additional experiments requested by the reviewer in Section R1 below.
Q2.
We intentionally selected the baseline scan as the direct input to the classifier to assign distinct roles to the baseline cortical state and the coupling representation estimated from subsequent longitudinal changes. Specifically, provides the subject's baseline cortical measurements, while the guidance represents the class-conditioned spectral dependency structure estimated from changes observed in the longitudinal pair. Under this design, the proposed model integrates longitudinal information through structural guidance rather than directly using the follow-up scan as a feature input.
Nevertheless, as the reviewer pointed out, incorporating the more recent cortical state together with the guidance is also a reasonable alternative and may provide additional discriminative information. This configuration can be evaluated within the same proposed architecture simply by replacing with , without requiring structural modifications to the model. Accordingly, we conducted the reviewer-suggested -only and experiments to more directly assess the discriminative contribution of the follow-up cortical measurements themselves and the additional contribution of score-derived guidance. The detailed experimental configurations and quantitative results are provided in our response to R1 below.
Q3.
We thank the reviewer for this important question. The baseline–follow-up pairs used in our study correspond to "CN to CN" or "AD to AD", with the same diagnostic label at both observation time points. Therefore, the diagnostic label in our study is not assigned retrospectively from one time point to another, but represents the diagnostic status consistently maintained throughout the observed longitudinal interval.
This setting reflects our objective of learning class-conditional coupling structures from longitudinal cortical changes observed within each diagnostic class, rather than predicting transitions between diagnostic states. Accordingly, we define CN and AD as separate diagnostic conditions and train class-specific score distributions using longitudinal observations in which the corresponding diagnostic status remains unchanged. This study design is motivated by previous neuroscience findings suggesting that longitudinal cortical changes and structural relationships observed within specific clinical diagnostic groups provide meaningful information for understanding the characteristics of neurodegenerative diseases [1, 2].
We also agree that analyzing diagnostic transition groups, as suggested by the reviewer, is an important research direction. Extending the current approach to investigate how spectral coupling structures evolve during transitions between diagnostic states could provide further insights into the progression of neurodegenerative diseases. We discuss this direction further in our response to the Suggestion section below.
[1] Xiao Y, Liao L, Huang K, Yao S, Gao L. Coupling Between Hippocampal Parenchymal Fraction and Cortical Grey Matter Atrophy at Different Stages of Cognitive Decline. Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease. 2023;93(2):791-801.
[2] Carmichael O, McLaren DG, Tommet D, Mungas D, Jones RN. Coevolution of brain structures in amnestic mild cognitive impairment. NeuroImage. 2013;66:449–456.
Author Response to Reviewer kmzb (Part 3/4)
R1.
We additionally conducted the -only and controlled experiments suggested by the reviewer. These experiments were designed to distinguish the discriminative contribution of the follow-up cortical measurements themselves from the additional effect of incorporating score-derived guidance when those measurements are directly provided to the classifier. All experiments were conducted using the same ADNI-CTh data splits, backbone, and training configuration as the main experiments.
The results show that -only achieves an ACC of , an AUC of , and an MCC of . In contrast, achieves an ACC of , an AUC of , and an MCC of , corresponding to improvements of 11.68 percentage points, 12.88 percentage points, and 0.236, respectively.
These results are consistent with the information-matched comparison above: with guidance, either scan as the direct input yields about 91% AUC (: 91.54%, : 90.87%), whereas without guidance even both scans together yield 87.13% (Table 3, “No guidance”).
Furthermore, achieves an AUC of 90.87%, comparable to the 91.54% obtained by the originally proposed configuration. This finding is consistent with the original design rationale of assigning distinct roles to the baseline cortical state and longitudinal coupling, while also suggesting that directly using more recent cortical measurements is a viable alternative.
We have added these experiments in Appendix D.2 (Table 9).
R2.
We conducted the additional -only classification experiment suggested by the reviewer. The purpose of this experiment was to directly examine whether the proposed score-derived guidance operator merely assists cortical feature extraction or can independently represent diagnostically useful information derived from longitudinal cortical changes.
To this end, we performed classification using only the guidance operator estimated from the ScoreNet trained on baseline and follow-up cortical measurements. We employed L2-regularized logistic regression as the classifier, following the same ADNI-CTh data splits and evaluation protocol as in the main experiments.
The W-only classification achieved ACC , AUC , and MCC . These results indicate that the guidance operator contains diagnostic class-related structural information beyond its role in feature mixing, and that such information can be extracted even with a relatively simple linear classifier.
Meanwhile, as reported in the manuscript, the proposed Full Model outperformed W-only classification by 8.98 percentage points in ACC, 9.09 percentage points in AUC, and 0.204 in MCC. For clarity, we summarize the results reported in the manuscript alongside those of the additional experiment in the table below.
| Method | ACC (%) | AUC (%) | MCC |
|---|---|---|---|
| -only (Logistic Regression) | 75.21 ± 4.79 | 82.45 ± 4.00 | 0.465 ± 0.112 |
| Full Model | 84.19 ± 2.10 | 91.54 ± 2.28 | 0.669 ± 0.045 |
These findings suggest that W not only contains discriminative information on its own but also support the effectiveness of the proposed framework's design choice to integrate W into cortical feature extraction.We have added these experiments in Appendix D.2 (Table 9).
R3.
We thank the reviewer for suggesting group-level visualization to assess whether subject-specific coupling patterns exhibit consistent group-level tendencies. Following this suggestion, we aligned each subject’s top-5% spatial coupling participation map to a common FreeSurfer surface template and averaged them within each diagnostic group for CTh and FDG-PET.
As shown in the newly added Figure 4 (Appendix E), CN and AD groups exhibit distinct spatial participation patterns, with relatively higher participation in several posterior and medial cortical regions in the AD group. These regions qualitatively overlap with areas implicated in prior AD studies discussed in the manuscript.
MinorComments.
We thank the reviewer for their careful review and constructive suggestions aimed at improving the readability and clarity of our manuscript.
- Following the reviewer's suggestion, we will revise Figure 1 to include brief module names alongside the existing notations, making the overall pipeline of the proposed model more intuitive and easier to follow.
- We have added the missing reference to Figure 2 at the appropriate location in Section 4.
Author Response to Reviewer kmzb (Part 1/4)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their thoughtful evaluation and constructive feedback. We appreciate the reviewer's recognition of the novelty of modeling dependencies among longitudinal cortical changes in the spherical harmonic domain, as well as the comprehensive evaluation across three neuroimaging modalities and cross-cohort/phase-transfer settings. We address the reviewer's concerns regarding the motivation and the specific contribution of the learned coupling structure through the clarifications and additional analyses below.
W1.
We thank the reviewer for this comment and would like to clarify the role of this motivation. We do not aim to resolve the sparsity of longitudinal data itself. Rather, sparse and irregular sampling is the main constraint under which coupling structure among longitudinal cortical changes must be learned: most subjects contribute only a few scans at irregular intervals, which rules out approaches that require dense or regularly sampled trajectories. Our design follows from this constraint. As stated in Section 1 (lines 44–46), we use the baseline–follow-up pair as the minimal unit of longitudinal supervision, so that subjects with only two valid observations contribute directly and longer trajectories can be decomposed into pairwise transitions, while irregular intervals are handled by normalizing change by ΔT. The motivation therefore explains why we learn coupling from pairs, not a claim that the method removes data sparsity. To state the central motivation explicitly, we have revised the first sentence of the Abstract: “Longitudinal neuroimaging provides direct observations of within-subject disease-related cortical changes, yet learning the structured dependencies among spatially distributed cortical changes remains challenging.” The sampling constraint is retained in the Introduction as the reason for the pairwise design, and the requirement of two scans at inference is stated as a limitation in Section 5.
W2.
We should have stated this more clearly: the “No guidance” model in Table 3 is not an Sb-only model. It receives both Sb and Sf as input channels and therefore has access to the same baseline and follow-up information as the full model. Its AUC is 87.13%, compared with 91.54% when the follow-up information enters through W. A second information-matched control that receives Sb, (Sf−Sb)/ΔT and ΔT directly reaches 85.66% (Appendix D.2). The Zero-change row was intended to show that the guidance depends on each subject’s observed change, not to separate W from follow-up information; the information-matched comparisons above serve that purpose.
To address this distinction more directly, we conduct the Sf-only and Sf+W comparisons suggested by the reviewer in Requested Additional Experiments. These experiments allow us to assess the discriminative value of the follow-up cortical measurements themselves and the additional contribution of integrating them with score-derived guidance. We provide the detailed experimental configurations and results in our response to the corresponding request below.