- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper operates on frozen joint PET–SUVR embeddings, organizes a neural ODE using a clinically generated LLM-teacher disease progression index, and refines its endpoints with conditional residual flow matching. Source state, patient context, and treatment scenarios condition the regional SUVR output. The paper also claims a nonnegative progression-rate link to calendar time, although the central presented inference algorithm requires a supplied target DPI.
Critical strengths
- The shared-dynamics decomposition is interesting. Besides, frozen encoders and patient-level splitting help isolate transition modeling. The explicit distinction between observational treatment conditioning and causal treatment effects is suitable in this case.
- Internal ablations show a meaningful state-prediction signal. Showing the unfavorable cognitive trade-off makes the empirical account more informative than an unqualified claim of improvement .
Critical weaknesses
1.The prediction setup is unclear, especially how the target disease stage is obtained at test time. If it relies on future-visit information, the results do not establish forecasting from current information alone. 2.The advance over existing Neural ODE and generative disease progression models is not convincing. The ablations and baseline comparisons do not clearly establish why each component is needed, and imaging gains do not translate into consistent cognitive prediction gains.
Questions for authors
- How is the target disease stage determined at test time? How does the model perform with only current-visit information and a forecast horizon?
- What does the ODE-plus-residual design add over direct conditional generation under matched conditions?
- Are the main gains consistent across patients and forecast horizons?
2 comments
reply
I thank the reply. However, I still remain concerns about the evidence for the method’s added value and the prediction setup so I remain the initial decision.
Serious Concerns Regarding Review Accuracy, Technical Understanding, and Evaluation Fairness
We respectfully express our concern that several questions raised in this review appear to be based on interpretations that do not accurately reflect the methodology, objectives, and technical contributions presented in our manuscript. The relevant technical details and explanations have already been provided in the paper, making it difficult for us to identify the specific deficiencies or unresolved concerns underlying these questions.
In particular, regarding the three questions concerning (1) target disease stage determination at test time, (2) the contribution of the ODE-plus-residual design over direct conditional generation, and (3) performance consistency across patients and forecast horizons, we find that these questions are not sufficiently connected to the specific methodological formulations and experimental settings described in our work. We have already clarified the corresponding modeling objectives, framework design, and evaluation methodology in the manuscript. We would therefore appreciate more specific references to the aspects that the reviewer considers unclear or insufficiently justified, so that we can provide meaningful technical responses rather than reiterating explanations already presented in the paper.
Furthermore, we notice an apparent inconsistency between the reviewer's second question and their own assessment in the Strengths section. The reviewer has already acknowledged the methodological advantages and contributions of our proposed framework, yet subsequently questions what the ODE-plus-residual design contributes. While we welcome further discussion of its effectiveness, we would appreciate clarification regarding which specific contributions the reviewer considers insufficiently demonstrated, particularly in light of their earlier recognition of the framework's strengths.
More importantly, we are concerned that the review may not fully reflect the actual technical content and intended contributions of our work. We respectfully ask the reviewer to carefully revisit the relevant sections and evaluate our approach based on the methodology and experimental evidence presented, rather than assumptions that may not apply to our framework. Given the importance of a rigorous and informed peer-review process, we believe that the assessment and assigned score should be grounded in a careful and accurate examination of the paper's technical content, modeling objectives, and contributions.
We sincerely hope that the reviewer will reconsider their evaluation and assigned score after reviewing the relevant methodological details and clarifications. We remain open to addressing specific technical concerns and welcome constructive discussion grounded in the actual content of our manuscript.