- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a framework called CoStitch for disentangled color style and stitch texture generation in embroidery image synthesis. CoStitch consists of three key components: an attribute-sensitive block localization method for selecting Color LoRA and Stitch LoRA parameters, a progressive reconstruction strategy using aligned sketch, color design, and embroidery images, and a texture enhancement strategy for refining fine-grained stitch characteristics while preserving color appearance.
Critical strengths
-
This paper addresses the disentanglement of color style and stitch texture in embroidery image synthesis, which is an interesting and practically meaningful problem.
-
The proposed method enables independent control and flexible combination of color styles and stitch textures from different references.
-
The paper is well-written and well-organized.
-
Extensive experiments are conducted to evaluate the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experimental settings are not sufficiently detailed. The paper does not clearly report the number of reference triplets and target patterns used for evaluation. Moreover, Section 3.1 mentions using HED and Wilcom to construct aligned sketch, color design, and embroidery images, but the detailed data preparation process is unclear. More information about the dataset and evaluation protocol should be provided.
-
Some more recent studies from 2026 are neither discussed nor compared in this paper, such as StyleGallery [1], CRAFT-LoRA [2], and StyleExpert [3].
[1] StyleGallery: Training-free and Semantic-aware Personalized Style Transfer from Arbitrary Image References. CVPR 2026.
[2] CRAFT-LoRA: Content-Style Personalization via Rank-Constrained Adaptation and Training-Free Fusion. CVPR 2026.
[3] Mixture of Style Experts for Diverse Image Stylization. CVPR 2026. -
In Section 4.2.2, the authors mention "the reproduced first-stage EmoLoRA result." Does this mean that only the first stage of EmoLoRA is used for comparison? If so, why is the complete EmoLoRA method not considered?
-
Although Figure 6 demonstrates cross-reference generation, the results are only evaluated qualitatively. More quantitative experiments should be conducted to evaluate whether changing the color reference affects stitch texture and vice versa. For example, the authors could fix one attribute while varying the other and measure the resulting changes using color and texture similarity metrics.
-
Some experimental results deserve further discussion. As shown in Table 2, the complete method achieves a lower Silhouette Dice score (0.9593) than all the ablated variants, despite structure preservation being one of the main objectives. Moreover, although the quantitative results are promising, no user study is conducted to evaluate the perceptual quality and realism of the generated embroidery images.
Questions for authors
Please see Weaknesses.
Others:
What is the time efficiency of different methods? Some evaluations regarding this should be conducted.
3 comments
Weaknesses3. Scope of the EmoLoRA Comparison
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for pointing this out.
The original experiments indeed included only the reproduced first-stage results of EmoLoRA. Since the complete training code of EmoLoRA has not been publicly released and its official pretrained weights correspond to only one stitch style, we reproduced its first stage based on the methodology described in the paper and evaluated it on the same 1,200 reference-target combinations to examine its generation performance across different stitch styles.
Additional Quantitative Evaluation. We further evaluated the official EmoLoRA model using its publicly released pretrained weights on the same 40 unseen target sketches, with the six metrics reported in Table 1. The results are presented below:
| Method | Dice ↑ | HFRD ↓ | GLCM-TD ↓ | SIFID ↓ | EMD ↓ | ΔE₀₀ ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Official EmoLoRA | 0.9472 | 0.0214 | 0.1941 | 45.4214 | 59.1532 | 11.7042 |
| CoStitch (Ours) | 0.9662 | 0.0034 | 0.0735 | 14.9552 | 39.0005 | 15.3110 |
CoStitch achieves better Dice, HFRD, GLCM-TD, SIFID, and EMD scores, particularly on stitch-texture-related metrics, while the official EmoLoRA model achieves a lower Palette ΔE₀₀.
Weaknesses4. Quantitative Evaluation of Cross-Reference Control
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestion.
Experimental Setup. We have newly added a quantitative cross-reference experiment using 40 unseen target sketches. Config A fixes the color reference while varying eight stitch-texture references, whereas Config B fixes the stitch-texture reference while varying eight color references. For each sketch, we generate eight embroidery images and report the mean and standard deviation of pairwise metric differences across reference combinations.
| Metric | Config A | Config B |
|---|---|---|
| Palette EMD ↓ | 13.2916 ± 1.3497 | 63.4266 ± 6.0085 |
| Palette ΔE₀₀ ↓ | 4.8900 ± 0.6055 | 21.2639 ± 2.3952 |
| HFRD ↓ | 0.006149 ± 0.001499 | 0.001183 ± 0.000360 |
| GLCM-TD ↓ | 0.085504 ± 0.019543 | 0.039867 ± 0.012628 |
| SIFID ↓ | 10.6759 ± 1.9477 | 9.2045 ± 2.7367 |
Results Analysis. Under Config A, the relatively low Palette EMD and Palette ΔE₀₀ indicate that varying stitch-texture references has a limited effect on color distribution. Under Config B, the relatively low HFRD and GLCM-TD indicate that varying color references has a limited effect on stitch-texture characteristics. These results support CoStitch's ability to control the two attributes independently.
Weaknesses5. Structural Metric Degradation and User Study
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestions.
Structural Consistency Evaluation. To further evaluate boundary consistency between generated and target images, we have newly added the Boundary F1 (BF1) metric and evaluated 1,200 generated embroidery images using consistent mask extraction and distance tolerances of 1, 2, and 4 pixels. The results are presented below:
| Metric | 1 px | 2 px | 4 px |
|---|---|---|---|
| BF1 ↑ | 0.3253 | 0.5688 | 0.8278 |
BF1 increases from 0.3253 to 0.8278 as the tolerance increases from 1 to 4 pixels, indicating that the generated images exhibit local boundary deviations but achieve relatively high boundary consistency when small spatial deviations are allowed. This observation is consistent with the potential influence of fine-grained stitches on local contours.
User Study. We have newly conducted a perceptual evaluation involving 20 participants without professional embroidery experience. The evaluation pool contains 50 real embroidery images and 50 CoStitch-generated images. Each participant randomly selected 15 real and 15 generated images and rated their overall visual quality and perceived embroidery realism on a five-point scale. The results are presented below:
| Image Type | Visual Quality ↑ | Embroidery Realism ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| Real Embroidery | 4.35 | 4.17 |
| CoStitch (Ours) | 4.32 | 4.15 |
CoStitch achieves average scores of 4.32 for visual quality and 4.15 for embroidery realism, approaching the corresponding scores of real embroidery images (4.35 and 4.17). These findings provide additional perceptual evidence supporting the visual quality and realism of CoStitch-generated embroidery images.
Q. Time Efficiency Comparison
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestion.
Training Efficiency Evaluation. We have newly added a comparison of training times for personalization-based methods on an NVIDIA L20 GPU. The results are presented below:
| Method | Training Time |
|---|---|
| B-LoRA | 35 min |
| DB-LoRA | 37 min |
| PairCustomization | 26 min |
| Ours | 45 min |
CoStitch requires slightly more training time than the compared methods due to its successive reconstruction and stitch-texture enhancement procedures.
Thanks for the authors' rebuttal. I will maintain my original score.
Weaknesses1. Experimental Scale and Reference Triplet Construction
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestion.
Evaluation Protocol. Following the experimental settings of existing methods [1–3], we use 30 reference triplets and 40 unseen target sketches, resulting in 1,200 evaluation combinations. The original experimental data scales of the compared methods and the evaluation setting of CoStitch are summarized below:
Each reference triplet is used for independent personalization training. All methods are evaluated on the same 1,200 reference-target combinations, and the six evaluation metrics are averaged over all 1,200 test results.
Data Preparation. Following practical industrial embroidery sampling workflows, we use Wilcom, which is employed in industrial embroidery digitization, to generate color design images Id and their corresponding embroidery images Ie. We then apply an edge detection method [4] to extract sketches Is from the embroidery images. Through data cleaning and filtering, we ensure that the triplets are structurally aligned and that the color design and embroidery images maintain consistent dominant colors.
References
[1] Y. Frenkel et al. Implicit Style-Content Separation Using B-LoRA. In Proceedings of the European Conference on Computer Vision (ECCV), 2024.
[2] J. Chung et al. Style Injection in Diffusion: A Training-free Approach for Adapting Large-scale Diffusion Models for Style Transfer. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 2024.
[3] J. Ma et al. One-shot Embroidery Customization via Contrastive LoRA Modulation. ACM Transactions on Graphics, 44(6), Article 272, 2025.
[4] S. Xie and Z. Tu. Holistically-Nested Edge Detection. In Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV), 2015.
Weaknesses2. Comparison with Recent Related Work
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestion.
Quantitative Comparison. To extend our comparison with recent studies [5–7], we have added a quantitative evaluation of StyleGallery [5] under the same evaluation protocol. The results are presented below:
CoStitch outperforms StyleGallery on five of the six metrics, achieving lower HFRD, GLCM-TD, and SIFID for stitch-texture similarity, as well as lower Palette ΔE₀₀ and EMD for color consistency. Although StyleGallery achieves a slightly higher Silhouette Dice, CoStitch demonstrates stronger overall performance in stitch-texture and color matching.
Technical Comparison. We compare these methods in terms of their learning objectives and core technical mechanisms. The corresponding discussions have also been added to the Related Work section.
References
[5] B. He, Y. Ye, C. Liu, W. Wu, F. Liu, and Z. Cai. StyleGallery: Training-free and Semantic-aware Personalized Style Transfer from Arbitrary Image References. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), pp. 29092–29102, 2026.
[6] Y. Li, Y. Cai, and C. Zhang. CRAFT-LoRA: Content-Style Personalization via Rank-Constrained Adaptation and Training-Free Fusion. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.18936, 2026.
[7] S. Zhu, Z. Ouyang, Y. Kang, Q. Wang, M. Zhou, B. Li, M.-M. Cheng, and Q. Hou. Mixture of Style Experts for Diverse Image Stylization. arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.16649, 2026.