- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper seems to consider changing the OT ground cost to improve the regularity while assessing how much the underlying geometry is affected. Unfortunately I could not get the paper's idea beyond this point since I was unable to decipher the paper.
Critical strengths
I was not able to assess the strengths of this paper due to apparently unclear writing (at least to me).
Critical weaknesses
This paper is extremely hard to understand with many concepts and notions undefined. I believe this is not due to my lack of expertises but rather the fundamental issue existing in the submission. The following points are what tripped me up.
- L036: What is Ma-Trudinger-Wang condition? While it may be introduced later, readers cannot continue to read if we do not even have its informal interpretation.
- L039: What is log-cosh? What is A3w? The A3w condition seems to be a rather known set of regularity conditions in Riemannian OT, which cannot be assumed standard for ML audiences in ICLR.
- L040: What is the minimum repair price? The "repair" and "price" are used repeatedly without a solid description, which complicates the concept of this paper.
- L041: What is the curvature obstruction?
- L049: What is ? While this is defined later in Section 3 and rather a minor issue, please do not use math symbols out of nowhere.
- L049: Ditto; what is ?
- Figure 1: While the figure seems to illustrate "the critical repair" (mentioned in the caption), I really do not have idea what corresponds to it in the figure. Also, what corresponds to the transport plan in this figure? How much do (a)-(c) differ with each other?
- L117: is not defined.
- L117: The sectional curvature is rather a standard notion in Riemannian geometry, and skipping its definition might be okay depending on the audience, but we should describe it in front of the ML audiences. I believe a very few proportion of the audiences are sufficiently familiar with it.
- L118: What is cut locus?
- L120: It is unclear what it means by "profiles with an even extension."
- L127: What is the Lee-Li convention?
- L129: Is this the definition of MTW? Or an implication of the Lee-Li convention?
- L131: Please explain briefly. Should be instead? Also, can we always ensure the invertibility of ?
- L132: I think this is the first place where A3w (and A3s) is introduced formally. We should emphasize that this is the definition of A3w.
- L157: What is the purpose of this design problem? Why do we need to minimize the fidelity? What is the meaning of the constraint on ? And what does mean at the first place?
- L163: What are and ?
- L181: Again, the notion "repair" has not been defined yet.
Let me stop here. Some are minor and fixable, but others are really significant to understand the paper.
Questions for authors
See "Critical Weaknesses"
Response to Reviewer v3Qc
Thank you for identifying the points at which the original presentation becomes difficult for readers unfamiliar with MTW regularity. We agree that the research question and key definitions should be introduced before the technical machinery. We have substantially rewritten the Introduction, Figure 1 explanation, and Setup (revised pp. 1–3), and added an actual-source allocation visualization in Appendix K.
Clarification of the central problem.
In hyperbolic optimal transport, the ground cost determines which assignments are preferred. Squared geodesic distance is a natural choice, but it fails the weak MTW condition relevant to transport-map regularity. Replacing this ground cost can remove that geometric obstruction while changing optimal assignments and increasing numerical sensitivity.
Our central question is: What is the smallest unavoidable distortion of squared distance required to satisfy MTW regularity, and what numerical sensitivity accompanies this modification?
This concerns modifying the ground cost, not entropic regularization of the coupling. We do not claim unconditional map regularity or downstream accuracy improvements.
Point-by-point revisions addressing the review:
L036, L039–L041, L181 (MTW, A3w/A3s, log-cosh, repair, price, and curvature obstruction): Revised p. 1 introduces these concepts informally before the technical results and clarifies their relevance to the transport task.
L049 (normalization and distance-range notation): Revised pp. 1 and 3 define ℓ′′(0)=1, the distance variable r, the hard distance cap D, and the distortion measure Δ.
Figure 1 (interpretation of panels and transport plans): Revised p. 2 explains the three cost settings and the discrete dual-potential cells. The new Figure K.1 separately illustrates actual finite source-point allocations. Neither figure is presented as evidence of smooth Monge-map regularity.
L117–L120 (hyperbolic geometry, cut locus, and even extension): Revised p. 3 introduces Hκd, sectional curvature, the absence of a cut locus, and the meaning of an even C4 extension.
L127–L132 (MTW definition, Lee–Li convention, and c-exponential invertibility): Revised p. 3 explicitly distinguishes the MTW definition from its sign and scale convention, introduces A3w/A3s, and specifies that the c-exponential is inverted on its natural momentum image, not necessarily the entire cotangent space.
L157–L163 (design objective, margin constraints, and coefficients): Revised p. 3 explains why worst-case cost distortion is minimized, distinguishes the transverse margin Λ from the full margin Γ, and defines α,β,γ,δ before the directional analysis.
The revised presentation now follows a clearer sequence: original transport task → MTW obstruction → ground-cost repair → fidelity objective → numerical sensitivity → formal definitions.
We also distinguish the solved zero-full-margin problem from the open positive-full-margin problem and explicitly retain the limitations concerning continuous-map regularity and downstream performance.
We appreciate the reviewer's detailed feedback and hope these concrete revisions make the mathematical contributions and their assumptions clearer and easier to assess.