- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies entropic balanced and unbalanced optimal transport on the 2-sphere, where the Gibbs kernel of the squared geodesic distance is replaced by the heat kernel at time ε/4, as in the convolutional OT framework of Solomon et al. (2015). The theoretical contributions are twofold. First, Theorem 3.1 shows that, on any compact connected Riemannian manifold, the entropic OT problem with the heat-kernel-induced cost converges to the unregularized OT problem with squared geodesic cost as ε → 0, in both the balanced and unbalanced settings. Second, Proposition 3.2 establishes that the associated Sinkhorn divergence on S² (and more generally on compact symmetric spaces) is symmetric, positive definite, convex in each argument, and metrizes weak convergence. Algorithmically, the authors observe that the heat kernel is radial and acts diagonally in the spherical harmonic basis. Each kernel application in the Sinkhorn iterations therefore reduces to a forward spherical harmonic transform, a multiplication by , and an inverse transform. The resulting method, SHOT, requires O(n) memory and O(n^{3/2}) time per iteration and runs on GPU. Validation consists of runtime benchmarks on random synthetic measures, using the Clenshaw–Curtis and HEALPix grids, against kernel-matrix Sinkhorn, a Cholesky-based convolutional solver, exact W₂, and two sliced methods (SSW and LSSOT). It also includes a comparison between heat and matrix convolutions in the appendix. Finally, an application compares the 2000–2014 seasonal precipitation climatologies of eight CMIP6 models with ERA5 on a HEALPix grid with . The authors report model rankings under balanced and unbalanced divergences, regional bias indices derived from the gradient of the divergence, and an analysis of Arctic winter biases near the sea-ice edge.
Critical strengths
-
Theorem 3.1 gives a rigorous justification for replacing the Gibbs kernel with the heat kernel in Sinkhorn iterations, a substitution that has been used heuristically since Solomon et al. (2015). The result covers the unbalanced case and does not follow directly from standard entropic OT convergence results, because the cost itself depends on ε. Together with Proposition 3.2, it also settles a real theoretical problem: the Gibbs kernel of the squared geodesic distance is not positive definite on the sphere, so the standard Sinkhorn divergence guarantees do not apply to it. The heat-kernel formulation restores them. This is the main reason I view the paper as a meaningful contribution.
-
The algorithm is simple and practical. By applying the heat kernel as a diagonal filter in the spherical harmonic basis, SHOT avoids forming any kernel matrix, uses linear memory, and relies only on dense, parallel operations. Figure 1 shows that it scales to about 523,000 grid points, while kernel-matrix and Cholesky-based solvers run out of memory at moderate resolutions. Since the output is a differentiable divergence, the method could be useful well beyond the climate application presented here.
Critical weaknesses
The accuracy of the method at practical values of ε is not assessed. Theorem 3.1 is an asymptotic statement without a rate, and Appendix C.4 shows that the algorithm becomes unstable when ε is small relative to the spherical harmonic bandwidth, since the truncated heat kernel takes negative values. The only quantitative accuracy check (Appendix D.2) compares single convolutions after rescaling, not the resulting transport costs or divergences. As a result, it is unclear how closely the divergence computed at ε = 0.01 in the climate study reflects the squared-geodesic OT problem that motivates the work. This matters because the scalability argument depends on SHOT being a faithful substitute for standard Sinkhorn, and that has not been shown.
The climate application does not establish that the proposed metric is more informative than existing alternatives, and SHOT is only used as a post-hoc evaluation tool. The study includes no baselines (RMSE, pattern correlation, balanced OT metrics, sliced spherical OT, or the spherical convolutional Wasserstein distance of Garrett et al. (2024)). It also provides no external evidence that the unbalanced ranking, which differs substantially from the balanced one, is the more faithful assessment. Several conclusions, such as links to sea-ice parameterization complexity and the need for changes to convection schemes, are not supported by the analysis. Although the authors motivate SHOT as a differentiable, geometry-aware objective, it is never used for learning, and there is no test of whether it predicts out-of-sample skill. Since the climate study is the main evidence of practical value, these gaps substantially weaken the empirical contribution.
Questions for authors
Clarifications:
- At ε = 0.01, how close is SHOT’s Sinkhorn divergence to the exact W₂ cost and to standard Sinkhorn with the geodesic Gibbs kernel? A comparison on grids where all methods fit in memory, across a range of ε, would address my main concern. Do the model rankings change if the exact or Gibbs-kernel divergence is used instead?
- Can a convergence rate be given for Theorem 3.1, or at least an empirical characterization of the gap as a function of ε and the bandwidth L?
- How do the model rankings compare with RMSE, pattern correlation, balanced OT, and Garrett et al. (2024)? Is there any external evidence, for example from established assessments of these CMIP6 models, that the unbalanced ranking is more reliable?
- Are the values in Figure 3 normalized in the same way as those in Figure 13? From Figure 13, the Arctic DJF−JJA difference appears to be around 0.3 to 0.4 rather than 0.06 to 0.09. Also, why are the regions described as non-overlapping when the ITCZ lies inside the Tropics?
- On the HEALPix grid used in the climate study, SHOT is slower than several baselines. What is its runtime if the data are regridded to the Clenshaw–Curtis grid, and how many Sinkhorn iterations does each method require?
Suggestions:
- The paper motivates SHOT as a differentiable objective, but its usefulness for building better predictive models is not demonstrated. One direct test would be to use it as a training loss for a spherical forecasting model, such as an SFNO trained on ERA5 precipitation. The model could be evaluated on held-out years with independent metrics (power spectra, Fractions Skill Score, extreme-precipitation statistics) and compared with MSE and spectral losses. A less expensive test, using the CMIP6 data already collected, would be a perfect-model experiment. Each model would be treated in turn as pseudo-truth, the others weighted by their historical divergence, and the weighted projections checked against the pseudo-truth’s future period, comparing SHOT-based weights with RMSE-based weights. Either experiment would show whether the metric captures aspects of model quality that matter for prediction.
- Please show a plain difference map alongside the OT gradient map, to support the claim that the gradient localizes displacement errors that a difference map cannot.
2 comments
Runtime after regridding (C5).
We took the 16 divergences of the climate study (each of the 8 models against ERA5, in DJF and JJA) and computed each one twice with SHOT: once on the HEALPix grid (, 12,288 points), and once after moving both fields to the Clenshaw–Curtis grid with about the same number of points (, 12,403 points) by using an area-weighted average over the HEALPix pixels overlapping each Clenshaw–Curtis cell, rescaled in a way to keep the total mass. Settings: , (unbalanced) or (balanced) and with threshold checked every 10 iterations for the convergence and at most 1000 iterations in total. Times are for one transport problem (model vs ERA5) on a Tesla V100 GPU with medians over the 16 pairs.
| grid | iterations | time (s) | time / iteration (ms) | relative difference due to regridding | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| balanced | HEALPix | 596 | 5.4 | 9.1 | – |
| CC (regridded) | 596 | 1.0 | 1.6 | 0.6% | |
| unbalanced | HEALPix | 481 | 4.2 | 8.7 | – |
| CC (regridded) | 476 | 0.8 | 1.8 | 0.2% |
SHOT needs almost the same number of iterations on both grids, so the gain comes entirely from the cost of one iteration: as discussed in Section 4.1, this reflects the maturity of the two spherical harmonic transform libraries: torch-harmonics, used on the Clenshaw–Curtis grid, provides optimized CUDA kernels while s2fft, used on HEALPix, does not yet. Regridding takes roughly 1 ms and only slightly changes the divergences values.
Differentiable objective (S1).
We agree that the paper in the current state does not showcase SHOT as a training objective and it is left for future work (Sections 4.2 and 5). Both experiments the reviewer suggest are what we could do next, but each is a study of its own: training a spherical neural operator on ERA5 precipitation with SHOT and comparing it with MSE and spectral losses on held-out years requires a full training and evaluation pipeline, and the perfect-model test requires future-scenario runs for all 8 models. Neither of those experiments could be done within the discussion period. As a first step, in the resubmitted version of the paper, Appendix D.4 shows SHOT used as a differentiable loss: interpolations between measures on obtained only by gradient descent through the SHOT divergence, which move mass along great circles, whereas the interpolation fades one configuration into the other. This simple example stands as an empirical validation of the gradients SHOT produced, and to some extent validates it can be used in a learning pipeline.
Gradient maps vs. difference maps (S2).
We added this comparison in the revised version (Section 4.2.3 and Appendix E): Figure 12 shows the plain difference map next to the SHOT gradient maps, and Table 5 gives, for each (model, season, ) the correlation between the gradient and the difference map, raw or smoothed with the heat kernel.
We thank the reviewer for all the comments that hopefully helped us improve the clarity of our paper and the scope of the experimental results.
Climate models comparison.
Comparison with other methods (C1&C3)
We added this comparison in Section 4.2.2 of the revised version. We rank the 8 models with SHOT and with the absolute global-mean bias, RMSE, pattern correlation, RMSE after smoothing both fields with the same heat kernel as SHOT and the original spherical sliced Wasserstein distance (SSW). The balanced version of SHOT agrees with SSW (Spearman correlation 0.98 in DJF, 0.62 in JJA) and only weakly with RMSE and pattern correlation (0.48 in DJF, −0.17 in JJA) which is consistent with the double penalty of pointwise scores on displaced features. The unbalanced divergence moves between two known regimes as τ varies: for large τ its ranking matches the ranking by global-mean bias and for small τ that of the smoothed RMSE. Large rank changes between the balanced and unbalanced divergences therefore reflect global-mean biases.
Garrett et al. (2024) compare, at each location, the distribution of daily values over time with one-dimensional OT. Their metric needs daily time series and cannot be computed on the seasonal climatologies we use. It also answers a different question (the distribution of values at each point, rather than the spatial pattern), so we see it as complementary.
We have no external evidence that the unbalanced ranking is more reliable, and we do not claim it: ERA5 is itself an imperfect reference, and the balanced and unbalanced divergences answer different questions that are selected by τ. What we can show is what each metric responds to. In a new experiment (Appendix E.4), we add errors of known type and size to ERA5: a shift of the tropical rain band, a global or tropical scaling of the intensity, and a blur. When the band is shifted, the balanced divergence grows as the square of the shift, while RMSE grows more and more slowly once the shifted band stops overlapping its original position (double penalty). Balanced SHOT, SSW, LSSOT and pattern correlation are exactly blind to a global scaling, and the unbalanced divergence puts displacement errors on its transport part and intensity.
Comparison with "classical" Sinkhorn.
Rate of convergence (C2).
Yes, in the balanced case. We added it to the revised version (Remark 3.3, with the proof in Appendix A.2). For probability measures P,Q on S2 and 0<ε<1 we have ∣OTCε,ε(P,Q)−W22(P,Q)∣≤23εlog(1/ε)+O(ε). The proof combines two results from the literature: the sharp two-sided estimates of the spherical heat kernel of Nowak, Sjögren and Szarek (2019) and the convergence rate of entropic optimal transport for Lipschitz costs on compact manifolds of Carlier, Pegon and Tamanini (2023).
This result gives an order in ε, not a numerical bound: the constants of the heat kernel estimates are not explicit and as Theorem 3.1, it concerns the exact heat kernel and not its degree-L truncation. For this reason, the accuracy at the values of ε and L used in practice is measured empirically, in the comparison described below.
Small scale comparison (C1).
We added this comparison in Appendix D.3 of the revised version (Table 2): we compared SHOT against a dense log-domain Sinkhorn solver of Eq. (2) with the Gibbs kernel e−d2/ε on the same grid, on 10 pairs of random measures (Clenshaw–Curtis L=96 and HEALPix Nside=32), balanced and unbalanced (τ=100), for ε∈{0.01,0.1,1,10}. For ε≤0.1, which covers the settings of our experiments, the two solvers agree closely: the relative differences of the divergence values and of their gradients are below 1%. The difference grows for larger ε because the heat kernel Hε/4 moves away from the Gibbs kernel, not because of the solver. Table 2 also reports the gap of both divergences to the exact (unregularized) W22: it is the same for SHOT and for the dense solver, so it comes from the entropic regularization and not from SHOT.