- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper formulates historical character restoration as predicting missing SVG tokens while retaining observed paths. It introduces VECodex, with 2.23 million source samples and 35.7 million simulated restoration instances, and Script, combining raster evidence, partial SVG context, and background inpainting. Experiments report substantial character and masked-region improvements, with ablations for raster evidence and composition order.
Critical strengths
-
The representation directly addresses preservation of surviving geometry. Table 2's masked-region IoU improvement from 56.39% to 80.13% shows that the advantage goes beyond retaining undamaged strokes. This is a promising formulation for controlled character restoration.
-
The aligned dataset is substantial, and all degradation variants of a source remain in one split. The matched SVG-only ablation also shows a useful cross-modal effect: raster evidence helps most under water stains, where faint stroke information survives.
Critical weaknesses
-
The evaluated inputs assume clean surviving geometry. Section 3.2 constructs observed SVGs by splitting the undamaged source, while Section 4 assumes those paths are available at inference. No damaged-input vectorization or noisy-path evaluation establishes how much performance survives the intended scan-to-restoration pipeline. This limits practical applicability without invalidating the vector-conditioned task.
-
The source of the gains is incompletely isolated. Table 2 does not explain how raster baselines were adapted to VECodex or their training budgets. Table 3 establishes the value of adding raster evidence, but not of observed SVG context relative to a matched backbone. Consequently, the gains cannot yet be attributed specifically to the proposed representation rather than backbone and training differences.
Questions for authors
How are observed paths obtained from an actual damaged scan, and what happens when these extracted paths replace the source-derived inputs?
Were Table 2 baselines trained on the same split? A matched SVG predictor without observed SVG context would be a particularly useful additional control.
2 comments
Dear Reviewer 2Fi9,
I hope this message finds you well. With less than 22 hours remaining in the discussion period, we wanted to check whether our response has addressed your concerns. If you have any further questions or feedback, please let us know. We value your perspective and would be happy to clarify any remaining points.
Thank you for taking the time to review our paper.
Response to Reviewer 2Fi9
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. We evaluated SVGs extracted from damaged scans and added controls for training conditions and observed SVG context.
✅ Please find rebuttal figures HERE.
(1) Observed Path Extraction. At inference, observed paths are extracted from the damaged image I~ and the damage mask M. The multi-agent pipeline of Sec. 3.1 first determines whether HAT×4 super-resolution is needed. It then extracts and cleans the character foreground, removes foreground inside M, and vectorizes the remainder with Potrace. No undamaged image or complete source SVG is used in this extraction process.
(2) Performance with Extracted Paths. We replaced the source-derived observed paths with extracted paths and evaluated the same SCRIPT checkpoint on 1,600 test instances (400 per damage type), without retraining.
Table R1. Source-derived vs. extracted observed paths.
These limited reductions indicate that SCRIPT retains most of its restoration performance with paths extracted from damaged inputs. Qualitative comparisons are provided (Fig. R1, HERE).
We also re-extracted the paths and re-ran the complete pipeline with masks dilated, eroded, or shifted by 4 pixels. Mask IoU remains between 74.49% and 76.22% under these perturbations (Table R5). Case studies on naturally damaged manuscripts further evaluate the complete pipeline under real-world conditions (Fig. R2, HERE).
In the original submission, all baselines in Table 2 used publicly available pretrained checkpoints without additional fine-tuning on VECodex. For a matched comparison, we have now fine-tuned the strongest baseline, LaMa, on the same VECodex training split and adopted a unified evaluation protocol using the same foreground extraction and Potrace pipeline. SCRIPT still outperforms fine-tuned LaMa by 19.62 percentage points in Mask IoU (80.13% vs. 60.51%, Table R2). On the 1,600 test instances with matched input information, SCRIPT achieves 79.56% Mask IoU, compared with 61.75% for LaMa (Table R3).
Matched SVG predictor without observed SVG context. As suggested, we trained two models that differ only in whether the observed SVG is given as input. Both use the same backbone (Qwen3.5-9B + LoRA), the same 20,000 training instances and the training settings of the paper (LoRA rank 16, learning rate 2×10⁻⁴, eight gradient-accumulation steps, 3 epochs), and both predict the missing paths. They are evaluated on the 1,600 instances of Table R1.
Table R8. Matched backbone, data and budget, with and without observed SVG context.
With the backbone, training data and budget held fixed, removing the observed SVG context reduces Mask IoU from 64.88% to 19.45% and Mask B-F1 from 64.12% to 17.12%. Without the observed paths, the model has to place new paths in absolute coordinates from visual features alone, and its strokes rarely align with the surviving ones. Even a much larger MLLM without any fine-tuning, when given the observed SVG (Qwen3.8-Max, 34.86%, Table R3; Fig. R4, HERE), outperforms this trained model without it. The gain therefore comes from the observed SVG context, not from the backbone or the training budget. Both 20,000-instance models score below the full SCRIPT (79.56%, Table R1), which shows in addition that training on the full VECodex matters.
We hope these controls address the concerns and would appreciate reconsideration of the rating.