- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ABD-TDA, a framework that combines ViT features with topological features for histopathological cancer classification. The ViT branch uses the pretrained google/vit-base-patch16-224 model to extract a 768-dimensional representation. In parallel, the TDA branch computes Betti-0 and Betti-1 curves from the six RGB and HSV channels, resulting in a 1,200-dimensional topological descriptor, which is subsequently reduced to 64 dimensions using an MLP. The two representations are concatenated and passed to an MLP classifier. The proposed fusion improves classification performance over the ViT-only baseline on both ICIAR2018 and UT-Osteosarcoma datasets.
Critical strengths
- The paper is easy to follow, and the components used in the paper is simple and easy to understand.
- The ablation study is useful because it separately evaluates the TDA-only, ViT-only, and fused models. The fused representation consistently improves over the ViT-only baseline on both datasets and across multiple metrics.
Critical weaknesses
-
The motivation for introducing TDA is not clear. The paper argues that TDA provide complementary information about tissue organization but it does not clearly explain which biologically or diagnostically meaningful structures in these two cancer-classification tasks are expected to be captured by these quantities. Additionally, the arguement that histopathology contains “structural information” is too generic.
-
The paper uses the ImageNet-pretrained google/vit-base-patch16-224 as its visual encoder. However, the paper itself discusses recent pathology-specific foundation models such as UNI, CONCH, and Virchow, which are pretrained on large-scale histopathology data and are specifically designed to provide transferable pathology representations. Given the availability of these considerably more relevant backbones, the choice of a generic ViT-Base requires justification.
-
The paper title suggests the model as attention-based, while the only attention mechanism in ABD-TDA appears to be the standard multi-head self-attention already present in the pretrained ViT backbone.
-
Table 2 is confusing because different methods use different train test splits. If the reported numbers are taken directly from prior papers, then several methods are evaluated using different train/test splits and potentially different test sets. In that case, the reported accuracies are not directly comparable
-
The methodological novelty appears limited. The proposed framework combines existing components. While the empirical combination may be useful, it is unclear whether the technical contribution is sufficiently substantial for ICLR
Questions for authors
-
What histopathological structures do the Betti-0 and Betti-1 features correspond to in these datasets? Can the authors provide qualitative examples showing how differences in the Betti curves relate to diagnostically meaningful tissue morphology?
-
Why were Betti features extracted independently from RGB and HSV intensity channels? Is there evidence that the topology of these individual color channels reflects meaningful tissue organization rather than primarily stain/intensity variation?
-
Why was google/vit-base-patch16-224 selected as the visual backbone?