- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces CLUE, a computationally efficient approximation for propagating parameter uncertainty to per-vertex positional variances in 3D morphable models. Using the law of total variance and a first-order treatment of skeletal rotations, CLUE combines shape, expression, and pose uncertainty without explicit Jacobian computation or repeated mesh sampling. The method also enables vertex- and joint-space likelihood objectives for probabilistic human mesh recovery. Validation includes comparisons with Monte Carlo sampling and Jacobian-based propagation on FLAME, SMPL-X, and MHR, alongside reconstruction results on 3DPW, pseudo-ground-truth evaluations on seven datasets, and training-loss ablations. The reported results demonstrate substantial computational savings and improved reconstruction accuracy under the evaluated settings.
Critical strengths
Substantial computational savings for spatially localized uncertainty estimation. CLUE exploits the structure of 3D morphable models to estimate per-vertex variances without repeated mesh sampling or explicit Jacobian computation. On FLAME, the reported runtime is 3.4 ms, compared with 226.4 ms for Jacobian-based propagation, while additional memory decreases from 410.4 MB to 4.3 MB. This efficiency makes localized uncertainty estimation more practical for resource-constrained applications and constitutes a meaningful contribution. Demonstrated benefits of geometry-aware probabilistic supervision. Beyond uncertainty visualization, CLUE enables vertex- and joint-space likelihood objectives that improve reconstruction under the same training protocol. On 3DPW, it reduces MPJPE/PVE from 58.9/69.6 mm with parameter-space NLL to 56.2/66.1 mm. Training-loss ablations further support the contribution of the geometric objectives, providing evidence that the method offers practical value beyond accelerating uncertainty propagation.
Critical weaknesses
Limited validation of uncertainty accuracy and calibration. The statistical evaluation relies primarily on visual error maps, without a clear characterization of approximation error across parameter-variance magnitudes and pose configurations. Moreover, uncertainty evaluation on seven datasets uses SAM 3D Body predictions as pseudo-ground truth, measuring agreement with a reference model rather than directly establishing calibration against true geometry. Although the 3DPW results support improved reconstruction accuracy, stronger independent uncertainty evaluation is needed to substantiate the proposed downstream uses.
Questions for authors
Clarification of approximation accuracy. What parameter means and variance ranges were used in the statistical experiments? How does the error relative to the 10,000-sample reference vary with uncertainty magnitude and pose configuration, particularly when the small-rotation and fixed-joint-location approximations become less accurate? Evidence for uncertainty calibration. Do you have calibration results against independent 3D ground truth, such as empirical coverage of predicted confidence intervals? Since the seven-dataset uncertainty evaluation uses SAM 3D Body pseudo-ground truth, please clarify what evidence distinguishes calibrated uncertainty about true reconstruction error from uncertainty that primarily reflects disagreement with the reference model.
Response to Reviewer a6bh
Dear Reviewer a6bh, we thank you for your review! Please find our responses below.
Q1. "Clarification of approximation accuracy…"
A1. Thank you for this suggestion. We now include a study of a sweep over the parameter variance and the MAE between the ground truth (10,000 MC samples) and estimates. This study is in Fig. 8, and tabulated in Table 6. The study is also referred to in the main paper at Lines 366–371. We set the pose randomly by setting parameters in {0,+0.3,−0.3}. For each non-zero parameter, we consider its variance as a part of a sweep. The sweep goes from 0 input standard deviation to 0.25 radians collectively for all parameter variances.
The key takeaway is that CLUE tracks first-order error propagation closely while having pragmatic assumptions. The plots also highlight a general limitation with first-order propagation, which overestimates the output variance as the input variance increases. As a result, at larger rotation, shape, or expression variances, CLUE and first-order error propagation are inaccurate. However, the overestimation of output variance can be absorbed by the learnt parameter variances during training.
Q2. "Evidence for uncertainty calibration"
A2. We now also report AUSE on 3DPW and EMDB, which have ground truth SMPL meshes. AUSE compares whether the predicted uncertainty and the ground truth errors rank samples in the dataset in the same way. We note that CLUE has the lowest AUSE across both datasets. We use AUSE as a measure of uncertainty because while SAM 3D Body predicts MHR meshes, the ground truth of 3DPW and EMDB is in SMPL format. Mapping the uncertainty from MHR to SMPL is not trivial.
In general, using SAM 3D Body as the pseudo-ground truth for out-of-distribution data meant that both the ground truth mesh and the predicted mesh are in the same space of MHR.