- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Geometry uncertainty of defining PDE domain is consdiered in this submission. Some metjhodology to propogate this uncertainty from one image / scan is provided and some empirical evaluation is provided.
Critical strengths
This work addresses a challenging problem - uncertainty in domain geometry and its proposagtion. Methodology is provided and empirical evaluation is given.
Critical weaknesses
The work does not address the issue of what the impact of neglecting this uncertainty actually happens to be - is it a primary cource or secondary source - this remains unanswered as far as i could tell. There is no theoretical analysis provided which for such a rpoblem and for the classes of problem considered would have been valuable - consider early work of Nobile and collaborators. the area of Stoichastic Geometry would have been useful to consider for this work.
Questions for authors
I have no questions for the authors
2 comments
response
thank you for responding to the comments made at present it is difficult to move from current score given strength of response effect to contribution.
geometric vs discretisation error, theory, and stochastic geometry
We thank the reviewer for the review and for the pointers to the work of Nobile and collaborators and to stochastic geometry. We address the three points in turn. The new experiments use the paper's setting (32 modes plus K = 10 discrepancy modes).
Is geometric uncertainty a primary or a secondary source of error?
In our setting it is the primary source, and we now quantify this. With scan noise of 1% of the shape's radius, the geometric uncertainty of the PDE solution is 0.5% at the centre and 3.0–4.4% next to the boundary, so the boundary noise is amplified where boundary-driven quantities are evaluated. This is 10–150 times the discretisation error of the solver we use:
(Discretisation error estimated as the difference between our level-8 solution and a level-10 solution on the true shape.)
Neglecting the geometric uncertainty therefore means reporting the QoI with the dominant error source omitted. A deterministic reconstruction gives a single value with no interval. Our posterior gives an interval that contains the true solution at all 16 probes for every shape (§4.4). On a nonlinear problem, the Bratu equation −Δu = λeᵘ near its fold, the relative geometric uncertainty roughly doubles (to about 1.0% at the centre), so the effect grows when the solution is sensitive to the domain.
Theoretical analysis
We agree that the paper should engage with this theory more closely, and the revision will do so. Our linear propagation is the first-order perturbation approach that Harbrecht, Schneider & Schwab (2008) analyse for the moments of solutions of elliptic problems on randomly perturbed domains. Castrillón-Candás, Nobile & Tempone (2016) prove analytic regularity of such solutions with respect to the parameters of a random domain deformation; this regularity is what makes the QoI smooth in our mode coefficients, and it underlies both our linear approximation and the Monte Carlo or collocation alternatives. We cite both papers, but only in passing; the revision connects our method to them explicitly.
What our setting adds to this framework is the origin of the random domain. In these works the distribution of the deformation is prescribed. In ours it is inferred from a single scan through a trained network, and Appendix A supplies the link the theory needs: an implicit-function bound from last-layer perturbations to boundary displacement, with a remainder quadratic in the perturbation. The revision adds a short proposition bounding the error of the linear law in terms of the second derivative of the QoI with respect to the coefficients and the posterior covariance.
Our experiments behave as this theory predicts. When we inflate the posterior covariance by s², the linear variance stays within 8% of Monte Carlo up to s = 4, while the mean shift relative to the standard deviation grows roughly in proportion to s (0.02–0.21 at s = 1, 0.39–0.56 at s = 4, 1.05–1.44 at s = 16): a bias that is second order in the perturbation, measured against a standard deviation that is first order.
Stochastic geometry
Stochastic geometry studies random sets and random shapes with distributions specified a priori, for example through random closed sets or random field models of a boundary (Chiu et al., 2013). Our posterior is such a random domain, but one conditioned on data: it is supported on a low-dimensional family of shapes derived from one trained network and weighted by the measurement model of a scan. The revision will place our construction in this context, and will note that prior models from stochastic geometry could replace our Gaussian prior on the mode coefficients.
Changes in the revision