- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes EFiMAS, a multi-agent system for EEG–fNIRS fusion. Since the relationship between the two modalities is not fully understood and can vary across tasks, especially in terms of temporal and spatial patterns, the authors aim to build task-specific fusion pipelines. The system uses four agents for planning, verification, execution, and review. It also uses RAG to retrieve neuroscience and methodological evidence, which helps the agents propose fusion hypotheses, select appropriate operations, and refine the pipelines based on execution results. Experiments on ten EEG–fNIRS tasks show that EFiMAS achieves competitive performance and outperforms several baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses an important problem, as EEG and fNIRS have different temporal and spatial characteristics and may require different fusion strategies across tasks.
-
The overall framework is reasonably well designed and clearly presented, with enough implementation details to understand how the system works.
-
The experiments cover ten EEG–fNIRS tasks, and the results show good performance against several baselines, with additional ablation studies to support the findings.
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty is not very clear. Most of the system follows a fairly standard RAG and multi-agent workflow, with limited design specifically for EEG–fNIRS fusion beyond the domain knowledge and tools.
-
The paper is easy to follow and has a very long appendix with lots of implementation details, but some key questions about the proposed method and its actual contributions are still not well addressed.
Questions for authors
-
The T/E/H/S relations seem to be one of the main EEG–fNIRS-specific designs, but it is not clear how much they actually affect the generated pipelines. Are they used to guide the search, or mostly just as knowledge for the agents?
-
There are several ablation studies, but a budget-matched comparison with a single agent seems to be missing. Would a single agent with the same RAG, tools, and budget achieve similar results?
-
The paper argues that fixed fusion models are not flexible enough, but could task-conditioned Transformers or MoE models also handle different fusion strategies across tasks? There does not seem to be a comparison with these approaches.
-
The system relies heavily on existing scientific knowledge for hypothesis generation and verification, which seems to favor exploitation over exploration. Could this limit the agents' ability to discover new or unexpected cross-modal relationships?
-
The Planner proposes hypotheses and falsifiers, but it is not very clear how these are actually tested. Also, could some of the performance gains simply come from having more attempts and execution steps?