- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an inference-time trajectory correction method for structure-preserving manga image editing, which aims to adapt pretrained image editing models to manga images without additional training or architectural modifications. The authors point out that existing pretrained image editing models often struggle to preserve the original image structure during local editing due to the domain gap between natural images and manga images. Motivated by this observation, the proposed method aims to preserve the global composition of the input image while allowing the model to perform the intended local edits by correcting the early stages of the generation trajectory. Specifically, the authors leverage empty-prompt velocity predictions to construct an input-specific reconstruction target and interpolate the current latent state toward this target, while retaining the edit-prompt velocity for the subsequent sampling update. The authors further provide a mathematical analysis to explain why empty-prompt-based correction can preserve the editing response more effectively than edit-prompt-based correction. Experiments on manga text removal and screentone synthesis demonstrate improvements in structure preservation across different pretrained image editing models, with relatively low computational overhead.
Critical strengths
- In terms of empirical performance, the proposed method achieves the best or highly competitive results on most evaluation metrics, demonstrating its effectiveness in preserving image structure while performing the intended edits. The consistent improvements across two pretrained image editing models further support the practical value of the approach.
- The proposed method is simple, intuitive, and easy to understand and implement, requiring no additional training or architectural modifications. Moreover, Section 4.2, Why the Empty Prompt Helps, provides a clear mathematical explanation of the key design choice. In particular, it shows why using the empty-prompt velocity to construct the correction target avoids explicitly weakening the editing response, making the proposed approach more convincing and well-motivated.
Critical weaknesses
- Table 1 shows that the pretrained model achieves a low PSNR of 11.84 dB under empty-prompt reconstruction, whereas the proposed method improves it to 22.27 dB. Given that the correction relies on empty-prompt velocity predictions from the same model, it remains unclear how these predictions enable such a substantial improvement despite the poor initial reconstruction performance. Further analysis of the correction's effect on the generation trajectory would help clarify this result.
- In Table 2, the proposed method and several competing approaches, including FlowChef and FlowEdit, are evaluated using different model backbones. Although the authors explain that these methods are not directly compatible with instruction-based image editing models, the backbone differences make it difficult to attribute the observed performance gaps solely to the proposed method. A more controlled comparison would strengthen the experimental evidence.
Questions for authors
- Table 1 shows a substantial gap between the baseline (11.84 dB) and the proposed method (22.27 dB) under empty-prompt reconstruction. The authors should provide further experiments to explain how the proposed correction achieves such a large improvement despite the poor reconstruction quality of the original empty-prompt model. In particular, analyzing the reconstruction error and trajectory behavior before and after correction would help clarify the role and reliability of the empty-prompt velocity.
- The authors should conduct additional comparisons using the same model backbone whenever technically feasible. This would help isolate the contribution of the proposed trajectory correction from differences in model architectures and pretrained capabilities, providing stronger evidence of its effectiveness relative to existing methods.
5 comments
Thank you for the response. The additional experiments address my main concerns. However, the method appears sensitive to the choice of hyperparameters. Therefore, I will maintain my rating of 3.
Response to Reviewer x5jU (follow-up)
Thank you for confirming that the additional experiments address your main concerns. We would like to clarify the remaining point on hyperparameter sensitivity, because the results in the paper show that the proposed method does not require tuning.
A single fixed setting, not tuned on test data
All the main results of the paper use the same setting, correcting the first M = 3 sampling steps with strength α = 0.01, which we did not tune on any test set and applied unchanged to the newer backbone FLUX.2 32B. With this one setting, the proposed correction improves all five text-removal metrics over the baseline for Qwen Image Edit 2509, FLUX.1 Kontext, and FLUX.2 32B (Table 2). It also improves all nine metrics of document highlighter removal (Supp. D). More generally, the paper uses this same setting for every task, without per-task tuning (Supp. B.3).
Not sensitive within a practical range
The supplementary material has included a hyperparameter study since the submission (Supp. B.3, Table 5), and it shows that the method is not sensitive to its hyperparameters within a practical range. Specifically, on Qwen Image Edit 2509, every tested value of M from 1 to 7 and of α from 0.01 to 0.05 improves all five text-removal metrics over the baseline, so no careful tuning is needed. Table 5 also lists settings that we deliberately chose far outside this range, such as α = 0.001 and α = 0.1, which are one tenth and ten times the default. They are not candidate operating points. Instead, we include them to illustrate under-correction (too weak to correct the trajectory) and over-correction (the output stays too close to the input and text remains), which explains the role of each hyperparameter. The metrics that degrade in these rows therefore reflect these intentionally extreme choices and do not indicate sensitivity within the practical range.
The fixed setting is enough in practice
In the comparison of training-free methods on the same backbone, Qwen Image Edit 2509 (the table in our first response and Table 2), ours with this fixed setting is the only training-free method that improves all five metrics over the baseline. In contrast, each of the other methods, at its default setting, falls below the baseline in at least one metric. Beyond this, the α = 0.03 row of our first response (Supp. Table 5) shows that the strength of the correction leaves room for further gains. These gains are optional. In general, the strength that gives the best balance between keeping the input and applying the edit naturally depends on the task, as for any method that balances the two. However, the key point is that the proposed method already improves over the baseline with its single fixed setting (e.g., in text removal and document highlighter removal above), and all the main results in the paper use this setting.
We hope this clarifies that the method works with one fixed setting across these models and tasks without careful tuning, and that adjusting its strength is an option for further gains rather than a requirement. If any question or concern remains, we would be glad to respond during the remaining discussion period.
[Comment 1 of 1] Title: Response to Reviewer x5jU
Thank you for the helpful comments. In short: (Q1) a trajectory analysis shows that each early corrected step reduces the gap between the model's predicted clean image and the input, which explains the gain from 11.84 dB to 22.27 dB; (Q2) on the same image editing model as ours, our method is the only training-free method that improves all five metrics. Details follow, with pointers to the revised paper.
Q1: Why does reconstruction improve from 11.84 dB to 22.27 dB?
Notation: at each sampling step, Z_t is the current latent, X_in is the input image (in latent space), u is the velocity predicted with the empty prompt, and Δ is the remaining time to the end of sampling, so Ẑ = Z_t + Δu is the clean image that the model currently predicts. Our correction target (Eq. 5) can be rewritten as Z* = Z_t + (X_in − Ẑ). The target therefore shifts the current latent by the gap between the input and this prediction, so that following u from the target would end exactly at the input. In other words, the content of the target comes from the input, and u is used only to convert the input image into the corresponding state at the current noise level. At every corrected step, we do not replace the current latent with this target but move it only a fraction α = 0.01 toward the target (Eq. 6). Each corrected step thus reduces the gap between the prediction and the input. The baseline in Table 1 instead follows the model's velocity without such a correction and drifts away from the input, which is consistent with its 11.84 dB.
We verified this by tracking the sampling trajectories of 100 test images with Qwen Image Edit 2509 under the empty prompt, measuring at every step the residual between the predicted clean image and the input, ‖Ẑ − X_in‖/‖X_in‖ (Sec. 5.4, Fig. 3):
Q2: Comparison on the same backbone
FlowChef and FlowEdit were designed for text-to-image models, which is why the submission ran them on FLUX.1 [dev] and Qwen Image 2512 rather than on an instruction-based image editing model. For a controlled comparison, we adapted both to run on the same image editing model as ours, Qwen Image Edit 2509 (denoted "edit mode" in the revised paper), and added GRAG (CVPR 2026 Findings), a training-free method designed for instruction-based image editing models (Table 2, Supp. B.5). All methods use the baseline's instruction ("Remove text. Keep everything else unchanged."), classifier-free guidance scale, number of steps, and random seed, and each method uses its default setting.
The Text columns are computed inside the ground-truth text mask. With α = 0.01, which we fix for all backbones and tasks, ours is the only method that improves all five metrics over the baseline. The other methods raise the full-image scores mainly by keeping more of the input, including the text that should be removed. GRAG thus obtains higher full-image scores than ours but fails to remove much of the text. Its text-region PSNR (17.97) is even lower than that of the baseline (19.07), whereas ours raises it to 20.04. FlowChef in edit mode also falls below the baseline in text-region PSNR, and FlowEdit in edit mode leaves most of the image, text included, unchanged, which explains its high SSIM. For reference, our hyperparameter study (Supp. Table 5) shows that α = 0.03 further improves all five metrics on this backbone and exceeds GRAG on all of them (last row).
(The baseline LPIPS in Table 2 has been corrected from 7.16 to 7.92; see the general response.)
We hope these responses address your concerns. If anything remains unclear, we would welcome further discussion.