- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
MomWorld proposes a latent world model for temporally consistent, long-horizon autonomous driving. It jointly propagates scene states and a history-conditioned momentum variable through gated updates. The resulting future memory supports candidate trajectory scoring and selection. A flow-matching module then refines the selected trajectory through bounded, horizon-aware residual prediction. The paper reports improvements on nuScenes, NAVSIM and Bench2Drive.
Critical strengths
- The paper's approach of combining historical dynamics with future scene prediction is a reasonable direction for improving planning consistency.
- The future representations are used in both trajectory selection and refinement, giving them a clear role in the planning pipeline. It aslo includes several component ablations and reports the latency of different refinement settings.
Critical weaknesses
- The motivation for the proposed modules could be better supported. The momentum variable appears similar to a learned recurrent hidden state, and its physical interpretation is not clear to me. Flow matching is a valid way to refine the deterministically selected trajectory. However, if the refinement process is also deterministic, it is unclear what benefit flow matching offers over a simpler residual regressor. A direct comparison would help clarify this choice.
- The ablations show that these modules help, but without comparisons to simpler temporal and refinement models, I find it not eay to assess the benefit of the proposed design.
Questions for authors
- The role of the momentum variable is not fully clear to me. Is the momentum given a physical definition? Have you compared the momentum dynamics with a GRU or another recurrent model of similar capacity, using the same inputs and supervision?
- How does MoFlow compare with a simply residual regression model using the same conditioning and residual fusion?
- Could you clarify the individual contributions of FWM, LWR, and SMD? The cumulative ablation shows gains as modules are added, but it is unclear how much each contributes and how their interactions affect the results.
- Is GuideFlow's result with a scorer comparable under your NAVHARD evaluation protocol?
- Could you point to the Bench2Drive results and appendix, and clarify how the six-second nuScenes baseline results were obtained?
2 comments
How MomWorld Uses the Predicted Scene Trend for Planning
Thank you for recognizing that the comparison with the matched GRU supports our structured state update. We would like to clarify one point: why this design matters for planning. During training, MomWorld uses differences between successive future scene representations to supervise a latent variable that captures the trend in scene evolution. At inference, the model uses its predicted trend to advance the scene state step by step. The resulting rollout serves both to select a candidate trajectory and to refine the selected trajectory. The matched GRU receives the same supervision and is integrated into the same planning pipeline, but its scene state at a given step need not be updated using the trend predicted at that step. Our design requires the model not only to predict how the scene will change, but also to use that prediction to construct the future scene representations on which planning relies.
Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments. The matched GRU comparison supports the structured state update, though I still view its methodological novelty as limited. For MoFlow, the gains over no refinement are modest, and the comparisons do not yet clearly distinguish the benefit of flow matching from iterative refinement more generally. While these designs have merit, their contributions and demonstrated benefits are not sufficient to change my overall assessment. I therefore will maintain my original score.