- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies a quantitative MRI acquisition problem in which MR signal is measured at several different echo times (TEs). The signal decreases as TE increases, and this decay can subsequently be used to estimate the quantitative biomarkers. The proposed method keeps one source image acquired under a short repetition-time (TR) setting for each flip angle and predicts the corresponding set of multiple target images under a long-TR setting.
The model has two main components. First, an Endpoint-Conditioned Trajectory Network maps acquisition parameters (\alpha, TR, TE) and a continuous TE-related coordinate to a latent vector that modulates spatial features (by an image encoder) extracted from the source image. Second, a Physics-Constrained Decoder predicts a non-negative reference amplitude and a positive TE-dependent decay rate, and generates the target signal through exponential integration.
The method is evaluated on a private healthy-brain MULTIPLEX (MRx) dataset with 32 training and 10 evaluation subjects. The experiments include comparisons with existing MRI synthesis methods, several component ablations, prediction of acquired TE coordinates, off-grid TE querying within the target range, and downstream T2 (biomarker) estimation from the synthesized images.
Critical strengths
-
The paper introduces a clean structural constraint that is directly relevant to downstream quantitative estimation by design. The positive-rate decoder guarantees non-negative and monotonically decreasing signal trajectories over TE by construction. I find this interesting since the unconstrained decoder in ablation achieves similar image-level fidelity but worse downstream T2 quantification.
-
The experimental analysis is in-depth and relevant on a under-discovered problem. Quantitative MRI often requires parametric fitting, which combines information across multiple images. This requires more dedicated evaluation protocols. The acquired-TE hold-out experiments are well-designed completely excluded from image supervision while remaining available for final evaluation. The comparisons make the contribution of individual components relatively transparent and controllable.
Critical weaknesses
- The necessity of the proposed Endpoint-Conditioned Trajectory Network is not yet justified well. For subjects under the same protocol, the manuscript states that the latent path (conditioned on acquisition parameters) is shared, while the image encoder part takes all spatial information. The path is therefore mainly conditioned on the endpoints which are fixed within each FA group. This, somehow can degenerate the trajectory to a channelwise modulation on specific acquisition settings. It is then unclear why this requires the proposed endpoint-conditioned trajectory construction rather than a simpler continuous conditioning mechanism, such as FiLM or direct TE-conditioned feature modulation.
The Pointwise MLP ablation partially addresses this issue, but it changes the parameterization of acquisition conditioning and the use of endpoint representations as well. Therefore, it does not isolate whether the trajectory construction itself is responsible for the gain of performance.
This concern is closely related to the scope of the continuous-representation claim. The main experiments vary TE while keeping the acquisition protocol highly constrained. The manuscript explicitly notes that the held-out experiments do not evaluate unseen flip angles, TRs, or endpoint descriptors which should be of interest as well. The fully off-grid inferences are interesting, but still inside the target TE interval. I therefore think that the current evidence more clearly supports continuous in-range TE interpolation/resampling for a fixed acquisition setting than a general continuous acquisition-space representation where extrapolation is expected.
- The Physics-Constrained Decoder guarantees positivity and monotonic signal decay over TE by predicting a positive TE-dependent rate. However, an otherwise flexible positive rate can represent a broad class of monotonically decreasing signals. The manuscript itself explicitly states that is not a uniquely recovered tissue parameter, that a common relaxation parameter across flip angles is not enforced, and that cross-TR amplitude changes are learned from paired images. I therefore interpret this component mainly as a physics-motivated monotonic signal prior. The manuscript also acknowledges that a single source echo does not (and should not) uniquely determine an individual decay curve. For quantitative MRI, this raises the question of whether genuine subject-specific quantitative variation is preserved or whether the model primarily imputes cohort-level tissue statistics.
Questions for authors
Based on the weakeness, I would like to ask several questions that might help
-
Could the authors better isolate the contribution of the Endpoint-Conditioned Trajectory Network from generic continuous feature conditioning? That could be, how would the method compare with a FiLM or direct TE-conditioned modulation baseline that retains the same source encoder and other setups? Since the endpoint descriptors are fixed within each flip-angle group in the current experiments, evidence that the proposed trajectory construction itself provides a benefit would substantially strengthen the representation-learning contribution.
-
Can the authors provide more direct evidence that subject-specific quantitative variation is preserved than mainly inferred from cohort-level tissue priors? For example, within a fixed anatomical region, an across-subject correlation/ICC between T2 star estimated from acquired and synthesized echoes would be informative.
-
For the off-grid TE set, how exactly was the computed? Eq 20 uses a stride-two TE separation of 10.18 ms, which corresponds to the original grid, whereas the stride-two separation for the off-grid set is 8 ms. Was the factor in the expression changed accordingly for the off-grid experiment? Also, how is the repeatability of the the mapping when generating more images off grid?
-
Does the methodology works on other public datasets with quantitative mapping such as T1 mapping or on other organs? Since in this stage we can only infer from a private dataset on Brain MRI.
5 comments
2. Across-subject quantitative agreement within fixed tissue regions
Following your suggestion, we computed GM/WM tissue means separately for the ten test subjects, using the same fixed support, independent of predictions, for all methods and the acquired reference within each subject. Pearson and absolute-agreement are reported below, with 95% CIs obtained by paired-subject bootstrap.
| Tissue | Pearson (95% CI) | (95% CI) | Predicted/reference SD ratio | Regression slope |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GM | 0.654 (0.070–0.956) | 0.534 (0.035–0.828) | 0.673 | 0.440 |
| WM | 0.734 (0.502–0.941) | 0.596 (0.298–0.803) | 0.479 | 0.352 |
Within-tissue association and absolute agreement support partial preservation of tissue-mean variation among healthy subjects. Relative to tissue constants determined from the 32 training subjects, GM/WM MAE decreases from 2.306/1.566 to 1.409/0.989 ms, with paired-improvement CIs of GM and WM ms. Compared with four external learning-based baselines, our method achieves the best point estimates for tissue-mean MAE, Pearson , and ICC. Complete tissue-mean, calibration, and per-subject results are provided in Table 2 of the main text, Tables 16–19 in Appendix D.3, and Figure 9.
Slopes and SD ratios below 1 also quantify the remaining compression of variation under the current input budget. Within-tissue error, absolute agreement, and the magnitude of variation together provide a more direct evaluation than pooled correlation, as well as clear criteria for assessing the contribution of additional measurements in future multi-input configurations. Our conclusions here concern tissue means in healthy test subjects.
Your interpretation of the decoder as a physics-inspired monotonic signal prior accurately characterizes its constraints. The positive rate represents the negative local log-signal slope of the synthesized signal, ensuring nonnegative, monotonically decaying signals within each FA; a shared is an assumption of downstream joint fitting. Its quantitative contribution is tested directly through the Unconstrained Decoder control: at similar image quality, the paired improvement in joint MAE is 0.454 ms (95% CI: 0.237–0.675), with improvement in 9/10 subjects. The separate cross-FA evaluation is reported in Appendix D.5.
3. The actual separation used for off-grid fitting
The off-grid experiment uses the actual stride-two separation of 8 ms. Eq. 24 in Appendix C gives the expression for equally spaced echoes used in fitting:
Each term is computed from valid positive-signal pairs, with a default stride of . The acquired grid corresponds to , while the off-grid set ms corresponds to . Integration starts at the 3.86 ms anchor, and off-grid parameter fitting uses the five queried echoes, excluding this integration anchor. This experiment yields MAE ms and map .
4. Fitting stability with more query points
Following your suggestion to generate more images, we queried the same model at 5, 9, 17, and 33 equally spaced points over 5–21 ms, fitting with the actual stride-two separation for each grid. All results use the same acquired-reference support.
| Number of query points | Stride-two separation (ms) | MAE (ms) |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | 8 | 14.201 |
| 9 | 4 | 14.209 |
| 17 | 2 | 14.196 |
| 33 | 1 | 14.187 |
The maximum difference in mean reference MAE across densities is approximately 0.023 ms. Direct comparison of the fitted maps gives a mean absolute difference of ms between 5 and 33 points, and ms between 17 and 33 points. These results support query stability for the same model under the tested interval, integration, and fitting rules; details are provided in Tables 12–13 in Appendix B.5.
The original five-point off-grid result uses a 213-node integration trajectory, whereas the density experiment uses the integration anchor plus query nodes, giving respective five-point MAEs of 14.24 and 14.201 ms. The appendix distinguishes these two numerical settings. The density experiment changes both integration nodes and observations used for fitting; a check that changes only the integration grid at common TEs is reported in Table 11 in B.4. This analysis evaluates query and fitting sensitivity: additional synthesized points do not add independent measurement information, and scan–rescan reliability requires evaluation with independent acquisitions.
5. The scope of continuous representation and the terminal hold-out
The interior hold-out at 14.04 ms evaluates interpolation within the range; the terminal hold-out at 24.22 ms uses image supervision only up to 19.13 ms and is evaluated against the excluded acquired target images. The latter tests prediction beyond the image-supervised TE range under a known protocol. At the terminal echo, the Full Model improves PSNR over TE-Conditioned MLP by 0.603/0.397 dB for the two FAs, respectively, with joint MAE of 14.275 vs. 15.134 ms (Tables 8 and 10).
The numerical endpoint descriptors remain known; the current TE experiments support continuous querying within a fixed acquisition configuration, while direct transfer to unseen FAs, TRs, or endpoints has not been tested. The off-grid experiment evaluates parameter-map agreement after resampling, while the curves in Figure 5 beyond the acquisition endpoint demonstrate structural continuation. Their evaluation objectives are clarified in the main text and appendix.
6. Public data, mapping, and other organs
We added a public MPM experiment, splitting 108 healthy participants by subject into 78 for training, 15 for validation, and 15 for testing. The data contain eight echoes each for PDw (FA$6^\circ$) and T1w (FA$21^\circ$), both with TR of 25 ms. The Full Model, CCR, and D2Diff were all retrained on this dataset, retaining the first echo in each group and completing the remaining seven; the reference is obtained by jointly fitting the complete acquired echo trains from both groups.
| Method | PDw PSNR (dB) | T1w PSNR (dB) | Joint MAE (ms) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full Model | |||
| CCR | |||
| D2Diff |
Image PSNR is computed only over the seven generated echoes in each group, and quantitative error uses the acquired-reference support shared by all methods. The Full Model achieves the highest mean PSNR and lowest mean quantitative error under another public brain-imaging protocol, supporting the framework's use in different echo-completion settings after retraining. Results and image comparisons are provided in Table 23 and Figure 10 in Appendix E.
Parameter-map evaluation in both sets of experiments focuses on . Exploratory fitting of acquired MULTIPLEX echoes has not yet yielded reliable validation, so we do not report conclusions on mapping in this revision; experiments on other organs have not yet been conducted either. The public-data experiment extends evaluation to another brain cohort and protocol, providing an empirical basis for future task extensions.
Thank you for recognizing the explicit decay structure and the design of the hold-out experiments. Following your suggestions, we have added direct TE-conditioning and FiLM controls, across-subject agreement within fixed tissue regions, analyses of the actual off-grid separation and query density, and evaluation on public data. These additional results directly support the empirical benefits of the conditioning mechanism and individual predictive value at the level of tissue means in healthy subjects.
1. The contribution of endpoint conditioning relative to simpler continuous conditioning mechanisms
Within the same protocol and FA, the acquisition-conditioned path is shared across subjects, while encoded source-image features provide subject-specific spatial information. To directly address your proposed comparison, we added the following controls, retaining the source-encoder architecture, positive-rate decoder, training budget, and final-checkpoint rule, and training each model separately:
The Full Model achieves lower mean joint T2∗ MAE in all three settings, as well as higher PSNR for both FAs. TE-MLP directly compares endpoint inputs with coordinate conditioning, while FiLM compares modulation forms under the same endpoint inputs. These additional results support the benefits of our endpoint-conditioned parameterization and multiplicative modulation relative to the alternative implementations tested; full implementation details and results are provided in Table 3 of the main text and Table 8 in Appendix B.1.
Here, trajectory refers to a conditioning function indexed by endpoints and a continuous coordinate. The shared path represents protocol-dependent TE variation, subject-specific information enters through source-image features, and positive-rate integration further couples outputs at different TEs into a single signal curve. This division of roles allows additional acquired inputs and continuous queries to be designed separately: a multi-input extension can fuse complementary observations at the encoder while continuing to use continuous conditioning and positive-rate integration to generate echoes. The current experiments directly compare the benefits of the conditioning mechanisms under a common single-source input budget.