- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Edit-GRPO, a region-aware RL framework for instruction-guided image editing that separates editing and preservation regions using masks and applies different rewards and GRPO optimization signals to each region. Experiments on FLUX.1-Kontext and Qwen-Image-Edit show improved background preservation while maintaining well editing performance.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is well-written and the motivation is clear. Also, the proposed method directly targets the identified problem of the conflict between editing and background preservation. The overall design is intuitive and reasonable.
-
It has relatively complete experiments on the two popular image-editing backbones, FLUX and Qwen. The ablation studies are also meaningful, including the comparison between semantic-only, preservation-only, combined, and decoupled optimization, which helps demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed design.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty. The proposed method is essentially a straightforward extension of existing GRPO-based optimization by introducing region masks and applying separate rewards to editing and preservation regions. While the motivation is reasonable, I find the technical contribution limited, insufficient to support a standalone contribution to image editing.
-
Although the experiments are relatively comprehensive, I found several presentation flaws. First, Tables 1 and 2 include three additional baselines without clearly explaining why they were selected. All their locality preservation metrics are missing. Second, while Figure 4 provides qualitative comparisons, I believe the visual improvements are quite minor. I am not fully convinced that the improvements are good enough to justify the proposed method.
Questions for authors
-
One of the main motivations of this paper is that global optimization can lead to poor locality preservation in image editing. But the current visual examples are insufficient to establish how common or significant this problem actually is (Fig 1 doesn't provide any useful information, and Fig 2 only show a single example). Can the authors provide a more rigorous analysis of why global GRPO causes this interference? For example, analysis of the optimization signals or gradient behavior in editing and non-editing regions would help establish whether the claimed conflict actually exists and how the proposed method addresses it.
-
The proposed method shares similar motivations and design ideas with recent region-aware RL methods such as RC-GRPO-Editing and SpatialFlow-GRPO. Can the authors clarify what are the unique advantages of the proposed region-decoupled optimization strategy, beyond applying different rewards and advantages to different spatial regions?
-
Tables 1 and 2 include InstructPix2Pix, OmniGen, and UniWorld-V1, but their locality preservation metrics are entirely missing. Can the authors clarify where these scores come from, why these particular baselines were selected, and why their preservation metrics were not evaluated?
Thank you for clarifying the intended contribution. I do not find the designation of RC-GRPO-Editing and SpatialFlow-GRPO as “concurrent works” sufficient to explain their absence from the submitted manuscript. They were publicly available in April and June 2026, respectively, while this manuscript was submitted in late September. This does not call into question independent development, but it provided time to discuss both works and position Edit-GRPO against them. The absence of official code may make a faithful numerical reproduction difficult; it does not remove the need for a precise technical comparison.
My main concern is the comparison with SpatialFlow-GRPO. The rebuttal distinguishes Edit-GRPO by stating that it decouples optimization at both the advantage estimation and policy objective stages. However, SpatialFlow-GRPO also computes region-level advantages and uses region-aggregated policy ratios and a region-aligned loss. Considering that SpatialFlow-GRPO already uses region-level advantages and a region-aligned policy objective, the claimed “region-decoupled policy optimization” therefore closely overlaps with existing work.
While the rebuttal clarifies several details, it does not resolve my central concern about the method’s distinction from existing region-aware policy optimization. I therefore maintain my original score.