- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This submission proposes a framework of joint region localization and dense correspondence recovery for partial-to-complete non-rigid shapes. Its key design is an intrinsic neural field that parameterizes a Hamiltonian potential, coupled with reciprocal refinement in which the localized operator guides correspondence estimation and reliable matches update the operator. Through evaluations on regarding benchmarks and ablations of the operator and refinement components, the paper demonstrates competitive localization and correspondence accuracy.
Critical strengths
-
The submission is overall well-written, I liked the visualization.
-
The methodology design is natural and indeed performs well under certain conditions.
Critical weaknesses
- My biggest concern lies on the setting -- Selecting 25 anchor points from farthest-point sampling is indeed seems to be a very strong assumption. More concretely, to the best of my knowledge, this size of landmarks is often used in works on precise maps, e.g., [a, b], where the matching accuracy is more demanding. Furthermore, when considering the partial shape matching, the FPS scheme would benefit more as it can reach the boundary points on the partial shape, while the corresponding anchors on the full shapes might lie on smooth region where feature is weak (thus they are hard to identify by automatic methods).
Considering the above, I would expect something more than superior performance on regular benchmarks.
- From the technical novelty, my feeling is that most of the tools have been explored in the existing methods. The strong assumption also makes it difficult to isolate the technical contribution.
[a] Lifted Bijections for Low Distortion Surface Mappings [b] Surface Maps via Adaptive Triangulations
Questions for authors
- A comprehensive study on the relationship between supervision strength and the final performance could be useful.