acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

DUNE:Keeping Derived Memories Consistent with Changing Facts

Abstract

Research on long-term memory for agents increasingly studies how to replace an obsolete fact with its updated value. However, this overlooks a deeper problem, that is, updating a single stored fact can invalidate downstream conclusions, answers, or plans derived from it, even when their revised values are never explicitly stated. Drawing an analogy to materialized views and incremental view maintenance in databases, we define such downstream conclusions as derived memories. Derived memory maintenance requires revising the source evidence and any downstream derived memories whose validity or value depends on it. Based on this, we introduce DRM-Bench, a collection of 3,200 two-session scenarios for evaluating derived memory maintenance across semantic, episodic, and procedural memory. To address this problem, we propose DUNE (Derived memory Updating through Networked Evidence), which maps evidence to nodes and dependencies to edges, then propagates source updates over the resulting graph. DUNE achieves the best source update (84.8%), and derived update (73.6%) among the tested methods on DRM-Bench, and improves averaged F1, LLM Judge, SourceUpdate accuracy, and DerivedUpdate accuracy by 9.6, 14.8, 22.2, and 22.5 points, respectively.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
agent memory, update, derived data, memory benchmarks

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_9k6jOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies derived memory maintenance, where updating a source fact may invalidate previously stored conclusions or plans even when their revised values are not explicitly provided. It introduces DRM-bench, comprising 3,200 two-session scenarios across semantic, episodic, and procedural memory, with model-generated answers written back into memory before subsequent updates. DUNE constructs a proposition graph with similarity, contradiction, derivation, and revision relations, and separately estimates validity and currentness to suppress stale memories during retrieval. Experiments report improved average source-update and derived-update accuracy over the evaluated retrieval and memory baselines.

Critical strengths
  • The paper identifies a useful distinction between updating source facts and maintaining their derived consequences. DRM-bench explicitly stores earlier model-generated answers and evaluates both source and derived questions after an update, making stale-answer reuse visible.

  • DUNE achieves the highest average derived-update accuracy among the evaluated methods, exceeding the strongest baseline by 12.2 percentage points. The component ablations further support the usefulness of dependency tracking and update propagation for maintaining derived memories.

Critical weaknesses
  • The graph construction component (Section 4.1) is insufficiently evaluated. How accurately are proposition nodes and dependency edges extracted, particularly for implicit dependencies? An error analysis and controlled perturbations of missing or incorrect edges would help assess how graph construction errors affect downstream updates.
  • The benefit of DUNE’s separate validity and currentness scores remains unclear. Could the authors add ablations using a single activity score and simple dependency-based invalidation, while keeping the extracted graph fixed? The existing ablations do not isolate the contribution of this two-score formulation and its optimization.
  • The accuracy–cost trade-off under the main experimental setting remains unclear. Accuracy is evaluated with Qwen-Flash, whereas the cost study uses Claude Haiku 4.5. Could the authors report costs under the main setting so that the performance gains and computational overhead can be assessed together?
Questions for authors

Please refer to Weaknesses.

3 comments

Thanks for your time and valuable feedback!

Question 1: A direct evaluation of graph construction quality.

We conducted two rounds of manual annotation on a sample of 50 instances, with the following results:

Annotation itemRound 1 F1Round 2 F1Mean F1
Nodes49.66%62.65%56.16%
All edges31.51%43.24%37.38%

These results provide a direct quantitative evaluation of graph construction quality. As a complementary analysis, we also applied controlled perturbations of 0%, 10%, 25%, and 50% to the constructed graphs and repeatedly ran the propagation solver. All 20 runs converged, and we observed no flips in binary states. This result indicates that, within the tested perturbation range, the propagation process remains stable.

Question2: Ablations of two score

We further compared two alternative approaches: a Single-activity method that relies on a unified activity score, and a Simple-invalidation method that applies straightforward invalidation based on dependencies. Both baselines followed the same two-stage evaluation protocol as our main model across 200 DRM-SE scenarios, which included writing the true answer from QA1 back into the memory. The results are presented below:

Update StrategySource UpdateDerived UpdateOverall
Single activity61.50%45.50%53.50%
Simple invalidation74.00%50.50%62.25%
Full (Ours)81.50%51.00%66.25%

The Overall score represents the combined accuracy for both Source and Derived QA2 problems, with each approach evaluated on a total of 400 instances. As shown in the table, our comprehensive state update mechanism is crucial for accurately maintaining both direct source facts and derived dependencies, as simplified strategies fail to capture the full complexity of the updating process.

Question3: The cost evaluated with Qwen-Flash.

We further measured the paired inference costs of DUNE and BM25 RAG. Both methods were evaluated on the same 50 DRM-SE scenarios using the Qwen-Flash model, following the complete two-stage protocol (Session 1, QA1, writing back the ground-truth answer, appending Session 2, and QA2). Each method generated 200 responses (400 in total), with token usage recorded via the API, no Judge model was invoked during this cost measurement.

As shown in Table 1, while both methods require the same number of LLM calls per scenario, DUNE consumes approximately 3.16× more input tokens and 6.32× more output tokens under the native configuration. Notably, graph construction, reasoning, and index building are performed via local computation.

Table 1: Cost comparison between DUNE and BM25 RAG (averaged per scenario over two stages).

MetricDUNEBM25 RAG
LLM Calls44
Input Tokens11,149.763,524.76
Output Tokens683.86108.22
Graph/Index Build Time (s)0.0156010.000130
Two-stage Retrieval Time (s)0.0007060.000315
Total HTTP Request Time (s)17.91210.667
Peak Process RSS (MiB)1,736.08758.44
Reviewer_V82UOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates Derived Memory Maintenance, a problem in which updating a source fact may invalidate previously stored conclusions derived from it. To address this issue, The authors introduce DRM-bench, a collection of 3,200 two-session scenarios for evaluating derived memory maintenance across semantic, episodic, and procedural memory. They also propose DUNE (Derived memory Updating through Networked Evidence), which maps evidence to nodes and dependencies to edges, then propagates source updates over the resulting graph.

Critical strengths

The paper identifies a meaningful limitation of existing memory systems: updating a source fact does not necessarily invalidate previously stored conclusions derived from that fact. Formulating this problem as Derived Memory Maintenance is valuable, particularly for agents that continuously accumulate and reuse memories across interactions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The effectiveness of DUNE fundamentally depends on accurately identifying relationships among natural-language memories. However, the four relation types are primarily constructed using heuristic rules based on dependency parsing, normalized subject-predicate-object matching, lexical overlap, temporal ordering, and explicit discourse cues. DERIVED edges additionally rely on provenance recorded during answer generation.

These mechanisms may work for relatively structured statements and explicit dependencies, but it is unclear whether they can reliably capture the diverse, implicit, and context-dependent relationships commonly found in real-world conversations. For example, identifying a genuine contradiction or revision often requires understanding temporal context, conditional statements, implicit assumptions, and broader discourse semantics, which cannot be adequately addressed through simple syntactic or lexical rules. Consequently, it remains unclear whether the proposed graph can reliably represent the dependencies required for memory maintenance in realistic settings.

  1. All main experiments are conducted on DRM-bench, which is constructed by the authors using LLM-generated scenarios and predefined dependency and update patterns. Although the benchmark covers three memory categories, these categories share the same general data construction and evaluation framework.

This raises concerns about potential benchmark-specific bias. In particular, the dependency and update patterns used to construct DRM-bench may align closely with the structural assumptions and heuristic rules underlying DUNE. As a result, the reported improvements may partly reflect the method's effectiveness on the specific patterns represented in the benchmark rather than its ability to handle diverse, naturally occurring memory dependencies.

Questions for authors
  1. How well do the proposed relation extraction rules generalize to realistic, linguistically diverse conversations? In particular, how does the method handle implicit dependencies, context-dependent contradictions, and revisions expressed without explicit linguistic markers?

  2. Can DUNE maintain its performance on datasets independently constructed from DRM-bench?Since all main experiments are conducted on the authors' own synthetic benchmark, could the authors evaluate DUNE on an independently constructed dataset or realistic conversational memory scenarios?

3 comments

Thanks for your time and valuable feedback!

Question 1: Whether graph construction can reliably capture implicit dependencies in real-world conversations.

We conducted two rounds of manual annotation on a sample of 50 instances, with the following results:

Annotation itemRound 1 F1Round 2 F1Mean F1
Nodes49.66%62.65%56.16%
All edges31.51%43.24%37.38%

These results provide a direct quantitative evaluation of graph construction quality. As a complementary analysis, we also applied controlled perturbations of 0%, 10%, 25%, and 50% to the constructed graphs and repeatedly ran the propagation solver. All 20 runs converged, and we observed no flips in binary states. This result indicates that, within the tested perturbation range, the propagation process remains stable.

Meanwhile, the construction of the DRM-bench dataset draws upon various forms of implicit dependencies and contradictions in natural language, as mentioned in Line 174. Consequently, the results on DRM-bench inherently account for the challenge of handling such implicit dependencies.

Question2: More evaluation on other benchmarks.

We also added evaluations on belief_r, MEME, and MemoryAgentBench, which respectively cover static logical reasoning, memory update/deletion, and conflict resolution.

On belief_r, we follow its original static single-turn protocol, using only Session 1 without artificially adding QA1 write-back or Session 2. All seven methods use Qwen-Flash for answering and are scored offline by the same GLM-5.3 judge; each method is evaluated on 1,744 questions, with no errors during generation or scoring:

MethodDUNEMem0Hash RAGDense RAGBM25 RAGA-MEMLangMemLightMemPowerContext
Judge Accuracy56.77%29.53%36.75%36.93%36.75%37.04%37.04%37.04%36.75%

We also evaluated DUNE on MEME and MemoryAgentBench:

Benchmark TaskDUNE ResultBest Paper Baseline
MEME Cascade8.54%5%
MEME Deletion44.00%27%
MemoryAgentBench SF34.00%54%
Our experimental setup aligns with the default settings in the respective papers. DUNE significantly outperforms the previous best baselines on both MEME Cascade and Deletion tasks. On MemoryAgentBench, it ranks second, just behind the top baseline, HippoRAG v2. These results suggest that DUNE has partial capability for handling external updates.

Thank you for the response. The results presented in the first experiment suggest that there is still a considerable discrepancy between the graphs constructed by DUNE and those annotated by humans. Nevertheless, I consider these results reasonably acceptable given the limitations of heuristic rules based on dependency parsing, normalized subject-predicate-object matching, and lexical overlap.

However, as pointed out in my original review, unlike the highly structured and standardized data in database systems, information expressed in natural language is much less structured, more diverse, and often context-dependent. Identifying dependencies primarily through syntactic and structural patterns without sufficiently accounting for the underlying semantics is therefore unlikely to be reliable in realistic scenarios. Therefore, I maintain my original rating.

Reviewer_X5xfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses a long-context problem for agents, especially handling out-of-date facts and updated information. This paper considers the scenario where a single updated fact affects other facts subsequently and defines this problem as derived memory. The paper first introduces a new benchmark for it, DRM-bench, and proposes a solution, DUNE (Derived memory Updating through Networked Evidence).

Critical strengths

This paper addresses a timely and important problem in the agentic AI era. The reviewer thinks studies about agentic memory look important.

Critical weaknesses

(1) This paper should be compared with previous benchmark studies (e.g., MemoryAgentBench (ICLR'26), MEME (arxiv'26), and so on) that evaluate how agent models properly update their memory when facts are changing. In other words, the paper should provide a justification for why the new benchmark is needed for the community and what significant advantages it offers beyond the previous ones.

(2) The experiments should be strengthened with method ablations on the DUNE architecture. In the main result, DUNE has higher performance on avg src than the comparison methods (Mem0, LangMem, etc.). Why do the other memory systems (Mem0, LangMem, etc.) show low performance even on src? As the reviewer understands, DUNE is focusing on the derived memory scenario, thus, the reviewer wonders what in DUNE induces the performance improvements in the src scenario.

(3) The presentation could be improved. For example, the explanation of DRM-bench (lines 152–158) should be elaborated to help the reader understand it and be convinced. From the current presentation, it is difficult to imagine why this benchmark should look like this. I think it would be good to show some illustrations and examples, if needed. The explanation of the DUNE method is not logically well connected. In my view, a good paper that presents a benchmark & solution follows this flow: a good problem statement -> building a benchmark -> showing that existing methods do not work well -> a very simple solution to resolve it. Currently, the solution proposed in this paper looks a bit complicated, thus, the reviewer expected an appropriate explanation on the paper's design choices.

Questions for authors

Minor question: Did the authors use the same answer-generation backbone and alter the memory system for the comparison experiments?

3 comments

We thank the reviewer for your time and constructive feedback.

Question1: A justification for why the new benchmark is needed for the community

W1: DRM-Bench complements existing benchmarks by uniquely evaluating the update and maintenance of a model's self-generated memories. While MemoryAgentBench focuses on conflict resolution, and MEME further covers dependency update propagation, and deletion, DRM-Bench establishes a closed loop of “writing back the QA1 answer → updating the source → checking source facts and downstream QA2.” This design tests whether the system continues to rely on its own outdated generated answers, rather than just checking if it can access the latest facts. Thus, unlike other systems, DRM-Bench includes the step of writing back the model's own answers, better reflecting real-world scenarios where adding a memory system can sometimes lead to incorrect responses. We will clarify that in our revision.

We also included external evaluations:

Benchmark TaskDUNE ResultBest Paper Baseline
MEME Cascade8.54%5%
MEME Deletion44.00%27%
MemoryAgentBench SF34.00%54%

Our experimental setup aligns with the default settings in the respective papers. DUNE significantly outperforms the previous best baselines on both MEME Cascade and Deletion tasks. On MemoryAgentBench, it ranks second, just behind the top baseline, HippoRAG v2. These results demonstrate that DUNE possesses partial capabilities for handling external updates.

Question2: What in DUNE induces the performance improvements in the src scenario?

The stronger performance on Source questions can be attributed to three factors.

  1. Several baselines lack robust update capabilities. Among those with stronger updating, such as A-MEM, Source accuracy is comparable to DUNE.
  2. Mem0 was previously evaluated without enabling its inference-based update mode (infer=True). When we re-ran it with the official inference mode enabled, it achieved 84.07% on Source questions and 30.90% on Derived questions, indicating that its Source performance is also on par with DUNE.
  3. DUNE performs graph construction during memory extraction, which implicitly facilitates entity alignment and thereby enhances its effectiveness in memory updating.

Question:Improve presentation.

We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. Our underlying rationale is as follows: First, we observed that incorporating memory components can sometimes degrade response quality, because the system may retrieve and reuse its own previously written-back answers that have become outdated due to changes in facts or rules. Existing memory benchmarks mainly focus on information retrieval in long conversations or on updating directly mentioned facts, and rarely evaluate how updates affect downstream conclusions that were previously inferred and written back by the model. To address this gap, we designed DRM-Bench, which evaluates, through two-round interactions and QA1 gold-answer writeback, whether a system can update both source facts and their downstream memories after source information changes.

Guided by this rationale, we have reorganized the relevant parts of the paper and highlighted the revisions in blue in the revised manuscript: we added a motivation discussion in Section 3.2 (Line 161), together with concrete examples linked to Figure 1; we also adjusted the narrative flow of the Introduction to make the logical connection among the observed phenomenon, the limitations of existing benchmarks, and the design motivation of DRM-Bench clearer.

Minor question: The same answer-generation backbone?

Yes, we uniformly adopt qwen-flash as our answer-generation backbone.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
Area_Chair_V5XTOpenReview ↗

Discussion Window Closing in 2 days. Please Respond to the Author's Rebuttal!

Dear Reviewers,

The authors have thoughtfully responded to your reviews and the discussion window is coming to a close on November 18th. Please take a minute to engage with their response and discuss whether it changes your opinions.

Thank you for your time and effort!

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.