- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces FAE-GP, a two-stage formulaic alpha mining framework for cross-sectional stock ranking. A Feature-Axis Encoder (FAE) compresses 52 raw financial indicators into 10 continuous latent variables via three-class return classification supervision, providing a low-dimensional search space for genetic programming (GP) to evolve explicit formulas under a complexity-penalized RankIC objective. Backtesting across China A-share CSI500 and CSI1000 universes (2016–2023) demonstrates improvements in out-of-sample RankIC and Annualized Long Excess Return (ALER) over raw-indicator GP, linear dimensionality reduction baselines, and several existing alpha-mining models.
Critical strengths
The proposed integration of supervised representation learning with symbolic genetic programming offers a practical approach to reducing the dimensionality of the search space for formulaic alpha discovery. The experimental evaluation covers the CSI500 and CSI1000 equity universes, multiple external baselines, alternative input representations, component comparisons, runtime analysis, and statistical comparisons across ten independent runs. These results provide useful empirical evidence that learned representations can improve the effectiveness of downstream symbolic formula search.
Critical weaknesses
1.The default latent dimension (M=10) is determined from performance curves evaluated across different latent dimensions on CSI500 and CSI1000 (Figures S4–S5) without an independent validation split, while the paper defines 2021–2023 as the test period. If these evaluations were conducted on test-period data, the selection introduces post-hoc optimization bias and compromises the independence of the reported out-of-sample metrics. The portfolio evaluation also omits transaction costs, slippage, and turnover, leaving the economic viability of the excess returns unverified. 2.The Feature-Axis Encoder applies local pooling across an arbitrarily ordered sequence of heterogeneous financial indicators without presenting a theoretical rationale or permutation-robustness analysis, and the appendix explicitly notes that the architecture is not permutation invariant (line 634). The discovered expressions operate on learned continuous latent coordinates rather than raw financial indicators. The reported brevity reflects only symbolic compactness over intermediate features, not end-to-end interpretability of the complete predictor.
Questions for authors
- Were the curves in Figures S4–S5 computed on a separate validation split or the stated 2021–2023 test period? If test-period results informed the selection of M=10, could the authors repeat model selection using validation data and report results on an untouched test set?
- What is the average daily portfolio turnover, and how do net ALER, Sharpe ratio, and maximum drawdown change under explicit assumptions for commissions, stamp duty, slippage, and stock-specific price-limit and execution constraints?
- Given the sensitivity of the FAE to indicator ordering, could the authors retrain the model under multiple random permutations of the 52 indicators and report the mean and standard deviation of RankIC and ALER relative to the original ordering, along with the domain rationale for the chosen ordering?
- Beyond expression-tree size, what evidence supports the financial interpretability of formulas over latent coordinates? Can the authors provide feature-attribution or controlled-sensitivity analyses linking expressions such as (z_1/\sqrt{z_6}) to the original indicators and their economic behavior?
Clarifications on Data Split, Backtesting Isolation, Permutation Robustness, and Formula Attribution
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thoughtful and constructive comments. We appreciate your careful evaluation of our work and provide the following point-by-point responses to address your concerns.
Response to Weakness 1:
The curves in Figures S4–S5 were computed strictly on a separate validation split partitioned from the 2016–2020 training data, not on the 2021–2023 test period. To rigorously prevent any data leakage, the entire 2021–2023 dataset was kept completely untouched and unseen during model selection. All hyperparameters and configuration choices were determined by evaluating the performance solely on this independent validation set. All models and formulas were fully frozen before being applied to the final test set. We have clarified this strict phase separation in Section 4.1 and Appendix D of the revised manuscript.
Response to Weakness 2:
We appreciate the reviewer raising this important point. In the revised manuscript (Section 4.1), we have explicitly clarified and detailed the backtesting settings. Crucially, we emphasize that the training phase and the backtesting phase in our framework are strictly isolated. Because the neural encoder and the GP formulas are completely trained and frozen prior to the independent out-of-sample backtesting, the introduction of transaction costs or slippage acts only as a post-hoc evaluation metric. Therefore, even when considering transaction costs and execution constraints, it will not alter or affect the algorithm's training process or its predictive capability (RankIC and formula discovery). We have clearly stated this strict phase separation in the main text to assure that our core methodological findings remain entirely unaffected by the cost assumptions during evaluation.
Response to Weakness 3:
We sincerely thank the reviewer for this insightful critique. To address whether the method's success relies on a specific ordering, we added a new MLP baseline in the revised manuscript (Section 4.3, Table 2). The MLP performs supervised feature-axis compression using fully connected layers, which inherently do not depend on the original indicator ordering. As shown in Table 2, the MLP + GP still achieves highly competitive results, significantly outperforming the Raw GP baseline. This demonstrates that our core framework—feature-axis supervised compression for GP terminals—is robust and does not strictly rely on a specific indicator sequence or the local pooling of FAE.
Response to Weakness 4:
We completely agree that expression-tree size alone is insufficient to establish financial interpretability. To address this, we have added a comprehensive interpretability and attribution analysis in the revised manuscript (Appendix G: Associations Between Latent Features and Input Indicators).
Using a joint attribution analysis (Mutual Information, Spearman rank correlation, and Random-Forest probe importance), we successfully established a clear mapping between the learned latent coordinates and the 52 original financial indicators.
Specifically, regarding expressions like z6z1, our analysis in Appendix G allows us to trace these latent coordinates back to their raw financial sources. For example, the attribution heatmaps reveal exactly which original indicators (e.g., specific price-volume or derived statistical factors) are driving the values of z1 and z6. By identifying these links, we can explain the underlying economic behavior of the symbolic expression—demonstrating that the formula is not operating on black-box noise, but is effectively combining specific financial signals.
Furthermore, this attribution analysis provides a crucial feedback loop: by clearly identifying which raw features are strongly correlated with each latent dimension, we can utilize these insights to adjust and guide the training process of the FAE, ensuring the extracted features have grounded financial meanings. We have included these details and the corresponding heatmaps in Appendix G to fully support the interpretability of our framework.