- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper formulates financial factors as executable programs comprising an applicability predicate, a ranking formula, a fixed direction, and a forecast horizon. A symbolic generator searches for predicate–formula pairs using ranking quality evaluated on each predicate's support, subject to support-validity requirements.
Critical strengths
-
A clear formulation with a relevant mathematical motivation. Proposition 1 and the three-asset example explain why evaluating a formula on its actual comparison set can matter. Keeping predicate, formula, direction, and horizon together also makes the resulting object inspectable and its execution semantics explicit.
-
Careful controls and unusually transparent reporting. The study preserves formula directions, uses historical information availability, includes same-count support controls and cryptocurrency exposure-matched controls, and distinguishes reused periods from the preregistered extension. Reporting reversals and unsuccessful variants makes the evidence more interpretable and provides useful information about the limits of conditional factor discovery.
Critical weaknesses
-
The incremental value of joint discovery and the shared-state construction is not established. The mathematical argument motivates evaluating rankings on their support, but does not establish a benefit from jointly learning the predicate and formula. The directly relevant structure comparison in Appendix F.2, Table 16, favors two-stage discovery under the original conditional-quality objective: +0.170% full return and +3.217 percentage points over always-on, versus −0.536% and +1.225 points for joint discovery. Appendix F.3 also reports almost identical conditional increments for separate-state and shared-state construction (+1.19 versus +1.225 points). These are exploratory controls on a variant, so they do not establish that the main implementation is inferior
-
The independent evidence for a reliable applicability advantage remains limited. Section 4 explicitly states that 2024 U.S. outcomes entered development and that earlier cryptocurrency versions had already been evaluated on 2024 before the universe and features were expanded. In the later 2025 results, the U.S. within-support selection advantage is negative (Table 1), the U.S. matched-support ranking gain reverses, and the 20-day cryptocurrency spot-state program returns −0.07%, below the listed external methods (Table 4). Its +3.83-point improvement over its own always-on version is useful evidence, but does not by itself establish an advantage over alternative discovery methods. The uncertainty analysis in Appendix E.3 is welcome, yet most reported 2024 fixed-formula bootstrap intervals cross zero.
Questions for authors
Is there a comparison of the main joint method against two-stage predicate/formula discovery using the same grammar, source data, total candidate-evaluation budget, selection rule, and pool capacity?
Does adding the learned financial-state predicate provide a reliable benefit beyond the prespecified visibility clock under this control?
Which precise program-selection rules, predicates, and comparisons were frozen before the 2025 readout?
2 comments
Thank you for the clarifications. However, my main concerns remain. First, joint discovery shows greater expression diversity but no demonstrated performance advantage over two-stage discovery, which achieves better returns. Second, the learned state provides no robust out-of-sample benefit, with RankIC gains reversing in 2025 and clock-only outperforming clock plus state. These issues undermine the paper's central empirical claims, so I maintain my original rating.
Response to Reviewer jZkj: matched discovery and the scope of applicability evidence
Thank you for distinguishing the F.2/F.3 variants from the main method. We have added the requested comparison and clarified what each experiment answers.
Q1. Matched joint versus two-stage comparison. Yes. The main methods now share the grammar, source data, evaluation budget, selection rule and pool capacity:
Joint discovery explores a broader set of expressions; effective signal dimension is similar overall. Our public response to Reviewer adtv, Q3, explains why this supports retaining joint discovery while acknowledging the two-stage return advantage. Preserving exploration breadth while improving returns is the next objective (Section 5.4; Appendix H.3).
F.3 addresses a different choice: sharing the state between condition and score. Its similar returns make sharing a compact, inspectable representation, rather than an established source of economic advantage. The theory motivates support-aware evaluation and allows both joint and sequential discovery.
Q2. Does the state add reliable value beyond the clock? We added a use-time clock-only control that fixes formulas, directions and portfolio rules and removes only the state filter. Separately, industry/size/historical-risk/count-matched supports test local state information. H20 RankIC increments are:
The evidence identifies a local advantage in 2024 that does not persist in 2025. The no-hard-clock variant's 2024 gain also survives a larger minimum support. Portfolio increments beyond the clock depend on the funding/risk control. Finding a local relationship, establishing transfer and improving a portfolio are therefore distinct questions; our framework makes each testable, while stable superiority remains future work (Section 5.2; Appendix H.4).
Q3. What was frozen before 2025? Training ends in 2022; selection uses fixed rules on 2023. The original registry fixes:
All selected-pool hashes match the registry; no program was reselected using 2025 outcomes. Appendix H.9 and the code provide the precise rules. Later baseline additions, accounting correction and annual refits remain separately identified.