- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Horizon Extension via Self-edit Adaptation (HESA), a framework designed to extend the temporal horizon of pretrained video editing models. HESA constructs a short adaptation clip from consecutive frame groups sampled across the input video and trains LoRA parameters using the clip’s source-aligned edited latent as supervision, while keeping the pretrained backbone frozen. The reported results show improved source preservation and temporal alignment on long and dynamic videos without requiring additional training data.
Critical strengths
HESA addresses a practical limitation of pretrained video editing models: maintaining editing quality when processing videos substantially longer than those seen during training. Its self-edit adaptation strategy is straightforward and uses the model’s own edited short clip as supervision, without requiring additional training data.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty and insufficient differentiation from prior adaptation-based editing: Video-specific model adaptation has been explored in Tune-A-Video and Dreamix, while I2VEdit and LoRA-Edit further demonstrate LoRA-based adaptation for video editing. In particular, LoRA-Edit uses edited reference frames as supervision during fine-tuning, providing a relevant precedent for learning desired editing outcomes through model adaptation. Although HESA differs by using a self-generated adaptation clip to extend the temporal horizon, the methodological advance over these prior adaptation strategies is not sufficiently established. A more explicit comparison of the supervision targets, adaptation procedures, and how the learned edits transfer to other frames would help clarify the significance of the proposed contribution.
-
Insufficient experimental validation: The main evaluation is centered on extending VideoCoF, with an additional applicability study on LucyEdit, but does not establish how HESA compares with dedicated long-video editing approaches. Comparisons with methods such as AnchorSync and AdaFlow would be particularly informative, as they explicitly address long-range editing consistency through alternative mechanisms. In addition, the independent short-segment baseline illustrated in Fig. 1 should be evaluated quantitatively on the same test set, rather than only qualitatively. The evaluation is also limited to 24 videos and 72 video–prompt pairs. Broader validation on an existing long-video benchmark, such as LongV-EVAL, would strengthen the evidence. These comparisons should consider editing faithfulness, source preservation, temporal consistency, and end-to-end computational cost, including per-video adaptation.
Questions for authors
-
Temporal discontinuity in adaptation clip construction: The proposed grouping preserves local continuity within each group, but temporal jumps remain between groups, as acknowledged in Sec. 2.1. Could the authors clarify whether the VAE’s temporal receptive field spans these boundaries and how such discontinuities affect the encoded latents? While Table 4 compares downstream editing performance, a direct analysis of VAE reconstruction quality or boundary artifacts would help substantiate the proposed explanation for the benefit of consecutive grouping.
-
Generalization to different video lengths: Most experiments are conducted on 301-frame videos. Could the authors provide quantitative comparisons on videos of different lengths, such as approximately 100 frames and more than 500 frames, to demonstrate how the effectiveness of HESA varies with the temporal horizon?
-
Comparison with segment-wise short-clip editing: Could the authors provide a full-sequence quantitative comparison against the independent 33-frame segment-editing baseline illustrated in Fig. 1? The evaluation should assess the complete 301-frame videos reconstructed from the edited segments, including editing quality and consistency across segment boundaries. Please also clarify whether the 33-frame results in Table 2 correspond to this setting or to evaluation on short clips alone.
-
Computational overhead of per-video adaptation: HESA requires additional optimization for each input video, reportedly taking approximately 15 minutes on an NVIDIA B200 GPU. Could the authors provide an end-to-end runtime and memory comparison against existing approaches, including sequential short-clip editing, to better justify the practical benefits of the proposed adaptation strategy?